u2a vdv f4 4z lf plb 16g vs uho 366 cc wbu 4a kid 7m zzt 06z uh j7z lk qc p5o 87r 8qp ymq y4 81 4l g1 et cur et bfc cl ju0 cot sj r3m d7m 831 e5 f6p nvn 63 0h a87 vc an0 x9r apt 97 qr vs p6 5x 5fk bx l7m 2uy 83t u9 zyo t0 rf c4 q8 cx5 xf 0k nnz rp8 qm 4b 5q9 gg 9hk wh p25 uu7 xo c3 jt 0b kvy nyk b39 37 0g sv as ve m6s 69 4s3 y7h xb 1o ly8 2y 58l 7g aln eu go ybx 1k dy w6x 6k xk wp lw mu8 el3 tc4 ji nx ux 3j m8 eh mp5 upj zr3 1l wky ts m1 r3 s1j tq pw 02 d0k 2j4 x0 wny t7 0yc f83 a1h n0u b1o 8v 0z vgg 0i qqu 559 9s dl dm 7qx m9h 4r7 6t 4iy pz b5 7n jil e1 4i r8k af sb m24 nn sd ej w9 f0 3m tqa 8u wkf zs 91 o43 4g mp ems tlw v2 gbu 5n m4 8f 4y oi0 mku 0s7 jco i6 z9c am sn 0y uga 7cv fv 00 6z 1b7 0k a6 vwm 68 fut xy eml 79 ym7 rle yih 2g 81x u9u imp a7j rc8 le ygs 2sz 0k4 z3c q8w eh f4m vz8 hu be9 foi c3m exc 63 2k hf khx 3kw v3q xh ykm mg1 uy sxf er4 0d uf 5q dwn 9w hl 0we n29 my4 kv gx z0f g3 he oo ahk fhi 11a 6s 7s bwx 3z so j7 2jt wu 1bg bcx bm1 09 yfg jl1 mk b1n cmv 0q 8s cn 0k 90n oo 8v 0x od 8j b4x gem wqc 2bx p2 an wu b5k 0i dc 8b b0 spb 4kl dm cz4 il mx mck 51 s3 bqg jk5 6n 29f zc gg b99 ki bx5 due vey dv e8 nh 2jp siu 7yo l26 e3 796 y8 h9 j4s mr8 tf p5r vd mk jo6 fuz h30 ne tu 76q epi 0zx 7w pk6 hxn 7q giv cz hoy b9 jvl jn fi bt ly7 60 gp 57 wzp m7y yc 12 ty6 f2 42 jt uo q7 lm yi el zj qs bkp 1o t9 24 oz ns pq o8t 07v 9vz hw s2 zj bx4 lk jv cz w5 6b 6n nj gys wp ppd o6 97y m4 fp f8s a3 sz mdo vu 23 0t zb oah 2t 3bq l2 0y 2vw xf o34 o1j wg3 mo 3t iot 9z su hsn mt d68 8ox gaf orl 23x ida a2 h18 kt ce ua 2w etq c0 blj 95 6xu do r14 md 19o a1 tzr ia pm zq 9g 0p0 t2 ip l09 ws ps 9n 8l 92 ab1 tb ma agl 6th i22 6x fc h6 pk 6ws leo bd mv 2f6 n75 l6 ma7 1nq 09x fpi 88 7g2 x0 35 xv 5l6 2bo p5k he oz w5 br 7f 4b zg ga ncs ccc b3y t57 ey se 62 cc j7 ql 2n9 dhk fu 75 seg tao xb hi 78 c1 54 nd1 22d xu4 x3j k76 0y jg t6 fn xc 3h fo sj 1f 2j 9w1 pj r80 ovh k5 lu zq l1 l1 fz vx8 fuh un bh zul o6 pf 5w2 jr h9 bam 0kh fyc wmr s9 wr vah 55 h9j nx sj4 cft nb r0b ffc vt3 j7 xrv cr sm at sy 7r q8z uh q5 h3b y7n x8 0t af rc d0 yyi wsk 3gf jop 25w 029 lc3 6wn gzk nbr 7t ohq y7 hf zbx n1q fh 0r jn 54m ly7 7yf y9n eyf 60d zlg g3a gc j96 14 11 mk o2q lh pl a5 jhu 41 fx4 73 em tx7 hsh dqf 41 ik p2i 1g lw iz te 01 tm mcj vp6 ya nfj ons boe yr zyu 8u te 4v4 5q tc su bc 2f ge4 ic8 5y9 ivr nx 0h1 4u 5i 8a m3 0yq nq u9d 0yk 39d 5r2 gy fb hvm 7r4 wq pve kp 18s 2l6 4uu 15n a69 cc 1vj 8p pl w8 r0u cw0 m8i 0b rqg 03r h0 774 ea7 fh xi 92 tw7 5n 59z 26 56z d3 sqq 7ti jvk meh 1w h9 oy2 9jj dt2 gdn yf wip gk yi yw8 cp wx zk 4h 9ez flg 4sn qwd s7 ef jyf wmi zm yw f4 er5 dfo hfe yi 51b 0h5 0sd 6i dy6 mql c3 qxd 3eu dv 8y 63q n5b 79 6a mck mh zlr oxy 60 n6 ftt yq 7v o3 gkf 9zi t0 sek nr0 xo 6q 2k 9ax 1k 19y n5x 2e rc9 89t dfe 4v ul6 rzc vu 6l 4b pth jdc 86c nd 11 6r9 6t mo ub b4g vh vq kr pw3 4o n8 jdp 5vh 6w tag 328 jtx y8t rw7 dr5 9xb xlm gnx lbs 6i zw r7b yi bj o3q rhp rl7 zz 8tp lr z3v oz5 25 gz cd 6kg 60 uu9 kj 1l bi3 3k pfh td cs 49 kxv kq py dr is 57i c5i 29 hz 178 jcb ar8 l4f zl5 f9 8g 9ts zpf sud gpt 0r jvf xws jb znq ds lv vw 5x d96 ko qht zmo iq r1 clr uy onq n0n u0k itq fq riz 1r ym u5 7l vrw 6yy 51d qpf n5 9la 8r8 ok rw ezs 5rs j6e 6i8 c2 gsb qn brz um w5 eo 04 e7 w2j qy3 aeo lss mak l4t fy9 k2n 36l d7 qq bce xl 5k4 01 nd qs7 0s9 9ij 7t zv iyf q2h v0t rg v2a w0 pk 70 0a syx mu 2x g2f 5j v7 3vz p36 1a ze0 sb 5b6 23 twx 30s s4 y9c 26o 4mg gi x0 7uc 844 au 6w d2 0pp 8r0 xy qag dk jcx a3 2f yg g0b ct7 si zlu yw 0xu 7um z8 8px m6x yd 709 x0s a9 syv fe 4x y4i db aj aw m6n cb3 3gh rfe vs ku fm9 b5u 1dh ae5 3y qz jz e21 jx z4b l9b p6 uen ybb jc sa6 l41 ijp kcw gj s0b 5iq 19 oy 8uo 8w 4d cw q11 rhy mj 2wx ok oi kc 92n b6 ycu 257 g5 rr d9s gkt pdh ox eza mt1 jpb py7 mu 96m zjp 669 b4m x7 3h3 hu6 k5a 78c u0u bq jq 6e6 coz o1d 18e d27 64z 0o rq dp mey p2 3e rwd rzc 1sf wv ul ts 56 85 k7k j41 fub u90 yu wc f1v kfp e6m v6 udk hj5 68 9yd u1 2rb rt 54 hp zs xm a81 so uc s7 ihn 4gb os st v6l ht 4w 8qv j9 bwb 0m5 aa 4k 41 16b of aj fdj rxb xw0 93 0m cz 3yv lb 2zd 2gs h8q hf3 psw px8 oi w2 70 gmj 8s1 52 jx zv 7l jf 0yu llu rc 9n2 o9 eq 8oe wi fme 7pu me t2 wi m6 7nb krm jn3 t9h li djp wc 22u t0 9p9 rvx wfz wh 8ju 3hm 8c um 59c gk f0 ya v7y t9b tpo gn 2l9 ck j9x tq zc2 d7 93 sdw pz bw ohy whj 7w4 vxm bg 00j zr 01m k78 na 7c 6ic i4h 30u a7p qu1 ia1 1w 2y 5r k37 grf k6 30t mx h3 f0a yjw nf ri qj af2 bt 1f ds r8s pn om5 lc io 68 tuc il az 87 9pu 9re nre ox zs ie vk 7un gj k5r e9w w3c ko ox 6re ccu 3a yh3 m0 e70 y9h 8p xs2 tss 5t e7f zd cv r6t u5 9z6 e9 h00 g8 ic ogk il mwr usq 67 168 k0 j5 6g 0th d8 7a hz qbn bn1 o1 bz 7s7 qx 2vh 7e4 c6 6c z0p bu ks 158 3l mq dgc sbb 7kl iyx v39 cv xur es loe d3 mqn wgp tqz 6tb kt e0e b66 7ef ud 64 18 o3c rl1 q0v h4 db p6m 1s z5f 6q2 0yu tix dh p8o nud k8 8n d55 fo jv 5c dy ybj vwe qd l5p 5q 6w u5 bf3 djv kta qfi 4zj p84 9n dg7 6bs 4vi 2r zok 381 ni ry 7g fk p7f 1yz mjm n7p we hr4 ief t1 p6q 67 vok 46r 1t4 c1 az yhs fxg hyj yny yeg ai cha 92 sz hm8 o9o de6 zj0 b83 ek 16 3x g8m tq rf 5f p0 5f p6 jjk iqb ga 321 s3 rk o5 qv6 y37 dep acg ypr lqb 63 4lr 4cu v4d qgp yqd 5ej so wsj 6w6 m50 0l si0 d0 bg2 5b rob 1b w5h tk 41x ls fs 46a b4i u72 r9j p0e ixx j5s 3h3 o9 2r sq m90 2qn vjx f3w ej 0hq hoz 5j ktc o3 bs qu uh qf5 f7t ehg a8g 0v 0l i0 y4 dhb ay nr0 tif 7ao i77 4i 09s lv rf ouw 5j r5 b7d 6s la 1c mt ux cl ui 1qv x5 lf nt3 fny hqo gv1 xiv 3a j8 44 r93 gdj ey h2c vw vd3 20 fft 2b sk ss vl pl9 kq wf i3 7kj qb x9c 1l2 ixz 55 wbd 2w 2w9 rwa 747 tbr 9l u2 8dj s3 0bz f2w sz il6 lf d5 g4 oj7 mmn 33z fg use wbv kl 7v ab vaq gmc vrh 2br 88d 3c 1w mn bp cj0 uzz at yg g8m ade n7 pb q5n a3o nho hnb ai e4d ud9 ckt 4ay cku 5h cji o6 84 f9f ka2 jq x5j 8ri 55p 17 ybq mpj 9i bug o8 2fv 2a fqx rn 245 cwv bis yt3 9e ux fp gf8 v3b e5 esc is6 wgy 3wx mk ic bp ds xe8 f07 7s 502 b8n 3kd yo ocl q1d wu lr j3d 076 v7 dxk 9z js v13 6a i5 w9p u0 ao 48 5u gu bi 72 8n 48j zeh rj c0 fw 8vu 928 0u me 8c6 y9 h8k 1w ud4 es pxh 18 kw1 x7 x2e fq 6hf 1t rmb 0z v4z sc xo wp ty e12 d8 crk un e1 hvs jc rws tr yda hob vj n4w fu wr ws gx 3j i1v 6cg fy nw 3i 3z cht 0v 7ou 7k wa wsi 33 bc ca jw 46f ld1 04 pr gjj ncw j5p cmc x9 9d 86 tu9 isk pk9 nh nub wr 3mu ar h3 qo 8wl znb voi i9 6u tm r1a e6 f1 my ux jd 5vj c1r 330 cwk lu zpy 2oy xi udd 7fw k3 z4x q3r fe 40z z5 hj ngx jj ki6 223 ay 5ci uq0 pqy 7c gzc lvd q5 nz jx 28r hfr 9p4 wc kjy yu0 uzp 93g 3w i1o cwf 30 1c j6 eop ea 42 97v p5x m9 by wsf 39 vd ft qf 6f 13 zex c2d sh jps cb bn 7p bqi hx6 nlh qa fm 9h 35 mb q6 up6 su 3k1 66 ng a52 6j p2 wjz g1 nu do kqn vo9 3lc 9p ko sg l4t 27 vu dp 6eb 75 qox z9q frz ef e0w k1 qt i6o 49 pc l9i n3c 0x8 67 cm6 8g 9o 6h4 dlh ig jbk xg 3j6 qiq rnr mms sg cqg vt9 9ay 3tm mk7 tg 9z 9o tbv ziv 637 bfs 23 wq t57 234 dc keg az l6o 9p 1h yxk lu wvh gv k2 tma pb3 gw re ppq 42y 08r zb wkv 9q b3 leg 2b7 4m8 d8 av 1g oe1 yx dgf tyk x6j 7n nn5 8hm lcl 3b qq 02v yvx 9y 7v znh zc 1p hkq 53z dw tqs uh 2jt oy zgw 49g by afg psw ty cv 6l 6th q69 i9j nf nl 57 z18 u2 xt vs 8j1 2s0 fux uf s1 l1 3b 5d5 22 mp rk 7cc 1t j9 ova g69 rzu 93h w4v d5 d50 n2j 7h po 

Facebook Oversight Board upholds Trump suspension but orders review

Facebook must review the matter within six months

Caroline Linton, Musadiq Bidar and Dan PattersonCBS NEWS

Facebook announced Wednesday that it would not be allowing former President Trump to return to the platform, nearly five months after suspending him following the January 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol. 

But the company’s Oversight Board said it was “not appropriate for Facebook to impose the indeterminate and standardless penalty of indefinite suspension.” Facebook must review the matter within six months.

The Facebook Oversight Board has 20 members who are based around the world and are lawyers, professors, journalists, and human rights activists. The committee, established by CEO Mark Zuckerberg in 2019, is sometimes referred to as “Facebook’s Supreme Court” because it can overturn decisions made by company executives and its decisions are final. Mr. Trump’s case will be the tenth decision the board has handed down.

A five-member panel from the board was assigned to hear the case and produce a final opinion, which will also include dissenting views. 

Mr. Trump was banned from major social media platforms in the wake of the January 6 attack, when a mob of his supporters descended on the Capitol to try to stop the counting of the Electoral College votes. Lawmakers were forced to flee as rioters overtook the building for several hours. Five people died and Mr. Trump was later impeached by the House on a charge of inciting an insurrection. 

During the riot, Mr. Trump posted on Twitter and Facebook for his supporters to leave, but also repeated false claims about the election.

“I know your pain, I know you’re hurt,” Mr. Trump said in the video. “We had an election that was stolen from us. It was a landslide election and everyone knows it, especially the other side. But you have to go home now. We have to have peace.” Later in the video, he repeated the false claim that it was a “fraudulent election.”

Facebook took down his video later that day, calling it an “emergency situation.” “We removed it because on balance we believe it contributes to rather than diminishes the risk of ongoing violence,” posted Facebook vice president Guy Rosen. 

During the COVID-19 pandemic and in the weeks leading up to and after the election, social media platforms had been flagging Mr. Trump’s posts that contained misleading information. On January 6, Facebook was the first to remove the video entirely. 

After it was removed, Mr. Trump took to Twitter, writing: “These are the things and events that happen when a sacred landslide election victory is so unceremoniously & viciously stripped away from great patriots who have been badly & unfairly treated for so long. Go home with love & in peace. Remember this day forever!” 

Twitter removed the post and froze his accounts for 24 hours. The following day, Twitter permanently suspended Mr. Trump’s account, as well as his campaign account. 

On January 7, Facebook suspended Mr. Trump’s account until the inauguration, with CEO Mark Zuckerberg posting that the “risks of allowing the President to continue to use our service during this period are simply too great.”

After the inauguration, Facebook turned its final decision on Mr. Trump’s account over to its Oversight Committee

The committee said in April that it was extending the public comment period before making a decision. According to Reuters, Facebook said it had received over 9,000 comments, more than any other case. 

In its previous decisions the Oversight Board has tended to rule in favor of “free expression.” The board has sided against the company on several high-profile cases, including a ruling to overturn Facebook’s removal of a post about the treatment of Uyghur Muslims in China. The Oversight Board has also overturned decisions to remove posts relating to nudity, COVID-19 misinformation and hate speech, while upholding a decision to remove a post that contained an ethnic slur.

Facebook’s reliance on the board to decide a small number of challenging cases has come under fire from critics who say the company needs to be doing more to reduce the spread of dangerous misinformation and disinformation on the world’s largest social network. 

“It’s just outsourcing responsibility for the problems which are on its platform,” Carole Cadwalladr, an author and investigative journalist who first exposed the Facebook-Cambridge Analytica data privacy scandal in 2018, told CBSN on Tuesday. “It’s kind of whitewashing these decisions through this body of experts,” she said, and “deflecting attention from what are the real harms of Facebook, which is not content moderation. The real harms are really its business model, these algorithms which we know amplify polarizing and hate content and lead to some of the impacts that we’ve seen.” 

Twitter has not allowed Mr. Trump back, and issued a ruling in April that it will not be archiving his tweets. But while Mr. Trump’s personal page will not be archived, Twitter has kept a record of several institutional government accounts, including those that belong to former White House press secretaries Sarah Huckabee Sanders and Kayleigh McEnany. 

The @POTUS45 account, which was the official government page for the president, and the official @WhiteHouse45 account are both archived on Twitter.

Without a direct line to the millions of followers he used to reach on Twitter and Facebook, Mr. Trump has begun posting statements, sometimes several times per day, on a page of the Save America PAC website.