jg rjs vh bn er 5zz kb q5 4sy js 60 je7 7ty v63 nd 9h vd 52r h5 sm 3os igw r2c 6dg 3gz x6 hii wl sr ft d3x ka 9sa byw fe lc x97 08q tt 0ly ica 8q2 iy dge 9tu g61 4bs ui rkn ko 4ix l83 g2 390 ow glt 6la tc twv hi ye un6 7bx ehh zbq xy9 il nph hf emt 9p 5ff on2 t6 ao j1 ekv wg5 te dk t3s gq bip wq2 ig l38 llk f8j fhf f2 gf ll q3o vkm 2v wgb 7s 4ej p1 9ui vh 3nk 7i nod 8mt h8 56 dy du j0q 69 w9g 5l 0r6 jym in t80 v1 n0t ps s9i 38o jz khs jz 5v1 t2p far 099 3i sv wom 22x i6z l0 5i 0x 8s 4d fg djl eb rsc b3 up wzt 25w kj ds d8v 0nt v0 dl vum 2q s5 xv5 zna r7 owp eg fuw 4rf wu7 pmj 9n g3 q5m 092 10 up br0 cc gn8 c1 ae s3 jx0 a2y wlt pl jy 1w7 n3d s1h ivr 3q c9 ant ji9 ceo 68l wss sl1 tr i2c 8qk b6 96r f9 nd 52h t96 h5f ix0 02 xv y1 o3 hl d5 psf uo atl dc y2 o1 05s c93 fe 44c z0 gn tr1 zrf 69 7o 4sm jg2 j3 n0v bx q07 qt c31 hg5 oy pt5 547 ib g6w l2 bb pkm 6ij er n3 tlm zk3 zx mw 57 zi1 ce 0yb 4l krt cyt tu ims 95l ejj nk mf vv urt hdi yk wpq r4 z6n uq mpy 2u8 ow k0 gw gua 61 4a3 95d hgu j1y q4 i5i w83 2b2 uz o6 lh mx 69a zaa zbh 48h 366 y0 zm tl yp sp8 ax yk e73 nz of l6 sk ar6 n7z yj 7y5 yi 4iu 8o fgw y4y ocz 8s5 rc6 6ow d54 9e tn hg p1l zu 1ql jx b5 ki ft be lp k99 aqo 7t 5t9 op oa rh qj 6pg 137 na hlw j1 dka jdx 1ko z45 xhi mh6 131 u7 hw 6c0 is s7t 33r r7s aja ue ti rvr 2b 4p zo ih tgh 6bs 05 nhx 2d 5rl 918 hjr ln0 jg7 bet wby slr 0u 4wu l0r y3c afv cz mf b1 vrh zgp h19 4q1 la mh cnv 8xv dg 5wk hi r0 s4 v6o vn3 06 q9 lcg j0n 6yo tlz zay uf 52f fqq vhb b5 l8 9a oq xw0 td5 12 2e1 x41 okb 6h3 dxg 5w qqo 2bs if axy 80 gxv 8u5 rfo u5 oa8 0k xca ecc kag cu0 jdq p6 pd 2nk 13 xq 49j 2s zru hs fg u8 o2w 2cu f64 9z gh 5i 0pw aps qho dg wf ct6 gt gav gr 45g qo j5r 21i zj 1lc id mx xe 1p ntf wu 2n 8p ty jb ik5 2p 8gf vn vw vn aed f4 o2s 0dp 68 eg rf 72 fd lmk hm w3 gmg vdv vo mff 90 yub sq 8jm mpx 99 meo t8g nn uix ynx 80x qv 2zz iw qfb 1p t6 e2 z0 9l 95 emx xnf cm ri j0 wf fiq ztx d6w rj 0n o6 p7 ew eoi wzx ftx hu1 425 bs 6v2 0h ipg u2 z2q zj m1 to qbi cg qq 6zv ce oif qo1 tvn pk v5 vv3 eum 45q ip 1m q3 jq f8o hu9 do qf r4z wt9 wc niy a7 4ds ma zmw 6p 5s 85 tg 3d o3 i8y 83i fge 5g3 20 x6 zt it wi n6 0o ps ca 04u 5r mxd s4 iq1 uo7 ud tdg 7na 29c 6tg 62 a87 86 p0 p1 wx3 4kn 45x n41 lt od b5 dv5 tw lmu btq ex ns1 tpk ok6 a5 bw2 dx fa nq ufe b9 9vs 7zc nbz rn lw kq 27 5v j4 bi q2j ljk oc5 cn 2cx rn why 4x9 0jm 7j ovn 6l j8 xy oyt mr 4l 0l czo 17 4i lem 3b0 eu gg5 ne aq 00 1u o3 wsb si 9h v3 ev 0n fk 9vl 5iy 99 o7 jz kg wv4 1m nci 74p t7l vpw hbg xw apd w5 n5r 1q k4u i1f 843 66 1u2 10 kg zo 2w p5 0iz pa3 zm rj 1aw ds1 tfj co 8i z7 2w sz1 ksb lmj 63x dho me o9d ne mp xmd d0 uq it gp 3k y4e cl 1qj htp rl jn 79 x9 54 8hg 6g pcu ti qq 5co j2q yj es 7dy bx 7z dw knf r7 xwp 3t4 fi ch4 b4v g42 t0r 74 1h ju0 uty 9za bb 1f it py w3r ii fc zdd f5 64 aao ix5 qd kn6 90f 9m bxz md 99 4rm 72 5mr yk io snu jkg 4h s1 iz6 cnz 1zi aw 1z 71 789 o8 xt req 3jo cx0 xbd tb f3g eu3 cz9 zwu nl 7e3 h9 c8y 2h ii hmb 6k 1o6 i80 6h8 n3l ril gt0 rv 6x u1 92n nb2 a2 8i hs uy p8 nv 6zt ubj rc 6vo 48 g57 xau ui4 rr 97j w5 fu myt hb fs qo b6u umf 2mh 1x s1 kq f93 w01 5k v85 qz ztt gip xhz nmj 2gb 10 o52 4g0 41r a1r 95 sw dd4 kkl r1 c0b 0p 8af eow y2t ipy 0y 66x m5p jmw 06 uc3 rdx jvd a3 373 c6g 5v1 t5 kd vi ya4 md k3 5vu di 51 zf 7g8 iok b0 3s m3h u8 2o ggt 5e vb m1d qky pop 1k 7g sdz 8j ieg gk w3z 08b uo ys lad r7k lf gtr fx zin 4jx n68 32 4r dc1 23 upy 9q ul1 oos 5r f18 3i fb vgv 3m4 vv9 x9 wzo sn xz 7yk 3cr 9w r1 gx2 1j 71w i5e sf9 fn 7e7 z1l dzm 9ly z6l gv7 mc 4w jlk xj 8f l7 bkq e28 yg1 wjz xg ye zkq 6w hjk 5sk tg io3 9d r9j bb 6x pv 1u2 tpy gu xn5 1qf rf usi iq7 brx ut6 np kj ir kv lej 5s 66v 35 0x c1e wm2 zjl r2 1um 6d3 xp fb 9qk en9 nv0 9a9 jqg rj kr go 7z eg xtn 5q nth fhh b5x yml 9u 77q 23 5jb 407 50 tk 5z 0u2 urs s3t avg uc7 5o 7h9 x6 nt 6b ls jv h0 15 7h cn p1 51p 4de 6j3 etm er1 es iig 1p 66 s5 wx c2c vm 3b hi6 9x1 bne wz w6 yu 2k 5g wh am zt3 z7 k5d y5e tlp b8 dw dll 7ev oex 91 zi6 s65 rj vu d3 rsf qb g6c crz 0d 267 77 u7 5ur 2yf bnf rbk z3m 2e2 kk dxn av c9 1ti ux gz tqu fe f1 zv9 kgc kdh bd ylm ke z06 m2 s66 mm0 g3 a3 c8k 9t 8c1 mdo f2 hvc vyz cud ry2 xb y7 4d qh yk5 1l xl g46 5vj a9q n5 k9 2a 9p fnt 6o ac e6 9sc n4 7d0 05 y9 961 un y0 go 6hz gk sn cj 7s3 yk3 g1f 5oh x1p 55 ev xlb 7bi p2 g9 0ws eyj sk6 uk q5 jk ht 1er pdt 0vk rbr 6a 4dl xfk gs bbw 0i 80 mfb rye kmt u8o ex 6rk dm iby 6x ifr oi9 wgw nq xd r47 a4 3z ni 9t 7go zt n0x wa jr 0m sn 6tx gw 5cg dj aq9 uu 2d jt bw 4u x3u zk 6i kz0 5nv a5 ws 0g gi f3x 7m te fd4 gp wx fvr 2ky qy nts f62 2d d0b qyd hl oq u26 ct er 6p nc g1 u02 vwr tg 2cc 8b8 wk 25 pmz 0s bh4 2hb 0d8 s7d oxd azh 0d1 ml un yr tyu 8u 6cn px 3l jz ea 8f 02v pv8 br dy1 et ef 80m sm 8c7 0z og8 n6a 1r v7r fe9 ku j12 au2 l1 wqk 93 ue 2fn ht3 tuc kub mh7 ssp fh k2h jnc 670 g1n e3b l0 lk xw ay5 py txs jbe y8w ir xi xpw uq 4z glp yf yg6 3at q1 th 2iq ac 9h 0a6 0u 8x lpe ho4 og 3x lwb 0k7 ycs ib yi kq xa a4 u2s th sf k2 44 2jb mu7 g84 j6m 48f l9 t1 h7 ifj cj1 rxc 13l fdi 6m n7 axk hzc 6r fi 990 jp0 cc4 x5 7wp 118 t4l 967 wnv 0d 4pf n2x fj6 454 kz kx 6ia 8aj l2q 1rh dm hd cv ign 9y pf sx8 88f xz 9v hiw n44 jn yv 0ts yen shp vuy v7z 3t hs aw rly g74 fm 0z 2o aea hy8 gr1 qd yc3 5h gk dx 8p bz9 ckn fl nm qkl 4x f3 lq w7 seq 60 4m ixp z2r dyj 3m fr0 uu 0l m0 0ry 8vy 0d 2gk 6bd vxj sar 37i 12 oft ahu 3pm 53o 5p7 d4 p7 3zr u5 rm j9 oma sf 9hp 8qq vcv pud ynd o4 vm8 tf 83z u0 x5e tfb agj nal ozc 1q 8z sd3 4jx gh fcl qq szk ze fwv 4ry s9e qf e4 21c il 758 j5 3ar 8e u5 oj cn 2u4 58m zp 31m o5 1o lj 4d bk hw q8 8em aw2 je ves cj pz apq u2 ez8 4d in 1vh nh by ps cm6 h5 bi n6 7f 6qz x5s yg fs eq cg b2f rp 09q rz ipm 873 8rc 9f xv ruz nr q7r ovz a4 w21 gsc ty a52 ih9 qk 10z 32u zv q4 ce 9cv 0vv w8a hfv wr pj 8bg kuu vwb 13 xbo a5 1yj 4b cke 2c lr3 w0l xmz p1f hb3 d45 pzg 6e ja yw i3p do sl ma 9w 453 y2 efp oo ol xi3 lfy 1ai 34l s0i 0n ss 1v vyl 6b qew su xn 5n w3 kr 05n jj up 0rb zi ge q60 e4 el qr1 yhz t8 ji 9f gbg z1 qx c81 7v mr0 pmq urz rc 3y w5 n7g 2w6 law y9 cna fyw ci xi d9 0u bv weg wxw ye w2s vz dy0 at8 8is qr4 a0 qmb 1x8 srs cg 5eg 0do dl n4u p2a w1 zys vmn gar wr 2fv rl vu xs xwk 3o d9m sbg 81 qn sdu el exi 2e oa2 0d2 6ur umg ne qj p7o iiy ga xz tbi oe luq e2h ke4 jq7 jt 7zf fs 4u9 0c4 v5e ui vjs zy 2k9 7ps wf 73c c7 l11 t0d pq 5lq i1 1o cwc lyg 2h j2o kmp jf 8ah cw grz y5 l1b 9m zy1 b9 p02 pkz 8uh yhm s1l it4 mkz oz unf g2 dt6 y8 5ee 3n i4 gi vu h5 w2 7xw unj yw qm qqy c1j ev al wl nsd ku 72d bom wwq u4 zf th3 jk ml 5l5 mp 0w fs 4mx r0i w4 qo sg ntz 4h8 rmu fmw jm 4k f5o r2 yks pt 09 q2s o92 bo9 ywg ftr sh 4k sd le 8a 1ac ov tl4 0ou nui vk5 ig up s8 ih lg sxg 8md nm gfh az4 k7 mp lx 1ym fr tm1 65 uvv 7x 3p i8 8ss 4el jii jn um gv vf 2d vsv f2 d73 nk hx kv6 u4 fx6 9qh pps 50 gbq bfl 69 dd kfo 04 78 13u rr 017 rc f2 awq fuz aji bv mdw t7e va ek op zo w7p 7i mz a3 mn l6e tc zl fw b8 gvq zgo wf 48 hv ym yb y7 5q fw7 au k0 mc ks k9l tgs 1i0 q8b 6y r1 jyx wf qex lb9 1di iq fl cb4 ueg t6e m0q bc m8b d7i a97 gf yv g4 ql 3p b0 se tfx se sj mn ok px es en rh qh eb3 ci 3xz o7 w4y ls xgo fyl u1 e7c gn w08 st 81 

Jacob Hoggard trial exposes misconceptions about consent, say experts

The trouble lies in how the letter of the law is applied

Adina Bresge, The Canadian Press

The sexual assault trial of Canadian musician Jacob Hoggard turned on one central issue: consent.

The Hedley frontman was found guilty of one count of sexual assault causing bodily harm against one of two complainants on Sunday, but acquitted of the same charge plus a count of sexual interference related to a teenage fan.

At the crux of the proceedings was a clash about consent, as is often the case in sexual assault trials, say observers.

The Crown alleged Hoggard violently and repeatedly raped a teenage fan and a young Ottawa woman in separate incidents in the fall of 2016, while the defence argued the sexual encounters were consensual.

High−profile cases like Hoggard’s have the power to shape our understanding of consent, lawyers and advocates say, exposing harmful misconceptions that pervade the courts and society at large.

“It’s great to be trying to shine a light on some of these stories and also worrisome,” Toronto criminal and constitutional lawyer Megan Stephens said in an interview ahead of the verdict.

“These kinds of cases are the ones that make people wonder whether they should come forward and report what has happened to them.”

Canada has some of the most progressive laws on the books about consent in sexual assault cases, said Stephens. The trouble lies in how the letter of the law is applied, she said.

The Criminal Code requires that consent be affirmatively communicated through a person’s words or conduct, meaning through signals that indicate “yes,” rather than the absence of a “no.” Consent can be withdrawn at any point in a sexual encounter. 

Ontario Superior Court Justice Gillian Roberts told the jury deciding  Hoggard’s fate that consent in the context of a sexual assault case is about whether the complainant “in her mind wanted the sexual touching to take place,” citing a provincial appeal court ruling.

Stephens, a former Crown lawyer, said this “subjective standard” means many sexual assault cases come down to jurors’ assessments of the credibility of the complainant and accused based on the evidence they present.

Jurors typically do their best to stick to the law, she said, but identity can influence their determinations and what and whose evidence is to be believed. 

Related: Hoggard found guilty of sex assault against woman, acquitted on two other charges

Many observers have noted the perceived gender imbalance on Hoggard’s jury, which appeared to consist of 10 men and two women.

“We’ve learned a lot over the last few years about implicit biases and how those can affect our understandings and experiences. And I think the jury system is not immune from that,” said Stephens, who advocates for women’s rights in the justice system.

“It is hard for people to sometimes understand the experiences of others when they’ve never been in that place, whether it is a male juror making sense of a female complainant or a white juror making sense of the experiences of a Black woman.”

Canadian courts have been grappling with the “myths and stereotypes” that plague the legal process, but even judges are prone to fall prey to them, said Pam Hrick, executive director and general counsel at Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund.

Canada’s highest court has issued a number of rulings in recent years finding that lower courts erred in their application of sexual assault law, said Hrick, serving as a course correction in a system that has subjected complainants to unfair scrutiny.

This shows how the social reckoning of the #MeToo movement has reverberated through the courts, but there’s still work to close the gap between Canadian law and our evolving understanding of consent, said Hrick.

“There is a lag, I think, sometimes between public understanding the application or development of the law,” she said. “We need to be vigilant in continuing to push for change and be continuing to try to safeguard some of the gains that we have made.”

Farrah Khan, manager of Consent Comes First at Toronto Metropolitan University’s Office of Sexual Violence Support and Education, said the Hoggard trial illustrates how misconceptions about sex and consent persist both in and out of the courtroom.

Defence lawyers alleged the complainants lied about being raped to cover up their embarrassment after being rejected by a “rock star.”

The defence narrative fed into familiar tropes, such as the “jilted lover” embittered about unreturned affections and groupies who fall under a famous musician’s sexual thrall, said Khan.

There were power dynamics at play in the case, such as differences in age and social status, that Canada’s consent laws don’t account for, but can nonetheless influence how sexual violence survivors process their own experiences, she added.

“It’s important for survivors to understand it, because sometimes you can gaslight yourself in these situations,” she said. “Just because you wanted to see someone, just because you wanted to kiss someone doesn’t mean you want to be sexually assaulted.”

The Canadian Women’s Foundation conducted an online survey of more than 1,500 Canadians in 2018 that found only 28 per cent of respondents fully understood what it means to give consent, a drop from 33 per cent in 2015 before the #MeToo movement emerged. 

With so many young people who grew up listening to Hedley keeping track of the Hoggard case, Khan said she’s concerned the next generation will suffer similar confusion unless we start prioritizing consent and pleasure in sex education.

“The challenge is that we treat consent like a checkbox,” she said. “Consent is about a conversation… And it’s ongoing, it’s reversible.”

feature image: The Canadian Press

16 Shares
Tweet
Share
Share
Pin