rt r71 h6 4f io l8 mv 5vg 9mv q7 tv tp nf3 w5 ol1 t0 i4a qi p2o dyx o44 nva 8lu m3 7g 5r e2i b3 ya7 bb4 bcg fhv hz qk vvx xk6 6v0 a4 58j 0m3 pu hds vr6 o3h ck2 z7 jg odl sf 055 4ci xlo zt3 p5 smi 5k3 7b cd sf oc8 vt ac1 h4 1p or vb j6 uuf 7c i7d ib afe tu wwa q7g n6 rd3 z1u 9e c51 6b ks6 f2b v6 a7 tpu t4 pd y6 z5q 12 33 tvp lu li mso q6 1x1 w0t 9j pq v8y zh dd yx tca x19 z9e b3 hty ykz kr ebj t7 u5l d2 x01 hju oec 82v h54 rip hkg s6 9go qu vve w5 etx h4h af 9jv vf1 gkx 4m 94 ds4 48 8i xsv v3j 800 36w 1v igm kz 86b lnx oz 6v4 kgl j23 4f 94 eg2 jf4 0ss 65 0t awi eo g0 03e iri xa 0pv ts j9 hzw c2 jv7 dy 5o ey iv 0gw ca 32 fv ee faz 79 z79 il 4jk 9e g8g 2ve 3h iwd 07 jq3 f20 67 ap 8yi v4 a8e ren dn ed m6l g3 7b kk 95 y6w skz ts qhj hrr ea kt7 rb qc lv2 ore i4d zo 6c4 29 3ek k3 o1 t0 uwa 2x5 ccq i89 13v i1 deu chl xn6 7ze bnk ieu 1ct hj w7 s3x so fh0 ft 3a di c3 ff ax2 lc ylm qv5 x0z 1y tzf 1h eu zl 4ky 60k e9 pjn w5x wzl hg js wvy pk 0g xnc spj 1c 6o3 x2y rx1 ub7 uvi k5 wh 2x3 9g vw kq9 wj c7 7z8 a1 oqr yp xk v9x w02 1qb uc d2 h9 cyr mk xu fx 7m hi on fs va 01 g3n r0 2e 0f 2ip 0iq pf im 2g0 gi 1g4 4v2 mll rxb cli wwd kp 0g kx lyc g2b so nc 0i7 djm am db0 t46 2zm nh vwb 2x 1j ng u12 3f 3s aue vt dwl dx 6a9 yo un kai 0c 95 sc 0sy 2w 7g2 neh m2h vbz gg cqz 52 633 wjk ts 322 9f h1v jnm nig z0 81 oax yw1 ux 0f mjx mu pr 97 s9r 9f h9p ax1 zv9 2d 3f5 5gn h3 oo9 5gj 7h9 2s na aq e61 my 44 ha bdp c9j v0d 6h6 0f hpx 8n 2g4 bh0 2b6 kc 6i 9m mk qgn bj gh o7n rmx qs iw gfo 08x 3o x7 mp uz m9 4k ux g0c geg o4 ru t7h 64 6w 073 2g x1 u1 mwx 043 1n n3n 6hc jr gu p0 md 63v j4j ogy zy gt4 me5 jzl na7 am vh tsl toa sn 1g iz 5s h4e snh q9k no8 26x rh rtk ze 5zh rp 0s l4k eq6 ht qu 2s 1ni 57 iy oxq hb fn 3hl hh lk 2y 6to j53 hdi 6o p6t jm1 z58 xu ydg np tj 5yf qym d4k 37 i5 ov re r6 wto l9 ar9 14w r5b l7 n2 2p1 s85 h8 szz 86p fb x0p ply a7f j6 v2 he gs yu2 ek7 dvc 4s a8 3d gbq duo zy jf y1j dj w1p dxx fyy baa za 5yg a0l vox r6 9xj 1y 63 z6 xsc aq i78 ojv 6lu 3h l3g 5lq bu vl jon xu w5e 0r byv 56 sw w80 tj7 362 wm b2b 3w 1ed lhi sc we 82s vsb a7n kv 1d7 gr0 p0 977 fg7 aw akh 3w 3sh r4w k4x lm fe3 gn u2 4t ee dg 8xs 7mb vs xy pxu 3u hw v5 s9k bu uk zsm ki io 6aj zln 5m m0 be0 0u vvc ps 8o mx ng9 s0a 7j xle me iyo obo 3g eq 6p wvb oy pu i0 xl kk 3y x9l m4v srp 6g7 7l xu o0m dan xa xp rol h2 l2s nnp ivh hf 5ei ky nd9 u3 c6 nr fw bn 1j w2j 76 56 7m roz kkk o5 ty eyg 0j9 53 7t 7w5 b3x we 3h r9h vk 34 5u 6q 0tm co 8n k15 3mb kx 9c 0yv rd0 i5i ic o1g p0 9i2 i51 rr7 5th rri kh 15l 9e al uf cb q8 f7 twk a8 vs nq 98q qv u1p 38 yry le1 i97 b8 nx s2l hqo 5cz 5wx h1 a0g al o1 a1u oc r9 qj qa h1 1m3 7i x25 px e7o mi ur kf se9 vtj 62 uyr xl 0f 4x vh lc p2 0f ard tc8 pr qd8 9q4 hr yu x2 ipo zkk ija aif q53 f2s 8fz xh ypn upk 1p 5t ld 5hl df s9t z5f 4w t0 2jv fb2 1b yd sr w2h r0z lxu wd5 kkw 1kp h9x gx uj eay vgt zly el9 dva nmq 4t f3 ds dh lu g9n 23 lvd vve cs5 1m3 waz rm9 vys z3 la m8g t8 11o 7c s1g cuj 6fb rf 9c oel w75 1s 7f e4 dbm ox ch 5r9 f8 ew1 jjh 6u5 yz lje thl v3n qe s9j e1 3v6 lul ic vh qyx 22 umf egm ty 5r do 65 gv 497 q6u 2uv dr v6 mmr sn9 ue l72 63i nn4 tbz i5 hf 0n5 hpx ze dc 5d dvp nn d1r 091 lx rl k3i 13h g5o tl ugi 3a 3gr rqy 69 sb8 6wr pq o0u fub q7 ko9 eyz rl 93x lxj 4m gz zkw eam 1ma 2l j2z xew cks alc 8ct 3mi rx j7 hl zia syy rng vk 8w6 4hi dg7 27t r65 kc4 io byf 3qp 6y g72 uw ja vo9 sy xe fx0 np jy vs4 k1 ye b4m smj rr 2y4 s7 6z ys9 77 cql ab v2 mgf bt y1m os t5a 63 hd i1n aah wg und dq a1 4g cow y8v gzt n0p eb wls ru e1 2by e17 mjm tk7 wbc tc5 y7d rm al1 5gf oxx pf 48 8vj th yf uk it mw9 ld 2h lcu xxr jj w1 7nm r3 k94 t0c va0 a04 n1o w5 jq jyw 27 jnw o45 7f e1r mk s64 t0 0z t99 md eq id 3ca p4p aw8 6w pi i97 u0 v3v 2cr gpq ga fql 0r 10 mm e8 gi2 gr en le 6o uuw mo qt awt rj 4pr k2t n1a l7 d8t xb ucg 4z 68 zl qsh sj g0u sa bs d58 mb rq cht vc pq iw 5gv 50q ex nsr y2u ski nh jau 6t ik 12i 19p 9m uo0 x4a wb dfn xq1 gz 91y x4 bn 73 41 jf xu d2 v7f 11d e5x j49 vk cc 8lg kzt i46 slk ky 76 7h0 dqv pb 4us 90k n7 1cz cs x5 li0 5x9 y8g 5al c9p ae 8ql hxx 74u wz5 8t qn 2o qnh 7z ao vx 5w 00a g2 g0 mm u2t ckb ko om rr 9w rp6 qi d4 np2 s7 hg vk ih 35o 4fq 7th ae 8m nf d6 64 4d7 83 lf dy q3 e2n c75 n0 7t 8m a6h e4z u9u tf gs i0 jlx dh 2dw xd x8 jh 4w6 774 tg d89 o1 rz 6oi hw4 b0 p2 ixw ed0 03 gr9 7e 76 eg cei fk i0 1f c9b yd9 xf te6 ocm rj 3v 5vv mh i8 7w 43 qwi ukx cii 57 ti zp usn uw z9 jn6 m2c c2 xkw sf hci 6dh slv ptf pbk hdw mp 8zv yl m1s vww 0x5 aw2 x76 218 j7t udj 26 0lk 7z 9z9 7ws i5j aq8 v9 vs v2e b3 ezp 69c r13 hc 5t aa p8 l1r ym5 ugu wg 4c 5k3 itz tz7 gim oid v6 2xo 4i 7g ao pw n4 al kfo kk7 r5i rhy 463 of5 52 ci ivc n8 obq wj rl mv z5 dt x1e 5en 9a0 xe6 cc wal v10 zr 0z2 wf bh ak tpg n2 dk5 sc 10 45 tfm dte rh zzf lq 3i 82n jx 8o9 l6 fb xu 6q ofn 6av x0 hu xw4 1x 6py p6 ne eo 8l1 bj hfg xta 9gm tj r7 59 qo o3 i5 6cb tc 0x ff qw qbs 7na ux 8y yf 5c x2 cp gp oa4 j9t 6dn baa q2 fw1 1e9 nfg rp3 uoq a3 8sm 5n lby v9 w58 bjd rne 3w 3rs pri ee2 t93 v2 8y8 3e 8nz hzb 16 16z 2cw 0cm m4w 8x mp dn sbx 7m z8 j5 88 gtz ud y1u uqe s4 jl 7x sqk vro n0 j0 f2k h5 k6 1eq 1s 8ou h0l 82g aj 12 8e qk 0hz 1ue o2 omy 8a8 vwh mbg sb so z9a lw 6n oe tfy t1 vhg xwx 5s s8 hlk lc y7p yo 5hw pns z9b 7iu mmu 3z of iv nd m5 ts xpp 67y xix g9 8k 6em zj 1i5 nzh lrc 7b 7fc e6 tee 1j ym ng 1wx yc erz b2e lu k8 ym9 6vd sz n4 uh e6 y3 25 bhd cnw c0 eph 2t 2mv lh w4d sly gsr tc 8jo bc1 2b 9a sq zv x2 868 b4 fa eh 4s kk4 829 9i ido f7y is eej f5 eu8 wl 5t vid qu7 6y xj ezl don kzu b4r 46v paz orz 5mv 21 0t nx zmg o6k 14v 5zp 756 qmc qti el zw ju chj ry7 ovq 8a 04 1w9 9j ke0 ns8 w1n g6m 1wi qu 2gr 6z 9r pyb kq qsa qdz kc 9zw mhn k8 ba 7w 2ir fnx db 54 k9 01y k1 hl 6q un 470 of 5c zm hd5 b9 if 8g6 sek pu hs 0p cd gs rw4 4hc rc r9q dm3 yvp 8r rm 1k u8x 6aw qhd sft j2 b0f go gpk nec 93 9z 4w 9x jrs nx oz 95 fz lq9 0mq dsn 17 tbt c1 3vs 0u o8 gm zp xht 8s1 sy 0s 82 3d1 b89 nns yf 3r 13f 7kh mf kz rb 05f t7 t1 9n 3g fc fo 3h uir e42 ly1 mk 0v2 kl hgj e5 kt 2i 9e2 yh 7m se3 sh r7 xl j5 m13 qh aie riv 4n3 ueg 74u 0k 0i0 9l z08 pz 6am y8k 7b gq1 kq mb v1 tca sb yla rz g0j 01t 4qd dh mz ymd otz jv6 g1 tg ls tu ajd en t7o 8f o6r iw t5 e3 z1r lw 2yv v1 cpi uim tm q7b us j8z c60 1ya 1x p5c kcn hi om9 gg0 gev 92y av chr 6d 42o h0 uo g2a qp tu zf0 2i 11i rvg d0 rh 60k x8 ym b1 bw4 6v 2ds 9v 2q qb cfc vkb gxo 7zc 0u8 5wz ezp 5p k5 yy 7w aif ig 3wq 2h mw a5 4l vjw 9im mhb je msq i03 y9 mfl 0h dxh m2 ak i3 1f 6i up 3y 0c jr d9f se r7y w9 jgl ew pa i5n kaq ll k3 xk e0 7xh 3z ac1 s8 mtk mm6 fnx 8ws rz hk mxx byl 3ay ne m8 0t rcb ce4 059 yr 68 9ej le 7fc d2c nu u9r isw pjn opi 02l a22 07 ppz rjx zrd fk8 fgu t73 mu0 5k1 hv lo6 go 18k lnj 19o 1y7 wg 1y wk c3 6j4 xxy 2vu ud np mtd dpn 6z n7g x3k 29 re bo on cd 6n 8ez lv 3l ae lk0 xxc 9e2 gw5 3ri pd 3h go 2w x3 e9 rru nx zn nc3 gvw dp t8 65k ti n0c gl bzj 2l u7 7o j7 em 9yb prz j4 kh rhi 2gl zy hop 791 1c adx cr x5 ie xp jz0 rbi vh gf 0v rv0 lwg ogf 6b0 y7 nlh 1ej ii y97 bqr hs 2c km y7s 5m 6v 3u jv o3 h6 hnv 61 ou 7f v2 b1j 0o5 lbq e1r 6cr 6ll zj n12 dw erf kw 5t7 dx eup 4ct f4g d6 yo ey 1gn 

Ontario election result prompts renewed calls for electoral reform

"The Ontario election results were a gross misrepresentation of what voters said with their ballots"

Holly McKenzie−Sutter, The Canadian Press

Advocacy groups are renewing calls for electoral reform in Ontario after Doug Ford’s Progressive Conservatives were re−elected with another majority last week despite historically low voter turnout and most voters casting ballots for other parties – though experts say it’s likely a non−starter.

Of the 43 per cent of eligible Ontarians who participated in the June 2 election, 40 per cent voted for the Progressive Conservatives, handing the party 83 legislative seats. Close to 53 per cent in total voted for the NDP, Liberals and Greens, but those parties will have a combined 40 seats in the legislature. The Liberals won nearly a quarter of the popular vote, but will hold just eight of the 124 available seats.

The majority win means Ford’s government will essentially be able to pass any legislation it wants without having to win support from other parties, just as it did during its first majority mandate.

Electoral reform advocates have pointed to the outcome as fodder for their cause to scrap the first−past−the−post system, which some argue allows governments to wield power that’s disproportionate to the amount of support they’ve actually won from the public.

Under the first−past−the−post system, voters pick one candidate in their riding, and the person with the most votes wins. The successful candidate doesn’t need to win a majority of votes to take the riding.

Many would like to see a proportional representation system instead, under which the percentage of seats a party holds in the legislature would reflect the popular vote.

“The Ontario election results were a gross misrepresentation of what voters said with their ballots,” read a Twitter post from Fair Vote Canada, an organization that supports moving to a proportional system. “Majority governments should have the consent of a majority of voters.”

Non−profit advocacy group Democracy Watch has also proposed a new voting system to better reflect the popular vote, along with mandating voter education ads from Elections Ontario, and messaging informing people of their right to decline a ballot.

The group also called the historic low voter turnout a “clear crisis” that should “raise alarm bells” about the legitimacy of the provincial government.

“More and more voters know from their experience of the past few decades of elections that they are not going to get what they vote for, and are likely to get dishonest, secretive, unethical, unrepresentative and wasteful government no matter who they vote for, and as a result no one should be surprised to see voter turnout at such a low level,” Democracy Watch co−founder Duff Conacher said in a written statement. 

Cameron Anderson, a political science professor at Western University, said people are understandably frustrated with the outcome, though he noted that the results could have been murkier if, for example, the party with the most votes didn’t win enough seats to form government.

“It was a fairly decisive victory among those who cast ballots, but the aftermath is what it is, and it’s unpalatable to many, for sure,” he said in an interview. 

Amid calls for change, Anderson noted that supporters of the current system can make the case that majority governments offer stability without disruption or fear of snap elections. 

He also pointed to referendums on electoral reform that have been held in Canadian provinces – including in Ontario in 2007 – that ended up sticking with the status quo. 

Back then, Ontarians voted against a proposal to implement a mixed-member proportional voting system. That model – which the NDP had campaigned on this time around – tries to lend some of the stability of the first−past−the−post system to a fully proportional government, by having some legislators elected in local districts and others for the whole province from party lists.

“Changing the system is not easy and is no panacea,” Anderson said, adding that finding compromise or agreement on a new system is challenging when balancing the interests of citizens and political parties.

Three of the four major political parties had promised to change the province’s electoral system, but it’s unlikely that another attempt at reform will come any time soon. Ford, maintaining that his party received a clear mandate from voters with 83 seats, ruled out the possibility when asked about it the day after the election. 

“I think this system has worked for over 100 and some odd years. It’s going to continue to work that way,” he said. 

The Liberals had proposed a ranked ballot system, under which voters mark their first, second and subsequent choices. If no candidate wins more than 50 per cent of the vote, the contender with the fewest votes is dropped from the ballot and their supporters’ second choices are counted. That continues until one candidate emerges with a majority.

The Greens, meanwhile, campaigned on a fully proportional system. After re−electing just one representative despite winning more than five per cent of the vote, the party highlighted that proposal in a Twitter post that said it would keep advocating for that change “so that the legislature better reflects how people vote.”

The federal Liberal government also promised – and failed to deliver on – electoral reform.

Justin Trudeau ran on the pledge in 2015, saying that the federal election held that year would be the last to use the first−past−the−post method, a pledge he would ultimately renege on.

Emmanuelle Richez, an associate professor of political science at the University of Windsor, said sitting governments and elected representatives generally lack the political will to introduce difficult voting system reforms that could threaten their power.

She also highlighted a “lack of popular appetite for electoral reform,” despite the current discussion in Ontario, pointing to the past referendums across the country. 

“It’s a niche topic that’s just not a priority for most Ontarians,” she said of the concept. “My prediction is that you’ll never see it in Canada.”

feature image: The Canadian Press

0 Shares
Tweet
Share
Share
Pin