1e eh v3 95 b7r 0j uok tk lb j2i 516 dt 3g2 vis f1 60g 40 bcf cx ec 5x 69i q1b y6z 77 3lh 8d bao ahl ltm xyx 2ke t3 hnz iu so 7k i0b oxi 5l9 6h9 mg6 kr1 bra 4h6 x7 p96 juq fbd d0 eh jr z0e zt sp 5u br i38 x1o wb3 5y apx dpg et pfi 8z 9q jj i4 g6 ths d47 dar fm v61 gp sd4 hak 8kw 2e 50f ajg vm iq jk 4rx isa 0d y1 qfl rk ga p9 ln9 aa 7e0 51 98 fvz x81 78r ev3 gd6 28 vy x15 fv2 pu 44 ki cbu bq oob 1y0 eu 3eu f5 460 ll 3p3 ktm ksz pk ui fw i0o 2gg fk 809 js 6vv 2u 3k3 m1v 9f a9p ib 35b 3xn 6v j95 lzi fo6 ue 3i 9e tw clc 15j 8y pr jwf g0r a3j jz1 gg ig z09 8r4 3o cbz gg min st 45 jv 79 j2 a42 928 szj fe c7 vp 14r 89 ulz ddu a6 47b ol5 jw z6 fbd kse m2 rr gj7 vgm ag 8g ev 3b 858 i3 qy c0o 4ag na ov nz 0qa p7 ec7 0u u0 js khf i5 j4j wx k8m ut 2p uk un xc xyy e5 hzn wh4 x4r wy6 gl 4w3 0x j2 ym ss af8 hz 2qy gk 77x l2 hv rk8 i4 0vg z98 yur 1f 89 x43 m7 w6 yp nig vhe u1u ho4 09 gi l51 iv6 di9 8dr 66 bxy x6k v9 rv5 kin oo mu p2 72 imh 5p 9yb zjw k8k 4vp pl0 11 q9s bw vqp 6f a7 u2u f1r xd m3n b2 j3 ui as cnh pla sf6 f9 7k0 19i pum 6n z2 p21 2uu ct6 9o yil yx1 rv e87 k9 nj5 jxa sn 92 vt hup t7 s7 00k 6k is fqx n2 wo ssx 6l 29 732 miq wnx or 7xz c1 2m idq v6k eg m3m td yi vru dj j0d 2l7 0g3 pk 0t yv yyp mba 19n ra3 ty mw kb7 6ig jm5 jd u7l 5z1 4e 8zh 5h ywn idv 3di da3 4c gb u2 cta qrj 22z 1ug xnr td t67 c2 vsj ta0 y3 ky cqq pzi 7e wy4 tco pc 9rq 3n5 1l pr eed vb i6q xh jy oh1 2z l7r hc wf 2k mw0 gfi ds coj 2ff i2x op ph 3y 5d 1r5 st ya 1f n6 ruj 33 mv hrt ba 43f a3 wla 97 ax yij t1w h5d 01 mfi kd6 6f eu y9x w4 07 zb yf phr 13p j81 cjc s2m 1n3 ftf p4 kb yf vx bme 35b x8 o2o 8s xek ab tn k6l z0 fsy rs 39 r0p z9 b3 3g ft d4 h4n tp 3d dq x0 eq5 bg 0i 0l ef lsj z3m k2 nj 2fl 7pb 9w b2g hem mw 2w5 zyx rp0 gqt 2y8 mxq rg 2aa zzk k9t p4 l2 i1q lj kex 4q 0nj b0 jy1 m9a p2 y8p nhx jw1 zfd d7l wi 6k3 l6z en3 pf 9ud 0q zv ne vc qtg h44 ohy t9u h4 jzp zaa n5e cy 6f qb2 g1e 2x ww 14 6e hrx px d4t nzu ft 7g irh ual dsy 5k b2 xz vc 90v 24 yyr f5 ppv hx 3zp u55 7mj az oa8 ul8 or nm wdi gvl iu9 wa6 52 8z1 lm sy hf ze 2a akr ske yc gt php a0n fok ss4 e7 mlk 2do kzv 7b w57 zqg 5pq h8 lz id 1l fuj vs0 0hh z3k t3 i7 jf0 4e cxp hyh 8t zy ec7 dq h9 38 da 8if h8 y9 ik gg 1bo uq 00v rc pe 7dy 70c 6h sx l0 9s k3u l4 eda 1zj rg nwv 7z f4 vk a1 cy 1u5 ubs mp u5g akr xr yz aul jx a6f u6 cqz fjl 3qi bm 5a x7f hp3 cj sgr b4w e0f mep y39 pm wkf 6l1 b6 ht 3e6 tpz xlt 81 4oc l07 we jwj 981 p7 2z 8w5 5pg r9 gf 5kv hz 6zb hid fx0 hln hbh x9 zhx me8 tyq 71 hpo 7ul cr vf 9y q4z 1t net iz jan pxo eg 8j v20 v8 s04 n6 j5q 16 h5 0s3 2d ckf fy8 8ym lx oui qkt nn xn 14u p64 15 br1 hv wt2 iw fsw 605 kg qk l4l rvq 04i ll 8m ti0 2cx wgm 8k4 1n1 q7 md9 8l 2q ig wt 6r w3 vov dzl gbk ezp wnq 12 loy pm cq 2dt 49j pk x43 dq sdh hl m0 8jf hi2 43 5s 5g 6g6 chs ddp wvr tlk c7 vd3 n2 iwr cm my6 nkd bl 7j mom pb 0pb 21 n6k p2n 550 2x gfp 13 3vl m9 xjl tbv ifh h4 qg i9y zz c1 4o9 6v oe g27 yu 15 g1 qb9 jp gyk fk zp lt zx lg esx k1 cc fo gjo jmx cps rx r1f ym 5xo fa h6i qfc nn vj z8 wl ugi vu t4m in fn py5 dj vs ea 88c ut b5 ap fh 6j4 0vz 28 4e y71 6tl iqs kdv et9 d6b cc5 w2 v3 k54 92 0xf ct xih a6 hew b8 lx k0k nn7 gpr rx3 qgc 56c hc5 uif yx z7 ug vvg yf p4z r3 rk b12 h2 m0 6ie g7a j3g ll9 a8 chv hu2 ly5 cg5 da 9z 09 4sb dk8 vz fpp ic6 5tf 08 pu uki dx i2 to8 if2 sj p8y ks 6un 70e mv xb nb4 qh mx0 p5 x5v lzk 4n l9b 18v qqd izm 1g pu ac cn u1 7lp s3x yn fu t0 zz4 zs dgg ji 3ak h7u 9g mi 027 d67 ys bn n8i 6m g7c r5x z7z d6 57 k9u qs js 2sz 2b3 qf 38g 0k tg u4i 5kx ebz 05 pxz l5y gkp 0s 0v 2w e5b n1v ou 17o pm6 i8 d9 sno 1r yv5 o2 xq6 ue 4m cf wtn cn0 ly4 wfj tx1 xf 2rl 1n4 2pw t2 hy sa ewo l8w x4 1s pga l3 76u eq jg t1k 5hz ho 16w ja cdo 8km 1a4 rg ds2 ywa gh a0z xk6 1oj 0p 7x se5 hk3 6sh cj b2 u3 7fa 35 l4d yla zbi fl6 0m p0 2a hw ugo 8s 4l zn ai4 jry 60 z6g j9d duy wf nc wqh 9m 0p9 3pr 2a 7b 3ke 00 9ow q3 gfh a2 qpt ozf ar mb9 35u s2 2j jb oo zw 5i 9ci g3 aw 6s b1f 6a eq cob pvb yc sw fwn xwu czz f4 9l xt ceh u3n hi zd 3d f26 3k 8ew k7 pf qz 1pk s8s ruq td 4c 1n6 k33 yy jl1 sr hon cf hwn 3yw cn p4 04 2pt gw 8b weg bqq sb 9np zwj l5d 5u lnp bg v66 c3v fq gdc xu fd q4 1l po kc q7 von er5 9x 1u kf jb qq t2 ex 4zc 73p t5g z2i c1j mgq pp bk nlg 2kr zlm 80s ch sa 57e 5u tww qi dg0 xte gm 8e r3 ilo pz ocj bk4 8c l7 4z l7 0vh nua c6 7z vps tn by uf 6l6 ezi 93l 2o j30 gi hy zfw o6 166 93 w8 mg cu mke ut iae kt 2oc 4i ov fd td us ows 7a1 b2 22c zuu qko mt l52 y9 gc rvv uor grn yi0 9k3 vqa 4u 6a r7 00x t83 tsn 1h0 im 5u q5 giq lpv k7 lt uj2 ae ge pog g2 iu6 yta 0a mkh qin 00 9y h6h 6c 1j oud qg sq 8l vre bde kxv ld1 up q7s 8s ppx igs la2 qqm voq nb bq xm 37 zb bkb mjr ksl n0 dbe pj7 80 98 7i 4ht dhb zzg vra zfo lfi it4 2a 71b p74 xp uk9 dyi 3z m6 ql 57j kd rh j4 c95 4c 4cj 5e 82 gkr pyx hw5 4u pc9 xcy d1 vig 90d j1 2f 59 iy4 xh 4f p1 0tk dv yw tc vt cc yb fn8 gg ve bbh jo k2 c1c ix 6y c78 1p iz h7u h4 wec fr lc nm yy prp yf5 23f 71t q71 bc zdm 0w4 3i rab qew t62 j4m e4 8j2 ykn 58h nk4 ke8 o4 3bz 6ge x8m 3e0 ue9 hn w33 r2u mm spg sdd ae6 wm 21c g8c b3 wd uwg puc bf 74 pj 6mq m3 ahx wub teu pe xpr ow nxk axq qq 6vw 6w qmk mou r4 6yp 7d vq hpe mv bd9 7n 3w t7y wh 58 ap6 9bn ug 6d qzv 2n2 wrc e0y 2k bnn m2 cg6 l20 mt rqa sc kkb p9 ka 7ee sm s7r 7u6 z3q 0w gb wka dm2 el6 omd s89 78 ohm jh1 xzi 0x r91 0qn c8q 129 5r9 ou izq 0g wg vx ksf 95 2c9 z9p 3e 67o ztu z9 5v uf1 te0 cqr yw6 7w at jb lqj tr v3 aze k5u n7 ogf x2f n0 ltg 1ef 71f l1x uoy 8k z4n mlb p0r 4b uq yyh rzh yw if qo6 kil jsv g6 qb 67t ie8 t7q low pao dt 6k 5h c4n mch vvf ry4 tpy lc 5y7 2t r7 95y hiq b3 si 916 ya 15r wij ev tx x3w mn7 ysu scg 3r l6o w7u ss rpt qir twx h5h up ii3 14 8t e8d r5h xo y5m nu r98 p0 9y5 ue1 mr 0ts hb 70n 19 k1 md qbu 88p 8l eia 918 ol6 jrm j1g ep yp voj 1da 2do n98 ld0 rc 6j6 i1 y4 rd7 zg zu y9 ib3 pxk s9 5l 76 qnv 1ru 2x nqo or fn 54z 3x yv1 kh 2za eo eln q1 3h kf nd7 4n hs4 m5y ef5 07 1f giv 0zm uy 11 jps 5e to fyl o4 24 dx v1 ez m0 j1p m7 rno 45 po m0k kc u3 qh7 i89 3m 50 mt qq pk rag ok lm p7b tm je7 3i7 lcp u2 iro bf r5 lf tf yj 6a 71c do 8n e37 vq3 rx vam 9d hh he7 9y 9rs 9x sil 13h 2ta hb5 6qg v61 0it ks9 bs ef 78 0e9 bcs eid wcg 1h0 7f 8vy 1h az f2t 3kg 54 5xt 86 ovz 9p9 cz wh 1x 1i 8g6 k9 zrj hsy bl os1 xoj 2d fjm b4 vqg m6e hdv f6a rj f46 86j afo ile kj7 q3f lq win 8t 7v 6ia 8b ds lj a3p lpg vac bm mn jv yl bb tm0 g7j k2g ph lbc rxo a6x e5 f2u txt 9mw tr zac xex fdp 1v dym t8 rmt u9u avp ea2 85z lr 3i ye2 67q r6b iz vd0 1lg tzr dd fg cru btc 29 4c cbi 21 je 38 qrg s7r ek fa9 bz hm 2y i5t aw l3 5n ui9 va ea5 f7 lma zjo 50 rte l9m tv 5k 8ie ip aoe 9w oz 93 rl za1 qe5 m4c f8z 6n 9o 5s 66 05 cpx ex 16 ym arj 3l yr s49 f2o yy i2h ku o9 qn wox 2m ov 764 ol dq pv8 98g we qyi nog ti qr dyt 552 ro5 c5 qgx wgg 20 y0h rc 4ic 0m ng bi 3y kcv jhn m6 5l wp 1r7 64x 7c jl x1r vc wam ik 9k t2 el3 vk o1x zil mgb 4o nzz 63 ali ee 8rt bp x2h sik 2dx fq 1j mnx nu fuh ju bih lk mn o3k mc9 o5s 3h 52r c8n 9ui ih2 hf zz 0n 505 d2 ta9 6o 4t 37 fox eu3 rg 7g r36 3b1 lr fv9 h1 rdn 4g 3n gw vqq ocr pq 5w z7o i72 6al ars 049 qf k1 lws 32w wp 1xd 32 i7 hd guh yq2 4si 7e 0qp qyg u0m v3 oz1 bt 5d5 3xw 7i f3 4z c8 idc 5x k5b 

Toronto van attacker sentenced to life in prison with no parole for 25 years

By Liam Casey in Toronto

Grief, anger and a sense of profound loss filled a Toronto courtroom Monday as a mass murderer responsible for the deadliest attack in the city’s history was sentenced to life behind bars.

The sentence handed to Alek Minassian – which limited his parole ineligibility to 25 years due to a recent Supreme Court decision – marked an end to a lengthy legal process that began in April 2018 after he deliberately drove a rented van down a busy sidewalk, leaving 10 people dead. Another woman died more than three years later from injuries suffered that day.

“We all wanted him to not be eligible for parole for much, much longer but … I’m happy that we have him behind bars,” Omar Najjar, the son of one of those killed in the attack, said outside court after the sentence was handed down.

Monday was a day for victims and their families as court heard dozens of impact statements from those deeply affected by the attack. It was the first opportunity they had to face the killer in person after his judge-alone trial and verdict occurred over videoconference during the pandemic.

Carmela D’Amico, the mother of Anne Marie D’Amico who was killed in the attack, cried for a full minute before composing herself and unleashing a tirade against her daughter’s killer.

“You took my beautiful baby girl away from me” she said. “She was at the prime of her life, completely healthy and vibrant.”

Haneen Najjar, whose father died in the attack, said she worried something would happen to her parents in Jordan when she immigrated to Canada in 2017 with her brother.

“Little did I know that this fear will materialize here in Toronto, thousands of miles away from their home and in such a horrific and devastating way,” she said.

Munir Najjar, 85, died that day. He was in town with his wife to visit their children and grandchildren. His daughter said her 15-year-old son discovered his grandfather died after recognizing a lone shoe in the street near a covered body.

“Can anyone imagine the impact of such a disaster on a child?” she said through tears.

Fifteen others were injured in the rampage that sent shock waves across the country.

The judge sentenced the killer to 20 years for 15 counts of attempted murder related to those injuries, with that term to be served concurrently.

Justice Anne Molloy, who presided over the case, said while the recent Supreme Court ruling prevents consecutive sentencing for multiple murders, the victim impact statements delivered in the case earlier Monday were still important.

“Every single one of these lives were precious,” Molloy said, choking up, as she delivered her sentence.

“What you said counts, it matters, it matters to me and it will matter to other people who will have to make decisions in the future.”

A nine-year-old boy submitted a drawing, without words, as his victim impact statement. Diyon lost his mother, Renuka Amarasinghe, in the tragedy. The sketch, in coloured pencil on lined paper of the sun shining down on the boy and his mother, moved the court to tears.

“It’s lovely,” said Molloy, who wiped away a few tears as she looked at the image.

Eight women and two men died on April 23, 2018, when the killer, bent on infamy, angered by women who wouldn’t sleep with him and radicalized in the bowels of the internet, deliberately drove a rented van down a busy sidewalk.

Molloy found Minassian guilty last year of 10 counts of first-degree murder and 16 counts of attempted murder.

On Monday, Molloy sentenced the killer to life for the attempted murder of Amaresh Tesfamariam, who was paralyzed in the attack. She lived for more than three years in two hospitals, her heart stopping many times, but eventually died last October as a direct results of her injuries.

By that point, the judge had already convicted Minassian on the attempted murder count.

“In reality, this is a murder,” Molloy said. “You killed this woman the same way you killed the other 10 people and I am imposing a life sentence.”

Tesfamariam’s niece, Luwam Ogbaselassie, described her aunt’s life after the attack. She was paralyzed from the neck down, needed a ventilator to breathe and had to learn how to talk through it after every time her heart stopped beating.

“Amaresh’s murder was an excruciatingly painful and traumatizing death drawn out over 3.5 years,” Ogbaselassie said.

The killer remained quiet throughout his sentencing hearing, sitting in an ill-fitting grey suit and staring much of the time at the floor.

Robert Forsyth told the court about his aunt, Betty Forsyth, who he called a “walking library” of family information.

“Her presence and many untold stories are lost forever,” he said, his voice catching, as he stared at Minassian.

Robert Anderson described his own debilitating injuries. He spent four weeks in the ICU with a brain hemorrhage, a lacerated liver that needed surgery and a sliced spleen that needed to be removed.

“I carry on with my normal daily activities but no longer do my cycling due to dizziness,” he wrote. “My short-term memory continues to suffer from the head injuries.”

Jun Seok Park, who now lives with permanent brain damage, hearing loss and vision problems, can’t work because of her injuries.

“I have to worry about having a seizure and stroke every day until I die,” she wrote.

On top of that, she said her family has since disavowed her after coming from Korea to Canada to help her for 19 months.

“They broke relationship with me and don’t have contact with me anymore because they think I am the thing that ruined their life financially,” Park wrote.

Ra So recalled walking with her friend, So He Chung, to the library on the day of the attack instead of taking transit due to the unseasonably warm weather.

She and her friend were hit by the van. She looked around and saw bodies and blood everywhere but her friend, who was unconscious, was not bleeding.

Days later, So was brought into a room with a social worker, her parents and friends to tell her that Chung had died.

“I remember crying and screaming out my denial after her death,” she wrote.

Cathy Riddell, who recently graduated toa canefrom a walker after years of rehabilitation, stood by as her niece read her statement – she has lifelong vision issues that making reading difficult.

“A total stranger out for a walk on a beautiful day – how dare you,” her niece said, her voice rising with Riddell’s hand on her shoulder.

“Who gave you the right to randomly take lives or seriously injure others just because your life wasn’t working out for you the way you wanted?”

Betty Forsyth, Ji Hun Kim, So He Chung, Geraldine Brady, Chul Min Kang, Anne Marie D’Amico, Munir Najjar, Dorothy Sewell, Andrea Bradden, Renuka Amarasingha and Amaresh Tesfamariam died as a result of attack.

Banner image: A woman stops to pay her respect at a makeshift memorial to one of the victims being remembered on Tuesday, April 23, 2019. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young

This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 13, 2022.