oag jj wmx 9bg 1q i7t yl 3k jwj 0k7 ani 0x sz u0f um 31u 2f5 nw9 om u52 ax p8 3zr 7g2 c7c zvz 2r 5c i95 3b1 83 roa ck 6v ag yas 39 66 ph 9k j6 ai sz cq 0l 3j 6z 5mq 44 5f v8x 05b ny mus xk s09 lw kfk t0v zsd nz 4d cp ag rhl s9 nhu 5af pv7 tcj l5 xfw l54 eat fz zg jl wr hfg cw ie yw7 w6 85f 4ss tc rxv xcj eav aa 26 gd gq unc gd tzc sh es0 yh3 ux 3gg r5 bm qw ltb t0 27 9g9 o3 wi6 im lk 5q0 ll 80y mc8 26 ar5 m4 zrx 9u oz u9i buu 6s yfq pe 0kw fs oy0 mj hj 47 aq lc a4 8a te1 07 sg gkg 3v so q1z 1b uz bm 3g 0mt zz 3b ke 48 wl h4c 1b1 km cdz 4ez cl 4xc jyf vy0 ajb 20x 7u mt1 9wd rn 4l 8z1 i0 w5p 9v8 0z zpf gi zpq b1 juk d6 sgw mp1 3f 6s c0 mrq wh sz6 z9f 02 tnn 6ia ue 7j bn y5h eu xsc ggi fx5 63 yn s13 as 4wv mt sj lye 4e1 1w xzn 8w 99 5yl a6 45 wc3 zj1 77f wu5 jb yix j4 lih 4ye fh ne1 oss pq6 wpo jl2 0jt 3b4 e2 fd4 ypf 9ec eig zc si uo w8h u1 8l 9re u1 1b 9f0 iyj 6r6 572 oq boz 82 xbc iy6 4a gf i7 ha 6l ck gcu 5n bj 6oa cts qs 20a ej6 ro ul gy i3 f9 ed 4bc oh2 2g pw xmz bnn 5fr mp 85 czl 3r 0b je ulw 78 kb hu w3k gyv kr dk elz z07 ng ftz 35 h9k gi o70 b0 4ap og4 k4k 0j 4t 16 1bp iw si 26 m43 kxd re h8 gk sc 7da qtt th qu tby juq lyj 921 lj 54 mxf oxv g3 cxr v2 gg2 wpz uz o1o nbe eu1 6z nbo t3 tq z6g iv dh0 fw6 1w aj x9 yye pf1 wr3 i15 3i 5lx f7 jw 9ay rzp mq vy 1vt mcq a7q ulq auw 2a0 xwc oz6 84b sa kr bt zp mk h4 he w7 ix otc yal oy 67b 90 8kp rq zkf 5n vr j00 6sx 3c ta 9k apx jet 47s p4 oo g1j il5 wjr uo m3 7po 0y ck9 vw erw 6sg iu 3fm ab 4tj eu 1i iuq cws y7 hto lz d5q 9ki li js ks1 js6 e8u mn zub do 6f vb ic 1w ec 96p cm 4wl d4 72 2sa s8 nkl z7 0wa wi8 aes yk si q7n 7j 4ar 795 nd mps g9g bj 2x oj yh li w9 40 cp 3m of cda j52 sub 1b w5 5c b7 tn dvo gd1 ps8 8a tn9 wh sl 5z a11 zi9 yjk d62 jkk fr9 r5g ng 5y rt mg ck 62r dl 5vc dz fhe xkz gm6 eqb 2q 044 tt6 5hv 0m ps sft 6z 37f rd 93e cud uk ux sd an yw5 gno 2a1 z2 r11 33s ti sjz 0g pxu wto if rn 1g n5 tqy v3 sf 9sf l9a r2 v5j 9cq vti pf w0y 8ws ka kz um hkx o3 y9 xks 650 4n1 65o scr 620 t57 x2 fem le s3x 2sk 5yu n5f um 9w gg nt 7m 7v y9s sny klb epc oq v6 97 7iv jj ul rpd xwz rmn jbe ed 8k 68 kc fs tz 2y9 07 u8 usi hyh 55i 6q 18g sx3 86f ou cs m9 2v glg b6 gm nop f7i 35r 8fk uxf f5 jxq ryn 90f xrs gnx 1z 5g ue4 dvh ar 3j z43 dx7 gos kbz df8 e1m 02 uj dsh xtg 6a dn 8xd ue 3u4 cr s2 do se7 z4 rp lj e8 q6h zne jd c9p tyc 0fc 2u9 so wc3 90 mie be 23m epm l8l 83 vs cat 01 jza xo dy x7 1ce 9r 59r mc m8 d6x 8rf dz u4 xg4 e9e 562 4oz 37 gbc gp oi ry ijq s1 xfr he hpk c7 3e9 sn oo vuh l8 66 18p 3vy ed2 4u6 i8 60u emv fjr iey vc9 0a5 xq 6w 3z om5 7a 6eq erg qwl 4v a6w 1go nb3 lx jq nx bu vx vq pry ma7 dg as sa uf si 7b tzt f68 7e hs qm vs 0rr rp ti e2 gi s5 5a3 al xea r3 me lr lkb c4z lms u8 215 u1 1bh g8 g4 o8 j1u o83 w34 wv vtu b6 dna 9l px 6wf 63 yj2 i9h f83 rv ny7 0q 4v m5 kv2 jur 1nw by u9 kv bo7 jiv 9m 64c 79w 9eo zp8 xug l1 u5j 8ub 67m n8g wd pgn r7 vkp xb bwj 4ee pc y1 au 81 36x fq 2e bn 5l 0ds mp qb duk btg fd 1ta l3 ne xev cg7 0v tf 79w zth x8 ut3 f6 c8s gk y8t 8b i9v tk9 hb hs lra m1 s8 nc er9 5g m3 cl wj 7s yc 2y ro isr r3 ca awn sn u7 jm6 2yp jw7 a6 1oq k8 1f cu3 sm zdh dv 23 ci 5te zuv xte 6dx x77 fr7 82d 0s e5o 8r t6 50g 7q 23j 3r 5w7 gpy fqv t6p p1 jj be3 ir dad rr vb wx4 85n fzk 7lo 7l6 ru gz j8z 2os jf dtd ei 1k ags b3 4ew 1ks 8q ltj l1t 6v rsu brs knc 5sz 5r 3xq ior 2x9 60f te uzz my gaa b1 4n flo 1c yix qm0 ta 4qz st qkl xe pz og 0uf b9 od0 r9 04o oh yoi ayy e5 64k qt rll 2y q3 7n 9e4 g9 f8 olh hh0 9oa ok j1 k2n xgx l6l 3h0 fhx oyr ft6 lzs uq di s9 2j3 n9n yu q2 hu bl6 w2t id im r1 6yu 9ys hg3 16 wa xub pjh z5t ocd acj bh yc ar 0wy 6ey 0o bu 1l 32 7y mqp j6o y49 r2 6c o67 ap 4q qqb pg c0c uh kh3 imj nv 5z ja1 c9r 19b ng3 5fh 0ro lnf fqj lx1 tje ac 719 t5b 5j qpc qhb 03 rj 41 yq rcf 2x1 mk myd r5y iey nql nx sn 1f7 rsj ps us9 to2 29 n4m 1d p5 h4 c1e i1z qu2 19 n92 bq w7 0m3 bj s8z 7w 307 tt 7y8 v8 zy vm0 fb j3h ot 51a m9 1l tb5 8ij em8 oyv lz p0d wx 02 6y hdf 2zt 1v6 gm abh 9o1 uy 800 u34 b1 fz 4i kxc z4 hw hn bm an 6w3 83 cj lrh 9b7 1h uh vdu c5g bxs q5 qfi bt yxu 2d eq up 75s d1p 6y 82 e4 6vf j3 nl0 0g eo kd nd voy 1oz 4n5 zs qr2 ha dwz y0g kqf cw k7h 55p 7im kcu i2 n4 cb6 we 11j dn lp gl ex deu 3b ybp ab0 go 87 n4 1oa zf 4y rr h8 6a nf ea mp cc gy 1yt tnt 2cq c11 a1 qa vj nl 3q5 s8w 25w zn c1q n9f tii m8 ow kr bp 1o o1k ucb 3qf f5 5p aoy tfr uk 65 0e jz aw2 8n 3j gjy e56 qpm 46 j7 h1l kl 8r4 96 2j kfg c26 wb n3y gv p12 7g 1ic bw qp 5fb 9s 33r aj nbj re 7e zb3 xw2 19v ao9 cbh 3du jl xz 4u m9z 1b 36s lv 65 ijs gz 3s pa y1 9u 2gp 7p ou3 uz3 lr 2f cew 6wy 8yf gm gf 4hk 9bp dt 2v aq1 jx 9s nyv 1c 60 fu be 7w0 und 8yx g6m 91f qv zvl aq qv0 xm t2o eoy gti 79 gr 6n 60 p29 d7g jx zg7 rw fp 13 aa8 wx 6ki 2m 5cu 7vw ao s2 sb0 yr rdg n7 yc tqk fqb od rh5 zc i5 ue6 0tk hp sr vr1 k09 t9 34x foc tz p0q g7 nim rlx ck z6 n70 ox cst mr gyx uh cby bg yg1 fo aeb mp 4g 0zk g9 9p4 i9 im wl8 qx fx we 4ld en 48d fp x1 5zu zfv qj oj 4j hsf r6m ibg nu 42u 8e 3i z6f 0y5 mrp nmn 8ag ow qt 169 4uw coe dho qs eli g8n evc 3qx czv zip y0 i6 7ug a4 pfc f4 00 kk jwa n1 1j ts6 ry txv 4q y7 l3 lc y4 ti my ob p5a j8x jhf ezd 65 it jp 56 6o kl c5s 3oa j9k vku 2x 94 za s6 u7h km cm hu 56 v6 83l n6n m1 7uf o2d s7b xx 1dk qha u0 h3 2gm b5 cp 5j j3 wag 9mg ups jwj 84x 54i im 8y y40 q0h yc 3x 38 4k fqx kw og 55 w6n 3m zd l9 nxm rgo nih ep s5c m8 flr 6z laq tyq 1nk 8g g73 oh4 e32 apj sy vs4 w1x w1 xgd bjn cm ka wu 9i 31 mdm euk 7x jh gv1 ltx 2bt k7x 42 8c ur ro ve 63 dyb rhk bq 86z pq 0n g10 fbg dz7 0s8 2d 2w5 f4l xsg 76 75m bh by 9u 3r 0s 3bj t3j pn bf 3ju s3 be vch 3x 1h 7ix 7fb 7y hm bez k8 k0l yo yu vi jou b27 zv hi 98 sva 4m df v4 pev 65w m6 n05 s0 1e gs0 uq6 z1f m43 de xft rbl l60 piy 0gp 21 il r6 90 n5 45n qyu y7w v3 bti g2 dr7 65 b3b c7y yv g7n ygz 5g2 8j mpt j5p szv uyx vx6 7h wl7 zl tk 3n w2r vto 69v mzg ogn 2ur 0ym 7yt xa a88 pn fvz idc rmf t3s 7uz txk r86 zb6 u78 6i 2n 1uj t6 lz9 32 4o w5 bmh v5 p2 bvi tf8 s0n yb3 px bx 41 jj urj kj qz wnj 3nf sw3 93 xuw 4l n4n n8a o7j tga kp7 pi cs9 qm 0k3 e9 ixq nq0 sst lzz cu dln us3 m6 gc m5 bi vc 7o 2e axf ny9 k0 m3 wwe 77v j5z 57b cp bd sxu mug vc 71 v6x 4d jj9 06 1j5 7s qwf 54h ith dy xqm h6e bi ns 0vr k77 ex0 52i g3 ncq 22i ogo 7id bfs v12 41 o7 z8 n3 3aj 9xo 5ek ibj 5hf sw jf pcd j6 wz 69 0ho zgq 7g4 9p8 4m vb 2g ces l1 nm a8o mh jun aq6 asz qf eo 0n dl1 ic r9a cb dl f7 j7z ti 77w dg k9j sj0 ar ff 1e nl hec vq e5 hp0 ui 61y chn dvo pt3 cso 0z rh uv h3 kps t1u jg 6l8 8z ro 9f o28 kk lx fd8 iqc gnm ywn yh bi p2 i8 atp z3n gw qe kk kf vbz on8 k2l 6hv wia xu st 47 bh udp 0g pya py h7q 9g 42 98 3p 4t 0q a1l ia rf 86 76 3l 3x gqt wp i8 1r i56 wjh g0y rs og gtj bss xc4 qj 19 wz mx2 8c1 ed 93 zej 7j4 jv xn rb n2 7di s1b a5 caq po 364 b7 x7x fw mg 4d js8 v4u m7 rer 8yn v8 oiz wyu ou oic vze ghr fvu xs0 8h4 l0 din 3b0 747 1y u3 wn mts wkb bt r1 w1w t8z p63 n9l il m1h qs zg lm yw5 5j5 e4 tw6 omh dj 7pp rp brx ixd 8y0 m6b 7y7 oe 1n 20 49s f9a 2w uw ax1 wc jq yhz pm fy r2 vn 1l 71k wos 1u fx4 cr ng k15 wd 9bd 99 yr 9nz ih 07m b1 xb b0h l9d 5zh wrs a4 gu 00 vo 6g fs6 l7 59i lv n2z u3 ufn 7xr jl0 8cz 3h own 

Pentagon task force’s UFO report released – many cases remain unexplained

Task force reviewed 144 reports

CBS NEWS – BY NICOLE SGANGA, DAVID MARTIN, OLIVIA GAZIS AND ELEANOR WATSON

After decades of dismissing U.F.O. sightings popularized in American culture, a U.S. government task force assigned to investigate what it calls “unidentified aerial phenomena,” or UAPs, has found no evidence that objects came from outer space or a foreign adversary. 

However, while there’s no evidence the objects are extraterrestrial, senior government officials who briefed reporters said Friday that nearly all of the incidents investigated remain unexplained, citing the significant limitations of available data and reporting.

“Of the 144 reports that we are dealing with here, we have no clear indications that there’s any non-terrestrial explanation for them,” a senior government official said, nixing the possibility of exotic sightings. “But again, we will go wherever the data takes us on this.”

In fact, officials were able to identify just one reported UAP with a high degree of confidence. “In that case, we identified the object as a large, deflating balloon,” the 9-page unclassified version of the report released by the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI) read. “The others remain unexplained.”

“The limited amount of high-quality reporting on unidentified aerial phenomena (UAP) hampers our ability to draw firm conclusions about the nature or intent of UAP,” the report said, noting later that “no standard reporting mechanism” existed before the Navy created one in March 2019.

Most of the incidents the task force reviewed were reported in the last two years, according to the report, which is a preliminary version of an assessment.

The U.S. government officials said there is no doubt that identified UAPs were physical objects, tamping down speculation that sightings could be optical illusions caused by atmospheric conditions or sensor malfunctions. 

“From a safety of flight issue, we absolutely do believe that what we are seeing are not simply sensor artifacts. These are things that physically exist,” a senior government official said. “They are physical objects.” But officials stressed that objects detailed in the 144 reports represent a “variety” of phenomena.  

In 80 of the 144 investigated incidents, the task force detected objects using multiple sensors, leading officials to determine UAPs posed a hazard to flights. Over the years, the task force determined there have been 11 near misses.

According to the unclassified report, investigators found “[v]arious forms of sensors that register UAP generally operate correctly and capture enough real data to allow initial assessments, but some UAP may be attributable to sensor anomalies.”

Congress in December asked the Pentagon’s Unidentified Aerial Phenomena Task Force (UAPTF), along with the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI) and other intelligence agencies, to submit a report on what is known about UAPs; relevant committees received a classified version of the report on Friday, before the unclassified version was publicly released.

Officials poured over 144 incidents between 2004 and 2021, relying heavily on observations made by military aviators. 

Without evidence that UAPs are operated by an adversary like China or Russia, government officials say there is no reason to believe that a foreign power has made a technological breakthrough in recent years.

“A small portion of the data set has propulsion we cannot explain,” a senior government official said. “That doesn’t necessarily mean that there is an adversary that is introducing a technological surprise here.”

The report found that 18 objects investigated had propulsion systems that could not be explained, due in part to insufficient data and reporting. It said that the task force was conducting “further analysis” to determine if advanced technologies were present. 

It also said that, if and when the incidents could be better assessed, they would likely fall into one of five explanatory categories, including airborne “clutter” like birds and plastic bags, atmospheric phenomena, domestic technologies, foreign technologies, and a catchall “other” category. 

Officials stressed, as does the report, that they were limited in their analysis by the nature of the data underlying the incidents, which came chiefly in the form of verbal reports that were only occasionally supported by video or photographic evidence. The task force has since begun work on a new mechanism through which they hoped to standardize data collection on UAPs and apply scientific and engineering approaches to their explanation, they said.

“Ultimately, we have to increase the volume as well as the quality of the data we have,” one official said. 

Despite a dearth of data, the task force investigation did reveal “UAP sightings tended to cluster around U.S. training and testing grounds,” though officials conceded the high-concentration of reported incidents could be “collection bias as a result of focused attention, greater numbers of latest-generation sensors operating in those areas, unit expectations, and guidance to report anomalies.”

Lawmakers who received the report also said more work was necessary to understand any potential national security threats posed by the phenomena. 

“The United States must be able to understand and mitigate threats to our pilots, whether they’re from drones or weather balloons or adversary intelligence capabilities,” said Senator Mark Warner, Democrat of Virginia and Chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee. “Today’s rather inconclusive report only marks the beginning of efforts to understand and illuminate what is causing these risks to aviation in many areas around the country and the world.”

“This report is an important first step in cataloging these incidents, but it is just a first step,” said Republican Senator Marco Rubio, who as Acting Chairman of the Intelligence Committee authored the language mandating the report. “The Defense Department and Intelligence Community have a lot of work to do before we can actually understand whether these aerial threats present a serious national security concern.

The officials told reporters a “majority” of the information included in the classified report was presented in the unclassified version. They said neither agency would be releasing any supplementary evidence, including photos or video, of the phenomena the report had assessed.

Limited information about the UAPs has trickled out over the last few months. The Defense Department task force confirmed in April that the scope of its work includes objects described as a “sphere,” “acorn,” “pyramid” and “metallic blimp” by military personnel.

In May, CBS News’ “60 Minutes” spoke with naval aviators David Fravor and Alex Dietrich, who had never before talked publicly about their encounter in Southern California in 2004 that was visible on their radar and on video when they were flying in the Nimitz carrier strike group. They observed an object that looked like a Tic Tac moving over whitewater in an otherwise calm blue sea. 

The two said that they saw the object, about the size of their F/A-18F, but with no markings or wings and also without exhaust plumes, mimicking the movements of their own plane.

“Oh there’s, there’s definitely something that … I don’t know who’s building it, who’s got the technology, who’s got the brains. But there’s — there’s something out there that was better than our airplane,” Fravor told “60 Minutes” correspondent Bill Whitaker.  

The report, while brief and inconclusive, is nonetheless a notable disclosure for the U.S. military and intelligence community after years of downplaying and discrediting accounts of UFOs, as they were more commonly known, and “flying saucers.”

A senior government official conceded “historical socio-cultural stigmas” attached to UFOs posed a challenge to the task force, which had sorted through evidence gathered over the years without a clear standard for collection. 

“Really, that stigma creates an additional challenge to timely and standardized reporting,” the official said. “We applaud the UAP task force’s work in this area as a means towards improving our available datasets and our understanding over time.”

Banner image: Off the coast of Jacksonville, Florida (2015)

0 Shares
Tweet
Share
Share
Pin