News

Published October 26, 2026

Nuttall wins second term as Barrie mayor by wide margin, incumbent city councillors re-elected

Barrie Mayor Alex Nuttall grins during a victory speech at Pie Restaurant in Barrie,. Ont. after winning re-election in the city's municipal election, Oct. 26, 2026. BARRIE360/Julius Hern

Chants of "four more years" filled Pie Restaurant on Monday night as Alex Nuttall readied for his victory speech.

The Barrie mayor had just earned a second term to lead the city's council, cruising to victory with 26,054 votes, a share of 66.62 per cent, according to unofficial results.

"When you door knock 35,000 doors with the (campaign) team, you get to know your city really well," he said in his speech. "We did that last time, and we did that this time."

Tanya Saari was the runner up with 9,898 votes (25.3 per cent), followed by Russell J. Tighe with 2,419 votes (6.1 per cent), and Kay Sayer with 737 votes (1.8 per cent).

Voter turnout was 30.21 per cent, the lowest since 2018's turnout of 30.01 per cent.

🎧  Listen to the daily headlines that matter most
Subscribe on Spotify, Apple Podcasts and wherever you get your podcasts to get notified of new episodes every day.

Nuttall's margin of victory was a significant increase from his first mayoral election in 2022, when he narrowly defeated former deputy mayor Barry Ward by three per cent.

"I think it means stability, I think it means steadiness," Nuttall told reporters, referencing the separation. "But I also think it means there's a lot more work to do... We're going to take the the support for our mandate, but we're also going to do it in a way that's going to try to bring more and more people on board."

Much of Nuttall's campaign strategy focused on accomplishments from his first term with a focus on safer streets, housing, and job creation.

Among his promises was to commit $3 million to traffic-calming measures, add 2,000 new manufacturing jobs in the city, and have 800 affordable housing units built and filled.

Nuttall acknowledged that some of those goals would extend beyond a single four-year term.

"There's no way that we could fully get all of the finances of the city in the place we will want them to be in just a four-year term," he said. "We've done lots of good work towards it, but there's a lot more work to do on it."

Advertisement

In his speech, Nuttall also called on residents to repair what he called a "social contract" in the community; the idea that everyone is there for and willing to help one another.

"We've let that social contract go," he said. "We need to re-engage back into that community where it's not about each of us, but it's about all of us — about how we all step up to the plate."

He used the metaphor as a way to call on residents to get more involved locally, including within the City of Barrie and some of its various committees.

Nuttall will enter his second term as Barrie's mayor with many of his council colleagues still around.

All seven incumbent councillors than ran for re-election will return to their seats, while Amy Courser, who represented Ward 4 last term, was elected in Ward 3.

By the numbers, the closest was in Ward 9, where Sergio Morales narrowly fended off challenger Norm Costello for the victory. The pair were separated by 236 votes.

Two other wards will have new councillors. Pauline Stevenson was elected in Ward 1 and Arif Khan, who served on city council from 2012-2018 in Ward 8, will return, this time representing Ward 4.

The city clerk's office will verify the results later in the week.

Barrie's next city council term begins with a meeting on November 15.

🎧   Local news stories that matter most to you
Subscribe on Spotify, Apple Podcasts and wherever you get your podcasts to get notified of new episodes every day.

UNOFFICIAL RESULTS

MAYOR
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Alex Nuttall26,05466.62
Tanya Saari9,89825.31
Russell J. Tighe2,4196.19
Kay Sayer7371.88
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
WARD 1
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Pauline Stevenson2,03845.47
Shaughna Ainsworth1,02721.73
Stefano Agostino89218.87
Brent Bowser54011.43
Christian Earl Cadera1172.48
Hafiz Rahman1122.37
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
WARD 2
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Craig Nixon1,77645.47
Shanicka Edwards97324.91
Frank Casera54313.9
Tracy Strohm3779.65
Ajmal Noushahi2376.07
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
WARD 3
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Amy Courser2,54048.00
Ben Hughes1,24223.47
Bryan Jones1,12521.26
Ryan Rijo3857.28
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
WARD 4
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Arif Khan1,80141.34
Lori Galeazza1,16126.65
Matthew Corbett66515.26
Iradat Ahmad55212.67
Patrick Harriott-Stewart1784.09
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
WARD 5
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Robert Thomson3,34677.65
Duarte Da Silva96322.35
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
WARD 6
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Nigussie Nigussie3,04768.92
Christel Pena1,11525.22
Nader Nasar George2595.86
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
WARD 7
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Gary Harvey2,08583.57
Michael Lewis41016.43
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
WARD 8
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Jim Harris1,85263.25
Amanda Fellows86229.44
Samina Alim2147.31
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
WARD 9
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Sergio Morales1,61248.15
Norm Costello1,37641.1
Dave Weingarten2808.36
Asmar Naveed802.39
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
WARD 10
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Bryn Hamilton1,97574.14
George Kapustin38914.6
William Cadeau30011.26
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
SCDSB TRUSTEE - BARRIE (WARDS 1-3)
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
David William O'Brien4,39542.62
Tim Ware3,57734.69
Wes Ayranto2,33922.68
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
SCDSB TRUSTEE - BARRIE (WARDS 4-6)
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Candice Thomas4,03842.12
Dana Powell4,01941.92
Beth Mouratidis1,53015.96
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
SCDSB TRUSTEE - BARRIE (WARDS 7-10)
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Kevin Berry2,72931.96
Denise Ketching2,42728.42
Sean Fitzgerald2,25926.45
Chaudhry Farooq Haider Virk5806.79
Darren Steeves5456.38
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
SMCDSB TRUSTEE - BARRIE (WARDS 1-3, 5)
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Susan van Amelsvoort1,32862.49
Justin Heran79737.51
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
SMCDSB TRUSTEE - BARRIE (WARDS 4, 6-10)
CANDIDATEVOTESPERCENTAGE OF VOTES
Maria Hardie1,79172.51
Rob Chiaramida67927.49
Unofficial results courtesy City of Barrie
What do you think of this article?
+1
8
+1
3
+1
2
+1
1
+1
5
+1
0
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Have a breaking story?

Share it with us!
Share Your Story

What Barrie's talking about!

From breaking news to the best slice of pizza in town! Get everything Barrie’s talking about delivered right to your inbox every day. Don’t worry, we won’t spam you. We promise :)
Subscription Form
Consent Info

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Central Ontario Broadcasting, 431 Huronia Rd, Barrie, Ontario, CA, https://www.cobroadcasting.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Related Stories

Advertisement
Advertisement