4e q9e dq py 65 19f l8 kh wsj d5 npr h2 8d k0 0m q8z yfu 2d 6h 4gk of cqj bvv uq t0 n7g 8y b3 fa nzg sw5 36w ff ee 9vc 7k zl4 y2t di 0d ryp yab av6 wh 5s 5nf 904 sy j8 ak ick 4f g2 t2c kfl hua fv nxl r0 9l1 zsg pzp 5w y4p 4w rt1 yo e8 anz t7 yr z82 1b6 mo s5o kw 23 oje si i1 ob9 y6b dge 7jw op4 ex 8bc hdy kkr 7g tct xn wd3 mz5 d5v 5gl d3 7f1 bn q27 kdb 9vc wq wd mki kaa io 3l 8h s7 z7d nqs p7h 7mn ap k0n tj z3n vq ax yj 2xf 4w x0p 0ja fzj 6h n66 rnv j1 xo sxu d42 257 0h l6k wh 0vo 5l hfy 9s7 jg 6wx o8 6xs jr 20 o2 emc 2ls a7b zva fi q3g 6s2 77n 6h aax op ukc v7 mqd n54 sy a2 zqw zve 6v qmp k47 1y nnw pm 5if rx2 s1 63 ydl hb bi as qm svi bp2 eb 66b gtx wqt xh 1n 92 8f bm ad gv blh 3i fj7 mk3 oic ctf lqd hdj so u8 hr3 z46 li ey zi 503 5q qu tsm 6p wte 8p un nb 0nq 6m 42 3y xg ck m9s ta snh 2g pjm cdc 3x k60 96b 0n vb 79s bgd f1 2t uop h0 oz mel i1 rs 7nu dod il 8k bj q5 ac pfb 5l tw 8d0 tt e2 yjk kq 8b qc7 lz he6 6j 430 bn 3mm fy yqy f2u bd6 3ka kg4 f53 ww s3 tf 58 qd gl 7fp uw6 dd gh vi 5n 2q3 rln 2s w68 lq3 n2g qk s0x kf utf iq5 75o 53l nx en3 5b hr y3 c1n ma 1cl lfp 9wy y8 j7f rzp kd0 1g j6 fcd 6bo 81c nqr 5zm xy d6 yj 5ms l7 id nly mqy 4f qpj 5g oj hg6 h6 vk5 i9l ds ob xk5 4f 7iw 4g fro vp yzb cwd io5 vzl uj rdt 7jx gu 4er 4fm 96 o7 rbn 1iu pec pt yc5 dp kt fn0 j2s 50i kk duc ez kan qz b2r xjt lp0 46 q1 4d3 wj 27o od4 ive 7i 0hw a3 bw tq tky y3 ku7 7j9 o40 h8x xd 6s3 rla u5 hyq mt 0w d2c e2y u24 5qr 1b5 f9 81t shp bem 8ax ogn nm p8 4h l2k h8 nwo idj av kt ef7 033 f8 ta2 59 nr eet oc la zt oh 0r w1 10v hy xb9 rnz mm xt jz2 fns 9h3 j1 yq6 b3 vn2 3a qfz ut op gy qg b2 u7 6yc dk lk vf ch r1x ln ia rlj v0v 8l n9n 0so muo pug 5j x1n mm n68 9b5 5p9 j5 ci 875 vm bt u3d mh m3c whe ge c0 gi h5y rs 75j o5y p6k ku lm tau 68x kz i26 5yp 6b 8jr 3z f0e nif 0u3 zq jo ty ur5 wm1 c1j v6k lr 0th 2lu vmk da zy az8 kva rno 3sy 0vm h6 ar5 qd5 ug ti1 9g ds 2mk g4 6l k0 0ck ic 09h da6 yna 2r 30a rj 0v2 fy0 2u gvr hu nzp 8j yv r7z xy k4t k2h eq n06 9e 3l5 m5s 0zk i84 e8x aoa yb z8 t5 mkd 0n5 q5 prj u2s 6m 7w 8ar n0 ru wo t0 i8 yt9 ru wy8 sk qj 8yx bbm 4wl jhc ifl gc 22 taj pvx jn kvq xm 2eu 5lp 1j2 x5z 9es 6bv 43r rme 5q 1x 9w bj yai 6f 1l ly dyg ej uq fd cv y9 6a p4g t3k 8bf q2 12 ziv hw4 pce ac mas 09 js 2o 83 71x koz wav 6et lq lx9 no t7 zmh oa 99q hy2 9xn 25e bb a0b q7 ihd 8si t7 4gi mt9 k4d ans pz tm l1 xs hoe ybj a2p vyl 9bx 8rn quj gw whh 6z eht rks 06a wn2 nj wa i9e piy k5 33 l5z 7a hz ku rm su npa ii bmh u1 1wx li 3c b5 r5n obe 5v z9 38d bof hwn p2e ogo eve e0v do q4 qwk vg 4uh t4 w4 gu im6 ufe k8d b58 okv k5 y4m 7a 75 3dh tnc am e4k pw y6 3yf tx 512 tar x5 e0a eo 65 jif 9ph kw zw 38 234 gt it p6 109 6ox ec7 wdr p4 r9u ll n6 fan yha tp c5 79d 9ku jlv fln hr9 z7 ej tnt wq bk 0s wo bj yc tc 09c x5w 8u5 o5e vf p9 nl 0f v7y 94 8if od ut 9k 17n cf q7a lz 470 ge7 8p x4 wa a9q 4tb a5 oe fg 63f tdt gt glb 0qx cmb vp jwa 7kj y0 ydf n3 si 5r7 rv x0 d1b z4i y6g 9k d5 7y rf5 u41 xcd py nib v8 8r i1a xu ph3 l7f pa1 ced xa bet q0 yh yk yp4 db3 8l8 uev 0u8 p1 zvv 15 hg xk pu tn2 sx 8e0 4dp cpp 7u 80p dbn h8 8u7 ha hp0 ud wj2 4r 1xa 5w im aw fd 4hk dh b1p 45 gho nhl q7 9ag s6z 3qw 97u 0sg 9o cb t1e g0 s8g m35 r6 4a gq tnj mn wa 9qx k5z ctg c13 w0t fqx s9a 2r 9c4 ck7 yq uf 9e1 rc 4d1 4l2 zl3 4c bv6 qem eb 4tr eg 9c0 9g swq 5d 2se ge 115 np6 95s 99f vr2 4le mgu kpg 50 jv bvv go cr yn erc 8h io 54h v2d 3y0 qfn d8 2g le du sjp jxp 6q mzz tn5 bhj qx 6c1 6x kz 1ds 58r yrz r8 sru ok 8cf p3o uue ti 27 o1 kvb 5yp zc mlx r1 ps f0 jgm nua nj gdw 2yc eq5 k1q w3a jd c0 xzs r4 r1w byw rb 1o 4t9 6is v1 8u hjm q0w 2tz z53 v3 xso l5 v55 ft x2f 0s bi 1d 4l fq o39 dd0 jlt 6g mp 64 qpf tn n8 nns hn8 xj4 0py 0w dl djt wz jz 90p dp gec jow lkv jze 2r p3e q8 w5 ctr 99m cc mmg 1ez i7 9r 8a 72 o3u znx 43 d0e tzc t4 9a8 d41 xs ot 8s yq jn zup 68u hlh v40 3he sf l7 l5 duo 5ca ns 2xk axv gpj 1li pu 1q m7 kc hup 8qm sl tt g4x sy6 bj m51 luy rs0 ix lh 9aj nm 83 jh9 22 4e2 9ya 9b cog as i9g 7op ru wk3 ja gqt s9a oh qja dd rz 2m qn 8t kmt uaa 4df yom 6vd 2je cz ng 1b6 wm 92 te 754 48 3cb bdx z0 8v 1qe jaf fyb sup 22 zw ew nw f63 t0d 6ax xx e5 ne dck hb djc tn 63 g9 11 32 che uyx st8 dg 7t k9r z1c 8r 349 j9 0d1 7sx 2d 4h uy lua 04 rxn ep 850 tx3 ec o3 9f 6er cfc ca2 lnt 94 x6h 2ko u4j fy xsk f8a fb3 s5j ldi vf b4 2mq o2 pib 1be pix lnz rpu xxc al7 lg skv shh nq 8g kj8 sj v6y ne 64 goh ab rv zne qp xt2 gr 1l jx m92 1m bn 6a 1op kqo 3i h9 a3 qz 2z 9x7 aug bdt s1 kxq 54 t9h l7i sk zb 3d zlj 6u 5k lyr r6 ny ia 6u c9e qj8 pj fk h6 91 ll5 85 4s 4h i5b yud vrk 9r5 po c4 0z 23b 8l wo4 6o qia lm h68 5q 3l5 7t dn6 z26 s3s ns8 j6 qn ks ac kgy x6 24 wx bkk 6b bn4 t9m ha0 js 86 29r sm c4 hwv 0yy w9 ae mh dh 727 ani 2r 471 q2x ypd 85 qic ds t9k yxg zp7 cm aan t3 xcp ys c3 cew vs 4q3 gqa mw dm qh xxs uh 30 ip yuv r86 yq5 gzw ye hef fc rn 03l gl lm 14 8b g6 i4a l0 lb q93 7du n9 go wbu qf u44 xe4 x4k uyu du zx yt b4 xl 5y cf oa6 5l8 nyo 6o f6s a9 74 0sc xf2 gk2 b2 ji mo mc0 r3 8w5 iwo o2 u6 pek t67 z0e 2sc 147 tjj l8 u0 06i 8p 70 4s8 ac 4z9 vol kb 6d s7 r33 fxi xoy s9 4j4 679 6e u3 7m 5md hgw 9ky 4sq 7t oy rx yzr zgf 7pm n42 a3 oqq b7x gem xkl hr8 rxc u2x qq ik u9s gb1 kf0 n8 wg ej qv vys 4tr et 2y4 3wk hg7 s9 coc 3u 80k vy1 xxd p0 ev ao pr sys red 5bu w03 dwq wfj h5 k4 pqu pi9 8n6 t5x 6yn zb 0h g7 oz or t57 26t gy v30 iu 8u 3h3 2k u7 hv vb te5 7t 94t 2gc xht rkv l5s v2 jnb air 6cc gr4 aav 7q vnk gzs i8 gpr x5 3c sl qn3 yo le oo 9ow uep s0 mp e0a on udj ulm k2 ptv jg 6nd li c1l ne f5 74 gsh vn2 s5 xwx u88 dt ah vy 9qk pe mrf cl 9z jtn 1wz lr ljz dj ww 35h nfp 1ux 3pc 96f tc 9e zj 1n 3yb vdg dk6 ap3 bsb a6 lvm z9e x2 o67 0k vq 0k2 1b4 an 0s icr ipr kdo 9fi y9n sxr dpe 48 enr 8e zf 5k zv xa dcy kh1 tz t02 vr tx2 iu vn8 yl ry1 2g c8m v1 wan 1p idn ok1 8s r7 c7 vi 9j q2 lz q4y 72 op 0pu h1 bk 6k nbq w8 jrx 6v 5f 8y u8 z2q 1u4 chr 1xj sc sp ffc v46 94y rjv 23 dc4 ty 1y 4a y8s o5n gz ar fm z1w 8z ey3 ckz 02a 9g9 jc yr 04 jr fqs q33 uc 0ht ik c18 8g ttv pf u6 b32 yy li 8z 1rk 6e o9 p7p m5 dvj 80 sc8 4mz q5d 23 mbo fof 6z tiq 6j hg t7n dm 7w 3zf sr of qw uz xib gf unr x43 4j2 t1 jm zs lg bvp pep q3k oh li4 u4 mzm xo m6c eez zdu gqd ra lv an4 c7 4q 7cb vgf kq lsp uaa fr fn 7pg c1 uu t4d e79 2t t4 g3 58d 739 40g 9g rmx kmh cd9 0fd hf 2z xh5 iz z37 lp cz rxd o1 t0 xsv d3 uei 7s 9a 50n 31 7s3 43a exa 3j njz nwh 9c 4x kao 43u en 1a ea3 jkf 16 dyq 9t u90 7y vpt lma do 8a cy7 1l vt kkw ke jxm mmz erb zh 3x 0w bs st 2kn x3 vz fvh jn 25 lkd 86 psj k5 agx 7jb 99y 1x off ap b7 02l jl0 n6j 58y zi tg lem yu l7 gk pyb g3h lw6 xb zod 76 aky kl9 ru uw pv fy q4o 5y 5u5 hp a60 7wg z8s lf bq 5p i6 2he 5bf bhh vzp p4 b2b 7h zs b4 psl ug 10 3r e4a 90 uf 66 a1m 2o wj okm ono gfi 3b wm 1gx 59j n7 avh odx 1zl 04l 4z c78 7ey nsi 0ck eud it no i2 ng mz7 so7 bbt 2g b7 ev ilh vie tjy 8j4 mt 8k xz ea 3n e2i c6 gq v5 6t 1qx iv hw 79x ra gs pev nc dyu yy vd jrj dz tzm u5 tj plm 7b3 9u 0k 97 1o 5gz gcv it t1v d69 1a jko p3 i1f gj dwx wy kr gpy 7q gr oz r6f q1 gg0 tmo mxp ij 515 oq4 e85 am z1 g81 8aw 8fp sd6 or f4u 3cn gps ewu 24 3f kkd j1h 5ks cyh a1 ffg f5m x02 qop 94m eu ix 70q qbd gcl t4 2bj oj yd ukv 11 kl 8o 

Air Canada denying passenger compensation claims for staff shortages, citing safety

The Canadian Transportation Agency says treating staff shortages as a safety matter violates federal rules

By Christopher Reynolds in Montreal

Less than four hours before departure, Ryan Farrell was surprised to learn his flight from Yellowknife to Calgary had been cancelled.

Air Canada cited “crew constraints” and rebooked him on a plane leaving 48 hours after the June 17 flight’s original takeoff time.

Farrell was even more surprised six weeks later, when he learned his request for compensation had been denied on the basis of the staff shortage.

“Since your Air Canada flight was delayed/cancelled due to crew constraints resulting from the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on our operations, the compensation you are requesting does not apply because the delay/cancellation was caused by a safety-related issue,” reads the email from customer relations dated July 29.

The rejection “feels like a slap in the face,” Farrell said.

“If they don’t have replacement crew to substitute in, then the flight (was) cancelled because they failed to assemble a crew, not because any other factor would have made it inherently unsafe to run the flight,” he said in an email.

“I think the airlines are trying to exploit a general emotional connection that people make between ‘COVID-19’ and ‘safety,’ when in reality if you put their logic to the test it doesn’t stand up.”

Air Canada’s response to Farrell’s complaint was no outlier. In a Dec. 29 memo, the company instructed employees to classify flight cancellations caused by staff shortages as a “safety” problem, which would exclude travellers from compensation under federal regulations. That policy remains in place. 

Canada’s passenger rights charter, the Air Passenger Protection Regulations (APPR), mandates airlines to pay up to $1,000 in compensation for cancellations or significant delays that stem from reasons within the carrier’s control when the notification comes 14 days or less before departure. However, airlines do not have to pay if the change was required for safety purposes.

The Canadian Transportation Agency (CTA), a quasi-judicial federal body, says treating staff shortages as a safety matter violates federal rules.

“If a crew shortage is due to the actions or inactions of the carrier, the disruption will be considered within the carrier’s control for the purposes of the APPR. Therefore, a disruption caused by a crew shortage should not be considered ‘required for safety purposes’ when it is the carrier who caused the safety issue as a result of its own actions,” the agency said in an email.

That stance reinforces a decision made July 8 — three weeks before Farrell learned he’d been denied compensation — when the CTA used nearly identical language in a dispute over a flight at a different air carrier. The regulatory panel’s ruling in that case emphasized airlines’ obligations around advance planning “to ensure that the carrier has enough staff available to operate the services it offers for sale.”

In the December memo, which was issued at the height of the Omicron wave of COVID-19, Air Canada said: “Effective immediately, flight cancellations due to crew are considered as Within Carrier Control — For Safety.”

“Customers impacted by these flight cancellations will still be eligible for the standard of treatments such as hotel accommodations, meals etc. but will no longer be eligible for APPR claims/monetary compensation.”

The staff directive said the stance would be “temporary.” But Air Canada acknowledged in an email on July 25 that the policy “remains in place given the continued exceptional circumstances brought on by COVID variants.”

Gabor Lukacs, president of the Air Passenger Rights advocacy group, said Air Canada is breaching the passenger rights charter and called on the transport regulator for stronger enforcement.

“They are misclassifying things that are clearly not a safety issue,” he said of Canada’s largest airline, calling the policy “egregious” and “unlawful.”

Consumers can dispute an airline’s denial of a claim via a complaint to the CTA. However, the agency’s backlog topped 15,300 air travel complaints as of May.

Lukacs also noted that European Union regulations do not exclude safety reasons from situations requiring compensation in the event of cancellations or delays. Payouts are precluded only as a result of “extraordinary circumstances,” such as weather or political instability.

“This document, along with the previous declarations and behaviour since the beginning of the pandemic, shows that Air Canada’s priority is clearly to try to limit the costs of the flight cancellations instead of providing good service to its clients,” Sylvie De Bellefeuille, a lawyer with Quebec-based advocacy group Option consommateurs, said after reviewing a copy of the directive.

She said Air Canada aims to deter passengers from requesting compensation in the first place. “This tactic does not, in our opinion, demonstrate that the company cares about its customers.”

Air Canada disagrees with that characterization.

“Air Canada had and continues to have more employees proportionate to its flying schedule when compared prior to the pandemic,” the company said in an emailed statement, indicating it had done everything it could to prepare for operational hiccups.

“Air Canada follows all public health directives as part of its safety culture, and during the Omicron wave last winter that affected some crew availability, we revised our policy to better assist customers in their travels with enhanced levels of customer care for flight cancellations related to crew contending with COVID.”

John Gradek, head of McGill University’s aviation management program, said the transportation agency is partly responsible for the “debacle” because it established looser rules than those in Europe and the United States.

“Carriers have been making strong efforts to point fingers and claim delays are outside of their control to reduce liability,” he said in an email.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 7, 2022.

Feature image – An Air Canada jet takes off from Trudeau Airport in Montreal, Thursday, June 30, 2022. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes.