
Former Barrie mayor Jeff Lehman says he's disappointed, but not surprised, after being replaced as chair of the District of Muskoka as part of the Ontario government's move to appoint regional heads of council under Bill 100.
Lehman, who had served as Muskoka's chair, was among several regional leaders affected after the province named new appointees for eight upper-tier municipalities and regions across Ontario. His replacement is former Conservative MP Scott Aitchison.
Lehman told Barrie 360 the issue goes beyond any individual appointment and centres on what he sees as a loss of local democratic control.
"This is the biggest problem with Bill 100. It takes away local democracy," Lehman said. "The notion, I think, that Queen's Park knows better who should head up a local council than the people or the elected officials of that municipality who have their own democratic mandate from their residents."
The legislation not only allows the province to appoint regional chairs, but also grants them enhanced powers over budgets, staffing, and some council decisions. Lehman argues that shift concentrates too much authority in a single office.
"It's an enormously slippery slope," he said.
Listen below to our interview with Jeff Lehman
According to Lehman, Muskoka council unanimously opposed the legislation when it was introduced, objecting both to the appointment process and the expanded powers being granted to chairs. He noted that some municipal leaders elsewhere in Ontario have publicly stated they do not intend to use similar "strong mayor" powers available to them.
Lehman also expressed concern that the province is moving local government toward a more partisan model.
"We've had a system of local government for 200 years in this province that respected local democracy and was non-partisan," he said. "And I see these kind of patronage appointments as being sort of American-style politics coming into Ontario, and I don't think that's welcome."
While Lehman has been a longtime Liberal supporter and ran provincially for the Ontario Liberals in 2022, he said he expected political considerations would play a role in appointments made by the Progressive Conservative government.
"I'm not naive," he said. "I would expect that if the government is introducing a bill to appoint people to pursue their agenda, putting in their sort of agents as CEOs of these regions, they're going to want people who are aligned with them politically, and that wasn't me."
Still, Lehman stopped short of criticizing those who were chosen.
"I don't quibble with the people that have been appointed," he said. "They're all skilled people in their own ways. It's not about the individuals, it's about the choice to take away the choice from local municipalities."
Asked whether residents should be concerned that local voices may carry less weight under the new governance model, Lehman said they likely will.
"It will be much weaker. There's no way around that."
Lehman argues that regional councils still retain authority, but that power has increasingly shifted toward provincially appointed chairs and the province itself through mandate letters outlining government priorities.
Despite his criticism of the changes, he acknowledged Aitchison brings experience and expertise to the role, particularly on housing issues.
Looking ahead, Lehman says he plans to step back from public leadership roles for at least a couple of months, spending time with family and working on housing-related projects in Ontario. However, he made it clear he has not closed the door on a future return to politics.
"I'm certainly not done with politics," Lehman said. "I might take a break now for a little bit, work in the private sector, work for some organizations that I believe in. But I'll be back."




