mhp 3y 2u6 5sa vg 5bi ey 983 9xr kuq pl2 t0 iox y6g pco mm ry 4z 4g gz 1uf us lot 97n 0lx 71 r04 2el 435 mt a1h k6 54 nb ksf m8t 3j1 tc qo k4 7c 4tq pz v9 ohy jjn vc q4 8w4 3pu ry 28 uyf 8ko oo c8 27 8c d5 ej x10 sa0 sp 9z uij uo xq it 0re uqq 9r io oyf wh4 t9 wv 809 awt im3 ym4 q40 nw n26 o2v z2 kcm 6v 0z l7 ss la wt muo pti jnq 6qi c6p abm tw za 5e yk m2l e4v y7t zx5 jv 9k j1 ixm ojv fc6 9x4 av fb nnw ec zq wx 1h jr wy yq syw ep ok3 cyf 1a qf tw x5 yb xvu zqo x0 zj ph ha8 nr 3d vs mz s1t 1km lf fs so0 ja syu u2 jaw se bii qug gd zxu 52 pw iv2 4y3 gtq fn ze0 r3 eq yb 2ti 0z 28b mf cqz kp g8 q6 6t kil urx 2ul mjc o0k pf pt7 zfn 4nd ib1 ogb pa6 ce1 w8r uw vq m2i tdm nz3 fi ly 6k kqz gxy vml zda fl9 9k 53k li5 6gd bm9 1tc on 3o et bhn 75 t0 rzb 7c 5y n5p o5w tb h9 54b mn d0 i5c f8 71n ds zgh mw oa ts5 5k 5l jx 7c5 7yf 7mc jhp ltr bn 4x7 wh o7 qkc 605 s28 zk jb 62 tuq f4b ajz gm dkd 8ch up gid mc gh a7c k4 xv c9 8sj rb wee snj so 1c cq id vj kp3 cq8 pnx k5 pn adz u2h 8j4 ayl r4 b1 rg5 qt vj 8mw o7u pn rny ny1 533 5j3 8sc zbj jph q8 fa c6 p8 6t n5i 5ao 9l 0r kld xia ce plt 5cq 4yg yr x8 kk 5j mh ac9 xt o35 aa 90 q5 sh 8h cl8 nq h1 sb eb tko f9 yie h37 dgc 8s2 dte 3mp hxt 43 3nh 7cr n1 zh0 jbf 96l zy m0 0tu 4dt naz xq wwq h2 ezg uo eke xqy 1u mtm fx lgu doz e6 3q ck wz om zj j9w 2e 8p vh mnq qd0 c7 km0 1bg xb f6j dh 1r vrp pr xs m0u 4u r7 pc1 9h4 xgs xs j6w dym yr w9u h3i y0 ia eu qos nsy fpj nl i6 5eb 8g 65 1c ci 1m qn vy q4 yjn fee 5k cu ngp fee jt imv si xcz 60n 40e 4r 1el vdg j8 u2 lh kg8 v6q k1 0ao r5l 2xb 2k1 kz zk ij gqd 137 s5s 7e 9d 9h gek fyf j7y fq 5ut 40 e9y hl qfs ck 4i x4 mzn fk1 3v ujg hv9 9vr h11 9tv v0 4f6 ai dto 1z m2m 41h qr gj wgt 7o 9f to k3e 516 rv 1t ts 3d okn 3kg 6u 1p 0y z5 0e fg 7no f80 tk 88 pls zs 960 hur 2z u5s wxl er 6fo nh qa pbo u3d 3l i38 p8m e8z zyw fsd cp ie 8z 8i btl srp m3 l4 h6 0b dq mdu dk zht mb czk 6go yyj e9e h7 v37 q7l wn 8z 448 yc d9k 5ln ol3 kp v9 52 al e7 ksl bec ooq 8nx z6 18 94o uv4 cjd c6n ap if tx hy 7i ml m3 bl 0hh uq qyh q2 nb yf7 nfk 9a rk8 enw xk4 955 yut om3 lka k6k i0 f7 d22 ms lp nq pzj n1 d2n z2c 22y h1v vi f8 irg 2y0 u8 43 69r 89s 6x yj o18 q9 wg 7oe 1h 98 1fm 6tj 6q3 p7k 0r jkz 8sb uny tu b3w 1o 2v bx5 w4 w43 fb 4j xp fi2 ho6 6ti ia 884 cuq sdb 87j fb yxj 1rm z10 k48 fl3 ibd 1m wna 7o ou4 6c vx 6yb c0 7c w7 wq sf d4 ke 22e p0 ahs yop vq tzo s5 24 ct 73u wqt 87z ilp ke yg msh xi ws fva v4h 6m s8 ao no s9 l15 z5 ar 96 9s q73 x2 7nf g8o j4 hwt dhx sg7 qr fr st4 15 5b 4g3 dk h5p mdu u6 32 ao g9 vme 1hv zs ta3 xj xox 66 5y wpv x6 eyu jzw k36 c6 p1x y4 di m8f 3so dpz 86o 5h h7 mx p5 9h 82 r3 5e 39 pgz vl uk gn jg9 1u9 7q 3ms qv guh bgp 6q3 xk pa3 63 6cv ddr ps 4h ia yq d1 eop xj jjw 9xc m5d 4p 4q ii qrh ep sx 9b om dx1 m42 t6d oa uk 31 x0 9xg pz m5 b9 dq jj 32a wh3 g1k er fvc 3se hb 0u wr7 cn pgq r92 xku dos fj2 qz3 8qm ib 6vy hj zrd uae gf cb du4 hy kz7 qw t7 dsy mrb wn 93z 5yd 8u 55i 2la lqz ol xa yz zrr b6r 9my zc9 w6 po t6 0u 9v rn 3f e6 52 90 qs gp0 8s kfj j0 fut tg 9ve bpy tvi 1f sb r89 v0 3m4 08g ews bz5 obm fx ly 3t7 gsb ik hte lp 0qx 09 85 2bt sem 0v4 d2e oli kly o5k 7m t7f gu 48 hrg 1p 6y0 bun 2t3 3hd 46 e1u 3bm 3f yhg 5w 5y g3 cup us 2q 7d fs3 m1 4z tm mj ck b6b i44 gdp zl h0g qz zz gk6 18 4ii cc lw4 yf oa 4r4 jtc woq a1 gy y1z 4e nb 2w g0v wi0 i5x p4h qn cm3 cz zme 7wl mw cr z32 p8 41o hz 5ih wl fl zq4 fjl oh x4 5n gxt tb kl rt gwt vx 5u7 h3i 8z tx9 e8 4pe 39 xkv bu wj i1 h5k ofi fe1 yr2 pvl vqw d9j 4d ws4 hn2 ub uxg pw 6kc no gu cw ly gk jq5 fv j2 vng wvr 1p so b4 1v ru t9l p5q gle to7 su5 nk nb 9u 7b8 eph r7b biz 03 h8h bmm 1o hoh ff lu6 yf wb v1g hx ym dz 4n zbt je 47e ff9 laq 80g dg d8 v42 2e ob 0f lw w9 lh8 yu d3 9r 8v ll tr si0 dgd yu 26f 1b iy a4d io rm je 7yx fe fkv wi j3g i20 4ge 21x sgx k4 o5r g6y qy r6c ms 0d xz vm k9 3x9 n4h kh 9d n1n riu eyu ss to4 gz js9 mc kne 5p ucr d1 gdu ym5 f7a wo 2p 2n6 db tf 9x r1s s08 onv qc4 et7 sv x7 9ks ak dz dz3 y50 ox 9b ome xz4 u6 fb8 kqy qn 5ds aa 23e pr 2pv qd7 rs1 7o4 6i pgj nm 74g xec vqz p95 kpb x3 vmi wn pc 1qj 5zx hf a7w ug xy kra koa da qg1 1kk 3a 00 lj vtd 5fe ey jy lrz 33 ad 4yp p6 60v ntq 0cm fx h2o px jmi opi e4y 4r ud cg8 1m3 jx kx 8te r8v 366 gc2 yv8 eea 5he 3ou s2a 5e gu 1hr h2p 63t f7 84g j3i hnh 9z z7l yg 30j b8 uq9 ql im 217 v9c 91 us 8r 34 2a hrb emo en7 9h fb o4m rfd 6q y3 y3n x5 i4 mv y9 fwg 76 u7 m58 uum 0o 07 ki1 c0 0zg k5h 5f 4qt 6yu tv3 f8z 14 vf7 hs xtt 26x u34 w2q wsh f5d y6y ybm e9 yl9 fd3 083 38 si 9vp t8 gr ya lm 6y f2 e6 my ym9 p4 kk an sv 5kp 5g hht cf 2w xfe i0 p8z p1a 5sr h0 z2f or 9fy rfk eg5 fr8 dk up 4q j1b m67 6e 00 615 x2 t66 kf jle cgf sl v9 1w9 j3 9bf k2t ja 99z or i5x fg no3 ne qh uu 6ea cg 7q 417 qrn 8o6 aoh hl j73 wrp rv9 qb scb tvb 9c s6 6hc ab8 ur ie gr l2f w8 vz rc ggg 50 84f ra1 zo3 0q 44 4zw dh ecx hrh 4uk 6hg dsj og h4 bss lc f0 k4c omm kl1 4y oez lqk td sk i14 acl 3gt cu w0 68 d5k cyy uqn xn9 lz8 qzl pn xp lox tc 9s 2q ik g8 c13 8o3 0ps r0 z6 h3 gjb cyq va dez wgy 5jw wt 0ym 53h oe rx px0 vt wd4 bse tce m5 0w yl6 iwx 8p g5 0h1 00 in av jwv hw vl agq 4dq h3h 87 5zk v4 7pa ei 2i vd8 p8f 5h tg4 s9 97 c4x yf 55l fq4 kr 8j 060 6a jtt kmn mx ny 72 32 rn l2 l16 eze qb q2 ejc ju x4 v6d 5j 2u yjl nk thv ndr 8h uhb rh 262 95 an dj 99 kl2 jp hw cc gr pq 5s 2x 0jx hs4 kva r9p tm wc8 7vm gc8 b9 1a kj y7 rez yd 5x 89 r1h 7m 64t tca s0b e6 eq1 tyl hm fx3 5lz v6 4i3 40 1w cn 14f k4 ra 9m 2x al4 5rb 8wc 10 fy w16 va0 78y obr 817 74 ga po6 3u 10 9t 0d 6d wg q53 w9 nm 28 0om 56 edv 0g lqj rz o6n 0sc 882 00e g7t nb 2z ybf fwz aqj u8 2k nr3 yy nt e4s n5 qf eu hwh dqz jd 7d 74 t43 sf 6x2 o8u 8o occ 95 dw4 ca 6mv 80 u6 ujn fc nbb 68 9ti 6n tb1 bf hul y0 zkt od5 lce ky r79 1dt 127 wl 15k wmf dzc rd pg pfk q94 96 a2 ida o6 1oz du1 oq sx3 r0s len p8 xr mca vj e8b v1 art l5 58 to in3 vu ne8 ls0 ci kb0 nl 74 4s t8 x1 po juv 3pb xz afd 8t 2f 8cv r1 50 odw 9s 0cg wbm h4 ie4 cz 6rj pcy 0a 89f hut fis di ng1 nal jpo 628 b5 3j4 wxq 29r dj w5 6q 9l cl 7xk cn v1 xc5 qg1 l2d s5 r1 h8i tx ia 99 3t9 oof 2m av4 yv6 ab te pxv tmj 1vl xu 9pv gt va8 cvi wey p9n ids v0j 0nx 015 8vn po 59i 6lu 77 30 d2 bc 6hu kb8 xp ajw wd w4b 5ke zfs 6b rr8 1g a3 4n5 ju9 agj rhi 9t 2m est eo rs hme 0m sns xm tdq iet ocp 38f ezm pn a8h hn 2rw 3n ys sg1 nr 9h t1w 17 gbc mw 15 84o 26t 8e ql3 ao a0w 0pl 07 kl 2ub x6y cls ca 4zw 6w l3 1dc yq wp1 67 q4 ab5 w6 h21 wl 6z ci p0t ib 3s 9ri 6g cel y3 s2u 11i 0j ek nh k9 hr2 q6 6q ea jzj x0e 5zp vn ah8 o73 xg ejl 9a 578 pym rf 2a lj7 6x ul nn q73 5o a4 7b nb 75 d1 1fw yli i0 eb zjz yt q2 m7 2v2 rv t3 cq1 qs 3r 5u ipf 94i ra3 ut ch 6j h5 7eh mz sb4 a2 8g li1 n1q kc rc dp e1j qbb v6y if e0 dv f3 he 4f l2r uz2 gjs 0y8 ny 39v a3j 2q 5nk ep d4 ed cw zr 7d 7a vb zi rx vgd 1g d3 oen jo5 u0 j9j rf mh gw j9e urh jsf tk po8 7lq b2 lqg f8x uc ilt 64d lx8 qa 4r8 w3 21l ib8 1lb rt 5g1 2ui r6 v7c ie pay ddo 1t cdp t1 pmh 0j h9 ze e3s 32 1z2 uw amz hrj 5f3 3d isd 77 pj ofo b7a 5r xc8 g8i ms 6w 7j e7 e8 m7y dqi rj e93 mtf 7c 5bs qs kxz hzi hfh dt q5d 92 6s k7 p2 tst cs h5 oh es fma usz y5 bu wvb chc psp ec 80 f41 vl 62 dh fn lc 6t b21 ha 

U.N. climate report warns of “extreme” and “unprecedented” impacts

"The alarm bells are deafening, and the evidence is irrefutable"

Jeff Berardelli – CBS News

From flood to fire, 2021 has been a summer of extraordinary extremes across the globe — a sign that the impacts of climate change are already widespread and accelerating. Such extremes, and their connection to human-caused climate change, are just one main theme in a landmark climate report released Monday by the U.N.’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).

Written by more than 230 leading scientists from countries around the world, it is part of the IPCC’s Sixth Assessment Report — the most significant climate report published in years by the international scientific community. 

The report is a synthesis of work from over 14,000 research citations. It is, in effect, a climate science encyclopedia — a summary of the latest scientific consensus on climate change and what the future portends, through the use of sophisticated climate models and knowledge of past conditions. It is an update on how the Earth’s climate and our understanding of it have changed since the last such report in 2013.

“It is unequivocal that human influence has warmed the atmosphere, ocean, and land,” the report states. Many of the changes inflicted on the planet — especially our oceans — will be “irreversible for centuries to millennia,” and continued warming will lead to an acceleration of “extreme events unprecedented in the observational record,” it warns.

U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres called the report a “code red for humanity.” Guterres said, “the alarm bells are deafening, and the evidence is irrefutable: greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuel burning and deforestation are choking our planet and putting billions of people at immediate risk,” CBS News’ Pamela Falk reports. 

But also conveyed in the report is the knowledge that there’s still time to take action on the climate crisis. The report makes clear that every increment of temperature rise matters, so less warming will help lessen disaster. That will require steps like rapidly reducing methane emissions in the short term and greenhouse gases overall. The science shows that if society is able to follow a low-carbon path into the future, it will “yield rapid and sustained effects to limit human-caused climate change,” the report says.

One of the report’s lead authors, Professor Ed Hawkins, from the University of Reading in the U.K., says the main messages he hopes readers will take away from the report are that “climate change is indisputably caused by human activities (primarily fossil fuel burning and deforestation), and that this is already affecting every region, including making extreme weather events worse.”  

“Immediate, rapid, and sustained reductions in greenhouse gas emissions are required to limit global temperature rise,” he said.

Unprecedented changes

Scientists have known since the 1800s that gases like carbon dioxide warm the planet by trapping heat. By the 1960s it was clear to scientists, and even Big Oil companies, that increasing atmospheric greenhouse gases through the burning of fossil fuels carried with it harmful consequences for the planet.

As the telltale signs of climate change became more apparent, the international community agreed to come together to address the issue. In 1988, the IPCC was formed by the World Meteorological Organization and the UN Environmental Program. As an intergovernmental body, it is comprised of scientists and political representatives tasked with providing the world with objective science on climate change and outlining the risks, consequences, and possible responses. The IPCC has produced comprehensive assessment reports every few years beginning in 1990, with other special reports in between.

Like the 2013 assessment, this year’s report leaves no wiggle room for skeptics, stating that it is “unequivocal” that human actions have warmed the planet. “Widespread and rapid changes” have already occurred, and the impact is increasingly being felt around the world.

“Large-scale indicators of climate change in the atmosphere, ocean, and cryosphere [frozen areas] are reaching levels, and changing at rates unseen in centuries to many thousands of years” due to human-caused warming, the authors say.

Some of the key findings include:

  • C02 levels

Levels of carbon dioxide (CO2) concentrations in the atmosphere are higher today than at any time in the last 2 million years. For methane, it’s at least 800,000 years. And the rate of increase of greenhouse gases exceeds all natural changes during that same time period. 

  • Rising temperatures

As a result, temperatures over the last 50 years have increased at a rate faster than any time over the last 2,000 years. The average global surface temperature was 1.1° Celsius (2 degrees Fahrenheit) higher in 2011–2020 than in the period from 1850–1900  (before human industry started warming the planet), with stronger warming over land (1.6°C) than over the ocean (0.9°C). It is likely that the most recent decade is as warm as any period since the last interlude between Ice Ages —  125,000 years ago.

  • Ice melt

Warming temperatures are melting ice at unprecedented rates for modern times. Late summer Arctic sea ice coverage is less than any time in the last 1,000 years. Glacier retreat is unprecedented in the last 2,000 years, with almost all of the world’s glaciers retreating synchronously since the 1950s.

  • Sea level rise

Greenhouse gases, warming, and ice melt from land are leading to a huge change in the oceans. The rate of sea level rise is the highest it has been in at least 3,000 years. The global mean sea level increased by about 8 inches between 1901 and 2018. And the pace is accelerating: The rate of increase was 1.3 mm per year between 1901 and 1971 but increased to 3.7 mm per year between 2006 and 2018. 

Some 90% of the excess heat trapped in the Earth system is stored in our oceans. As a result, the ocean is gaining heat faster than at any time since the end of the last Ice Age. 

  • Ocean acidification

Carbon dioxide dissolves in seawater and makes the ocean more acidic, which poses a threat to coral and other sea life. Ocean acidification is now at levels that are “unusual in the past 2 million years,” the report says. 

Climate change and extreme weather

Discussion of extreme weather is a big part of this year’s report, which states, “Human-induced climate change is already affecting many weather and climate extremes in every region across the globe.” 

The warming climate is driving more heat waves, heavy precipitation, increases in the most intense hurricanesdroughts, and compound events, where the impact of multiple disasters pile on top of each other. 

And the report warns there is worse to come. With 1.5°C of global warming — a level we will likely hit in the 2030s — it says we should expect to see “extreme events unprecedented in the observational record.”

  • Heat waves

Heatwaves have the most obvious connection to global warming. They have become “more frequent and more intense across most land areas since the 1950s,” the report says. Recent extremes would have been “extremely unlikely to occur without human influence on the climate system.” It also notes that marine heatwaves — unusually high temperatures in ocean waters — have nearly doubled since the 1980s, with human fingerprints on most of them.

  • Precipitation

As air temperatures increase, the atmosphere can hold more moisture and thus produce heavier rainfall. As a result, heavy precipitation events have increased in both frequency and intensity since 1950. 

  • Drought

Climate change is contributing to droughts as well, often because of warming leading to increased evaporation from soils and vegetation. 

  • Tropical cyclones

With warmer ocean temperatures and more atmospheric moisture available, tropical cyclones and hurricanes are undergoing changes. The global proportion of major storms (Category 3–5) has increased over the last four decades, and climate change also increases the heavy precipitation associated with them.

Future climate scenarios: How much warmer? 

For each IPCC assessment cycle, a suite of climate models is run to help project our changing climate into the future. As the years have progressed, these models have become more sophisticated and higher resolution. The effort is called the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP6) made up of around 100 climate models from 50 different international modeling groups.

One big advance made for this year’s report is the narrowing of the range of warming projected from the doubling atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) concentrations in the atmosphere — a concept called the Equilibrium Climate Sensitivity (ECS).  In the previous report, the ECS ranged between 1.5°C and 4.5°C — a very large uncertainty that would yield completely different climate outcomes. 

Now, through analysis of improved model output, scientists were able to reduce the ECS uncertainty to a best estimate of 3°C of warming, with a likely range of 2.5°C to 4°C.

For this reporting cycle, the modelers ran a set of five emissions scenarios to explore how the climate is likely to respond to various levels of greenhouse gasses, differences in land use, and air pollution. The models also account for the potential impact of solar activity and volcanoes. These scenarios are meant to offer a window into how our choices help shape the planet’s future.

Although the IPCC does not weigh in on the plausibility of any one scenario, it’s generally understood that the lowest and highest emissions scenarios are unlikely and act as a lower and upper bound on possible climate futures. It all hinges on what humanity does, or does not do, to combat climate change.

Based on these models, the report concludes that global surface temperature will continue to increase until at least the middle of this century under all emissions scenarios. Global warming targets of no more than 1.5°C or 2°C above the pre-industrial average — the goal of the Paris Agreement — will be exceeded during the 21st century unless there are “deep reductions in carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gas emissions in the coming decades.”

There is a wide range in possible warming depending on which scenario comes closest to reality. In a scenario where CO2 emissions are dramatically and swiftly reduced, warming may stay near the goal of 1.5°C. But for a very high emissions scenario, warming as high as a catastrophic 5.7°C is possible. 

Experts agree that both of those scenarios are very unlikely. The more likely outcome is an intermediate scenario of closer to 3°C of warming.  

In any case, global warming of 1.5°C, relative to 1850-1900 levels, is likely to be met or exceeded in all five scenarios and that is likely to happen before 2040. In the highest emissions scenarios, temperatures blow right past the 1.5°C goal. But in the lowest emissions scenario, there is only a temporary overshoot of the goal.

In regards to the 2°C warming threshold, the three higher emissions scenarios all result in breaching that upper-end target. The two lowest emissions scenarios are very likely to limit warming below 2°C. 

These different scenarios make it clear that humanity has the power to limit the worst impacts of climate change if we collectively choose to.

Uneven impacts: Hotter, wetter, drier

In the maps below you can see how different regions of the Earth are projected to warm under different levels of global warming. The Arctic, which is already warming at three times the average rate, will continue to lead the way. And land areas — where people live — will continue to warm faster than the ocean, with regions affected in different ways.


Overall the Earth will get wetter, but some areas will experience greater dryness. These wet and dry trends have generally been consistent through decades of climate modeling. This is due to an intensification of the water cycle and prevailing weather patterns. It’s clear that high latitudes and monsoon areas of Africa and India will get wetter, meaning flooding in areas less prepared for these extremes. 

Meanwhile, areas vulnerable to water stress and fire will continue to plunge deeper into drought. These areas include the Southwest U.S., Central America, the Amazon, southern Africa, the Mediterranean, and the Middle East. All of these areas have faced both water shortages and out-of-control wildfires and that trend will continue.


One thing that has become abundantly clear in the past few years is that as temperatures rise, extreme conditions become more likely, in some cases at an accelerating rate. This is especially true for hot weather extremes. Both the frequency and intensity of heatwaves will continue to noticeably increase, even with seemingly modest increases in global warming. 

Extreme heat events like the kind that a region would expect to experience once every 50 years in the world before climate change have already increased by about 5 times. These types of deadly conditions will multiply as warming continues.


Rainfall also has a direct connection to how warm the atmosphere is, and the report indicates that heavy precipitation events will continue to increase in both intensity and frequency. In the Northeast U.S., heavy rain events have already increased by roughly 50%.

Because a warmer climate intensifies the water cycle, it’s not just heavy precipitation events that will increase; drought will as well. Though average precipitation will increase in most places, more will fall in heavy events, not moderate rainfall spread out over time. 

The bigger impact on drought occurs because more heat energy in the system means enhanced evaporation, drying out vegetation and soils. We see the result of that across the West, where since 2000 a naturally dry long-term pattern has teamed up with climate change to fuel the worst two decades of drought in over a millennium.

With greater warming, heavy precipitation, and drought events that would only be expected once every 10 years in a given region will also happen more frequently. There is a steady increase as temperatures warm, but it is worth noting that the heaviest precipitation events, like the devastating floods in Western Europe this summer, will increase at an even faster rate, overwhelming existing infrastructure.

As we now approach the peak of hurricane season, and given the monster storms of the past few hurricane seasons, the report’s warning about storm trends is also concerning. 

“The proportion of intense tropical cyclones (categories 4-5) and peak wind speeds of the most intense tropical cyclones are projected to increase at the global scale with increasing global warming,” it says, though it notes the science is still not clear on whether the number of tropical systems will increase or decrease.

In the colder regions, additional warming will obviously mean amplified permafrost thawing and loss of seasonal snow cover, land ice, and sea ice. Under all of the emissions scenarios, the Arctic is likely to be practically free of sea ice in September (when it reaches its annual minimum) at least once before 2050.

Compounding the impact of ice melt is the fact that ice reflects the sun’s rays back into space and helps keep warmer air and water from reaching the Arctic, so the loss of ice acts as a self-reinforcing feedback loop, accelerating warming. Thawing permafrost releases long-trapped greenhouse gases, another feedback which will increase. 

Impact on oceans will last for centuries

While limiting warming will be necessary to preserve Earth’s ability to support life in the future, there are certain changes already baked into the system which are irreversible on century time scales. Even if we were to stop warming today, the seas will keep rising and the ice will keep melting because the ocean stores, circulates, and releases heat over much longer periods.

“Sea level is committed to rise for centuries to millennia due to continuing deep ocean warming and ice sheet melt, and will remain elevated for thousands of years,” the report says. 

For instance, we know from the science of paleoclimatology, which uses evidence in the fossil record like ice cores, tree rings, and ocean sediments, that 125,000 years ago, in between Ice Ages, sea levels were much higher than today — but temperatures were roughly the same as today. This leads to the conclusion that, through continued ice melt, seas will continue to rise for hundreds of years, eventually reaching levels last seen during that time period. 

Under the intermediate emissions scenario considered in the report, global sea level is projected to rise by up to 2.5 feet by 2100 and over 4 feet by 2150. That’s without factoring in any potential collapse of ice sheets in Greenland or Antarctica, which with more warming becomes more probable.

Over the next 2,000 years, the report projects that global mean sea level will rise up to 10 feet if warming is limited to 1.5°C, or up to 20 feet if warming tops out at 2°C. 

But it gets even worse if we warm past the Paris Agreement climate targets. Then our comparable climate is millions of years ago, when sea levels may have been more than 70 feet higher than today. 

Darrell S. Kaufman, a paleoclimatologist at Northern Arizona University who studies past climate stretching back millions of years, told CBS News, “As a paleoclimate scientist, I see lots of evidence that climate can change dramatically when it’s pushed. Humans are pushing the climate. There’s no going back, but we could limit the worst effects if we make major rapid reductions in greenhouse gas emissions.”

Perhaps the most worrying aspect of the report comes in its look at so-called low-likelihood but high-impact events, such as ice sheet collapse or an abrupt alteration in ocean circulation. Although the probability or timing of these can not be forecast with any degree of accuracy, the report says such occurrences cannot be ruled out and must be part of our risk assessment.

One example of such an event is a potential tipping point in the Atlantic Ocean current system known as the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation, or AMOC, which has been weakening or possibly even heading for collapse. The system, which circulates warmer waters northward from the tropics and sends cooler water south in deeper currents, has far-reaching effects on weather patterns across large portions of the globe.


The concern over this has been growing. Just a few years ago the IPCC felt that a collapse in this very important ocean circulation was not likely for hundreds of years, but now they are not so sure. Now the authors say the AMOC is “very likely to weaken over the 21st century for all emission scenarios,” and they are only able to say that “there is medium confidence that there will not be an abrupt collapse before 2100.”

If such a collapse were to occur, it would very likely cause drastic shifts in regional weather patterns and the water cycle, causing widespread and significant impacts on rainfall and drought.

“It’s a solvable problem” — but there’s no time to waste

The portion of the report called the Summary for Policy Makers was finalized last week in a marathon session in which delegates from 195 member countries weighed in and agreed upon the final language.

“The government delegations discuss the wording of every single sentence in extraordinary detail,” Hawkins explained. “There is often some compromise between the different delegations on the precise choice of words — it is their summary for policymakers, so needs to include the information that is relevant for the governments — but the scientists always have the final word. If the wording is not consistent with the underlying scientific assessment then the discussions continue until it is consistent.”

While some of the final wording may not be as bold as many in the science community would have liked, Hawkins notes, “The language is pretty stark for an IPCC report.”

Andrew Dessler, a climate professor at Texas A&M University, told CBS News that there’s a good reason countries have to unanimously agree on every sentence of the SPM. 

“These documents serve as the starting point for climate negotiations,” explains Dessler. “Given the process, the SPM goes through, no country can later say they don’t agree with the science. They’ve already agreed to it.”  

While there’s a lot of doom and gloom in our climate reality, the report makes clear that we still have a limited amount of time to avert the worst outcomes.

To do so “requires limiting cumulative CO2 emissions, reaching at least net zero CO2 emissions, along with strong reductions in other greenhouse gas emissions,” the authors write. 

The greenhouse gas which can make the biggest impact in the short term is methane, which has about 80 times the warming power of carbon dioxide over the first 20 years. Methane has been rising rapidly in recent years due to emissions from natural gas and livestock. So the report specifically calls for “strong, rapid and sustained reductions in CH4 [methane] emissions.”

The chart below helps put the scale of the task in perspective. Since we first started burning fossil fuels, humanity has emitted around 2,600 gigatons of carbon. To keep warming below 1.5°C, we can only emit another 400 gigatons, which on the present course we will do in 9 years or less. It’s a near-impossible task. To avoid 2°C of warming, we have another 1,150 gigatons left — approximately 26 years at current rates. Most experts agree that is doable, but will require collective willpower and hard work.  

Breaching either one of these Paris Agreement targets will not result in falling off a climate cliff, but as warming continues, the impacts will increasingly overwhelm the planet’s human life-support systems — especially as they happen concurrently. So every increment of a degree matters. 

The report says that taking the low emissions scenario, as opposed to the high emissions scenario, would result in a “discernible difference” in temperature trends in about 20 years. Scenarios with low emissions “would have rapid and sustained effects to limit human-caused climate change.”

Some reassuring news reaffirmed in this report is that warming increases in a linear fashion with increases in greenhouse gases. This means if we stop pumping carbon emissions into the atmosphere, Earth’s temperature will also stop warming very quickly. 

Yet despite decades of warnings, emissions and warming continue at a breakneck pace. 

“It’s like we’re on a speeding train barreling towards a brick wall. It matters if we hit that wall at 200 miles per hour or if we hit that wall at 20 miles an hour,” says Kendra Pierre-Louis, a  climate journalist working on the climate solutions podcast “How to Save a Planet.” Pierre-Louis believes that while national politicians bear a lot of the responsibility for climate action, each person can work at the local level to make change. 

“Perfect is the enemy of good. The best climate issue to tackle is the one you can tackle provided you link it to systemic changes,” she said, offering as an example: “It is good to ride a bicycle. You can feel virtuous. But it’s better to push for the infrastructure to get say half your town out of cars, and onto a bike or walking or on transit.”

CBS News asked Pierre-Louis what message she hopes people will take from the IPCC report. She replied, “I want people to understand that it’s a solvable problem.”

U.N. Secretary General Antonio Guterres sounded a similar note in his call for action: “If we combine forces now, we can avert climate catastrophe. But, as today’s report makes clear, there is no time for delay and no room for excuses.”

feature image: Pixabay