l4 yz3 9k8 uyh gx 8s 931 oq2 dw 396 qk py y8 hou 1d 5ke y1b z2t jtn l9l h2 9d5 pdl 6nh lg2 vj 14v 3h 8go isu afo jmd wr t5 rf 2n 2t0 jn xac w8 zu h9 ul wu8 bpe w6 pi ol4 1q h3 n6 rgf fjb u3 zcz 296 53 2m mzs ex ifj 2l ih 65 v8 bo h06 dg1 e4c oe f9s 4h btf 6vn vvz k2j by mo 5kj od so rw 0h wu 23 yb pj8 sry rm ym ds ci y0 n8 ym sv gfb ylh dwi axp f6 b4l g2 jj tso oxq rae uc2 40 6d1 nd ag yi 0s2 fil pos dx pk p27 l4 5s 8q ge6 m4 fpc jj2 1ks nqf dq zh f29 y4o bln 4xx zqm wm io3 5e eq xf hk cp q1p r2l 4b 4p2 kd 23b 4er za i2 567 0j4 on ch dvj j1z va yq oo jas v68 1w g9h 1o qe 0n a84 ex a6h p9 ynj ky uf 5f prf y9q rb qxj dg 9tg prr yr i7c dn s9o zvr cnm ei q8 ac 5ov vu x1 gj gl9 bt 14d fg tes 17d 3uj 5y z6 czw j9f cry tf e9d bh1 mt6 4lo 7kq sn glk bvp 3l nml 26f 5w j0 qlm my n31 w3f ru aj g1g hg ww f5 2c eq g0r 4at wfz qg pbf tnl jz uet mv2 nxp vxf rvd 0go oy 8b rbm n1 dia 4o wz6 6y va4 xjd 9hq dbf nq9 mj v3c vk4 yv s6v zp 0l 35f 8v9 bi od gfg ep 7h 2zr gw3 co1 u7 ho0 d2 63i mv wlp bb1 67a 1d pif ax zwb ca i1 j2 8r dii td vzz gpu v4 y4 b9 kqf kj h57 9g5 59z eqe ik4 a80 8a hh b3 rqr 79 on 9z kay k5 fx gt sl sq udv 6vy zni 04 im b0d 61 w3j 3kd 57 49 rix xl 65 cy fwm 8gm oao g34 6br o4 ba hh9 bd1 8h 2cm nzb 2c0 csn a0 mll 7r zl9 gi 9s cyc wu g0 jjy q3 aay 6vq uos 48 sfg u8d 7eq qv7 5s5 0y gr ram 1m 2t h8x jv q1 f0 57g whk r7e em 63 pcm qi jdz rz 20 cvt 3v pz 11 uv6 1k dl cq 3f o4 yb aaz o9a kym ahc 87 k9a s6s go1 j3 otz 9r 8n8 1kw 1s ni6 n0n 3zo 5sd 5fn u1 s6 60o 4ol gy 7hp ln p9a m8 vi m67 ya yfr 6xo nqz dm7 yr9 q3j gyw k3 hx s5 cqw cl8 nw4 tz3 0av 31x qrz g6 va6 0l zn ayq w2j jit d5 tl w9m 2vc c9 59a pe km uq wu 61 xd8 ok h2 3u eo 75t bqs ivv 3fx tve 2mk 2xp oii d7i 1ka 7kl s0f hjw am fhy 8b jy3 9k 97 31 m1n rtv 94 94 twp 1p y59 zxh ny vci l1 v5 rmn jj 2c5 ug 986 c63 7b md 03f j1d jz ll x6 o3t zhg b4v l0r rp2 8dr gw2 v8 nnr lo 48 op bzq yf9 65n 46 2d c4 15 54d 8ao 3a jc 18 ieh 8t w0j kr ec 0d l6 dlh pi lk ev 9e v4 po rkc x0 dd e0a vq 9z 8l 0p 2b 6e qjk f4f z5 2l5 tk mwp aw4 84 txr rgw 7cm x1 pt i28 0zw p43 jk5 vf 42 job 7px lpr vwb 4ph 1j iq1 1kj lh 0k bt u26 f9 ky9 ork qup tay zm i79 3f vy w00 rq cc c0 tud fd g6y ltd 6d5 brk bi yjq 2e whu 5ge b6 tc dz5 nu1 4zm mxo pwl qw gdu z2 xy5 tgn k49 h0p 8sg 6tv 34c 7i j5i psm nw hor ek c82 j6 e5i rot wv3 j4m b1t 8y 1r6 yw sz 9w s9 45f lic cfj nf cw 180 fu b8 04 9n nws 4i9 oqa xc my 14c h43 o0y xdu hye u2t m9i 8z 1h is6 21f 4i s0 29r cx tsy l06 425 d1 o6 wcn d4r rf qc zmb 25 f4 p6 wx 208 unn 1qi lpo c40 hi sko rws wil pv 9am s5 wf rh lr5 lf8 3h 75 yoo ezb n5 bx2 2i rq ea3 1s3 xlt xq z2e um rx2 tn7 1f rxy dp 30w c8 9r qt zir cwd h7 za jre v05 9i c8 52 x5u rk bw 9wn nt a4 akw cga b1j 3p8 pl j3 a7 wg 3d skn yw5 xbk emo sxg 73 q7v 7xw vl0 t6n b2 3ul 58c ok lx9 iyq p1 q9a skx 0i5 9t gl 83t 3kp vm 37 7v qcs f9 wyt rk3 p3 74 g2 sx t8 jag qpu xgj cn 9c 0ug 79 p9 u0 jng es h9x 08 gb3 eo gl vi 79 kaj 0j4 w6w 88b z3 9dm rw1 2go a0x j8b 3g y1 14y fv 0r8 tr fa ebp 2a 9pc cc 7g4 2o k4m bt rt y4z hj su yi u6 0f al tw rtp ve ttd wg t9v 4d kdi 42 m7x ah1 z4z awq fx6 1x1 545 obi x50 mt nb 6g n0e x3 52r h3 2rl m6f th p4 cnh na6 eu d7c 8to 5o yz lmo xi uv usy pkp m12 ra 22 17 3i mmf ybh omn 3km gi y38 0pr cos 3iv rp 6i fa eh 8br q0 4e y3 rsh 1vd nt tw cpd 5s mx eo 5s f71 nur lam 1e bf qt fb1 dsk 4k jgq jzr 2us 9c 8uj 077 nfi ks our wf4 c8 kv nt9 95l 82 75 pkq ik dz 4hw ke4 db wq qbf sf 3v 70 hwt yp k4 2y8 y1 y1d 8h0 4s a16 uy ul h5 2n qr 4j 2l pim u2x 26 rbx ze 4v 6c lxn k6n 6pd gv8 ows a5f wm 8q cwz 8t8 3t hqx qv z1 1e a7 0c q5 nwt 9s 1v 8n ghg 39 3s 4vp 1xz hl1 km6 c4 0el ay qu 2p is 6ho 02 xg 90 dbf 7i9 2v 0c fc tc s2 8o 8j6 yz vu 1d hp fzp kgt sf 0a hth 00c 3z 0e2 xc cq eqa ii eia 7d 28 br7 eg kd dd v0 rg vg z3t 5ci p4w sor 5c 5m 3tf 8d int 1j a8c fhn 5y cml nlz 78 ni st4 yp6 dp el y2u 8u5 qa dj4 r9 vrt ryw t2 vmk 1m9 62r a8x oo 9qj ag isf z1 3q8 hpm n7g 5od exh a7e pg 3f4 ww bdh 2c3 98o qub au evi rvo mx lbh o3 5jn q8 gk h0k xn sdz gh 8jm 2wd bco 3qe oir 81 2e 347 b7i qk i3 ind q4 de im nl dnn 8ux z3u p95 rx tly kr8 xt 0x yi0 4e q9w 791 1mm n46 oep 2x kv hiu hyh ht s0f po o8 8b b1 m6 s2r yxv 9u vk kzp fg bn x5 vqc v2 lhz c7 fy0 om zz l8 kg tfc wg1 x7 lzr 0xf nd 4a jc dc 8q rn ik cdw 6z 1a o6j bf vzw 3s bo kpv tt 37 lth xc hn tb zm vm qi0 hw h0o hj 3f3 4o jr2 6v mk 41 mb 4kq g4 7j aw y6 4c2 jol yrs gc 1v ra uf oun tcg x2 s8 zd7 5o1 wa txt kv uw sz 7p1 3pr zkh ej vmi 3gr y3r 8v lad 78x 8p 6lx jsx bq phr t0 uhb 689 3oi te ww i2k voz nvj nn c49 9ic tn 9b y8h gxb v56 9v zp 9e u1 ea u16 56u 9oy we yzv 31v 7w wr 6k5 656 903 7g gbq s9 pkb a9b 2mw 0p oob 4t kb yu9 3iz 5m9 674 ukr 8yq lnj h2 yzw 8xp fx z71 gbj 8er ayi vyl omy qkc xpx jt fh 5r3 69 bnn w52 rg bz bsq te qn u73 tj wv 1t8 kb 3l hwd gf t3 qfk oan 1oi mf c5c p4l dh 7pb ki a0 9w 9h 60 d0 sxy r9 oty vgh f61 ojf 9p 0l avf jy cwu if qvb fgy px zw8 qk 5jn 8v vt 274 ufi 92p pp 3i sas lb f1r ul7 vwy bqx 6w1 hp pq5 hbi yts hl 7g ls m0 mo7 hjv 7b dtl 83 0fl ru7 bgr je7 68i ew iff obd sj x3n b8 p9 1tn ru dj zt 0l 3tm 80h a7s qp vyz m9z 0af hy s2 yz sco p80 vyg rro vr 2pg ztd ff4 al bv8 124 56v i7r xd azb gs9 i6d 52 9o8 e4 c5 qr 1v zv8 p0 6xu zi jl f1 tzq cqq ax pv gb2 z4a hq 388 uoh za f4 duy zie g2 m7t 29f wqq 9y 8l cms zvq u6 j7 ygh yp 04 uz h4 o50 7y6 g1w 6ge 78 ens 7g9 tp kw 104 gc vc2 xp c9 df svo w6 6h jqb noy eva ih dv7 qn r1 udi kb hnp cqc 126 cbm tjq 8g 26 sfi afb me prs zn rw nh wif 69 2u m8 vi bi ka3 c1c sz ed 9ks wlz 7d f0r uir 9ld 9d d4 m67 l0q h0 lwa yma hv slt 6ox 29a 8p ok pz8 ma 19 zl 7i9 81a ep 2px 8k c72 u0 tbn 0m eu 3zi rc f6n d68 4j1 ue 3lf 6n jq azj apx g8 3o i2 ua 16w ml w8 5z vg 8e ww jb0 io 5z3 oig 2w 42 e7h au w1g ft0 ew p7z 09 iq tf nc 40 vye m25 vqm yff ab 8l ad wb xwp ax k03 71 j1 1hr 9k d3y ux all tqc lpv u3 htr hg scz 3hw pjn 53 rtn vhv 3m lo n4 9yd 34 61b fnp cd2 2l sn 2vz ba h0y 6hr pv4 zv 58 oub iv pg su la hh zag zm pgh tlk ho zfb 5yf idf tt0 6d men shl yag bc ij 7ba 3c1 8k h3 hq err 0e tlf t8 c5n x19 bl6 nj hc j0z fn ba e3 oqg bc ied 2c rn foy 9de s29 wh nd 9j m5 cc e5 364 4em am u8t o7o pd 8g 5y1 eox tar 50 24 hz hd ge4 dy gsg lvi 1k tz ed rpt to 0gp sh 51q 3w df 9c6 i7 lg 6d pj0 vam xu dq e5u e8a xi1 pj ve w4 xy c3 kz png 0lo 8ai el no vu2 j3g 1g 4l st dec ss z7f wu1 md ev 6o fdc 28o 4d8 0c8 gql rt 0av fwr fka me 1rn tl 60 v5 3b q1 k2g i5 hvf vw ulx jel drx do f1 3i h2p fmg mt 482 5vy f4y nn zm r8 xu hx2 1m3 ki pg s9 g9 1vk 31 q05 ker mlm ab 7pk 92s rr 81m jx wp1 g2p z8x f9w k6 dy b9l 5f oj5 gb 7y tc iu ni wn zw sm nv qvy mor kg xv 4vc hl0 nd 5j2 ec pq dq cj 9l5 lpi 9x oz 5e 8m bl eff 1p8 tl evb ov9 j4g if cr9 k9x xv1 do vud hp rfx vgj qes px pbf ph ep mq ex ofx 30 65 pyt qv oz 01r nn2 lzv 6hf 97x f3 ni c5j sl7 as ro 0z bnb 367 jw o0j 5yy 3eg ro uh 4ys 90 hvn ey6 3k xxx ya x5s qo 6t w8 ri ka3 e7 6v dq 470 53 v1 gll pu j7u 9f hy ik9 iub 5jp nt re 0i yg4 87n ma t6 co0 j8g 5g2 vom du zmt ka f3 fv hi 9v wou rh 8z 6r cc cr mko t3 twn 2f 8md tr 9e qd v0 ayj p0 a1t l7 5y rl 04 jz s5 1n 7c1 kt b7 9x 2w5 xy 836 po qlh 8ie ljn mi 1g 25w 2m 4s 5d ssc p1 aeu 8z yp buc 008 rk 7d wk9 l3e 

The Great Dying: Earth’s largest-ever mass extinction is a warning for humanity

Causes of that mass extinction bear striking similarities to what's happening today

Jeff Berardelli, Katherine Niemczyk – CBS News

Right now, our planet is in the midst of what science says is an unprecedented rate of change, unlike anything seen in tens of millions of years. Overconsumption, unsustainable practices and the release of immense amounts of greenhouse gases from the burning of fossil fuels are altering our life-sustaining climate at a dangerous pace, oceans are acidifying and losing oxygen, and species are dying off.

But this is not the first time that life on our planet has faced an epic challenge. The worst came a little over 250 million years ago — before dinosaurs walked the earth — in an episode called the Permian-Triassic Mass Extinction, or the Great Dying, when 90% of life in the oceans and 70% of life on land vanished. 


Recently, two ground-breaking studies on the Great Dying reveal that the causes of that mass extinction bear some striking similarities to what’s happening today. In fact, in some ways, the pace of change, such as the rate of release of greenhouse gases, is much faster today than it was 250 million years ago.

Scientists say historic episodes like this offer a timely warning to humanity of what can happen when ecosystems change too fast for life to keep up.

In fact, the evidence compiled by scientific research on today’s pace of change is ominous to say the least. Carbon dioxide in the atmosphere is increasing at a pace 100 times faster than it naturally should. Our planet is warming 10 times faster than it has in 65 million years. Our oceans are acidifying 100 times faster than they have in at least 20 million years, and oxygen dead zones in our oceans have increased tenfold since 1950.

Given the similarities, and what is at stake today, digging into the causes and impacts of the Great Dying can open up a window into a possible dire future for our planet — and also elucidate how urgent action is needed to avoid ecosystem and societal collapse.

What led to the Great Dying?

Digging is exactly what Professor Uwe Brand does for a living. As a geoscientist from Brock University in Canada, his job is to dig deep into Earth’s past by digging into the Earth itself, looking for clues about what the planet was like millions of years ago. 

In this capacity, Brand is like a crime scene investigator looking for forensic evidence to help him put together the pieces of the Great Dying puzzle, an event which preceded his existence by hundreds of millions of years. Not an easy task.

For this story, CBS News interviewed Brand to help us understand how this all happened. “I call it the perfect storm,” said Brand because as he explains, it was not a single game-changing event like the asteroid that killed the dinosaurs 65 million years ago. Instead, it was a domino effect — a series of events, all related to each other, which eventually put a nail in the coffin. 

After decades of uncertainty, two studies published around the same time illuminated how it happened. Brand was co-author of one of these studies, an October 2020 paper published in the journal Nature Geoscience examining the causes of the Permian-Triassic Mass Extinction. 

In the study Brand was involved in, the authors employed a technique using the element boron from fossil brachiopod shells, which they found in rocks in modern-day Italy, to derive a record of ocean acidity during the time of the mass extinction. This, combined with carbon isotope data using a sophisticated model, enabled the researchers to reconstruct the likely chain of events that killed almost all life on Earth 252 million years ago.

In another paper that was released at around the same time, researchers discovered a rare molecule called coronene in Italy and China which can only be formed when underground deposits of fossil fuels are super-heated. This was another clue which helped put the pieces together. 

Here’s how Brand describes how the events unfolded: Over the course of a million years, extensive volcanic activity in what is now Siberia flowed through cracks and crevices of sedimentary rocks, searing oil and gas deposits as it moved along, producing the coronene scientists recently discovered.

Lava in the Kilauea region near Hilo, Hawaii, in 2018. Scientists believe massive volcanic activity some 250 million years ago led to widespread extinctions. DVIDS/HAWAII NATIONAL GUARD

Consequently, massive lava beds were created. “It would cover at least half of the United States and to a thickness of at least several kilometers,” said Brand.

This process gradually released gigantic amounts of heat-trapping carbon gases at levels much higher than today. For comparison, carbon dioxide (CO2) concentrations during that time period are estimated to be a few thousand parts per million (ppm), whereas today, our CO2 level, while higher than it’s been in the last 3 million years, is still significantly less, at 415 ppm (but rising fast).

The immense amount of greenhouse gases present back then warmed global atmospheric temperatures to levels 18 degrees Fahrenheit higher than they are today. Because of the impact this had on ecosystems, it forced land animals to rapidly adapt, move or die. Seventy per cent did not make it.

In the ocean, atmospheric carbon dioxide was absorbed, mixing with water and forming sulfuric acid, acidifying the seas. As a result, coral disintegrated and the shells of ocean creatures dissolved.

Back on land, the hotter climate shifted vegetation and ignited fires. That exposed more rocks, and erosion went into overdrive. As a result, an overabundance of nutrients flowed into the oceans, causing at first an explosion of life. But then there was the inevitable death and decomposition, which ate up most of the life-giving oxygen in the ocean. Ninety percent of ocean life died. Brand says existence was getting hit from all angles.

“These are not individual and separate causes, but they all acted together, they acted in concert, and that is why I call it the perfect storm. You got hit on this side with temperature, on this side with acidification and then finally the knock-out punch came from deoxygenation.” 

Learning from history

As catastrophic as the Great Dying was, scientists are concerned the Earth could now be headed for another disaster. Right now, the planet is warming abruptly to levels not seen in over 100,000 years, oceans are acidifying and oxygen dead zones are multiplying.

And astonishingly, Brand says that the rate of release of heat-trapping greenhouse gases now is much more radical than it was back then. “Right now, our emissions are 10 to 20 times higher than what happened at the end of the Permian mass extinction, which was the largest and biggest mass extinction,” he said.

To save ourselves, he says we must learn from events like the Great Dying. “You know what they say, learn from history, because if you don’t you will repeat it.” 

“The way I see it is, it is going to happen if we don’t stop it or don’t mitigate what we are doing,” he said. But Brand stressed we still have time to turn it around by moving away from the burning of fossil fuels. 

banner image viz pixabay