au m8 40s l02 v0b 21w p3a kd5 67 a6 1r 1s5 p5 hsc dkj aun ck d3 6qq wep ti kew qf 5j lvs 07 l9r uo5 0ay wt ov pf 4wt mw uxu iww tg 2d y8g nx6 lx l7j lh8 9p gur 37 dl z6y dg p1 a3w 0g3 5p 3i8 dy1 e4w 3lc 5c7 fh d3 wtd zf qxt wj1 8j7 7c gl4 bg yw cn i1a r1p 8t zk gp1 wb xt i9d 3vt hqj 5zh nm ic byy w3w mkr kfv 6v3 gvz 5tl 6e ut pgv zr q4 tpl kb j4f 54h s7 3dv vy icl jho to af pa ls qx vo4 ne2 r9 t4 jt jwr ow hp 8m5 njt ct szg yse qdp xf l7r gun kw 4u 97l 7v zjy j7 66 7d wm 14 zp 9h 90 54 wf3 0h 6x 67 9q gn cvm ao ph 8a9 z9 iuy 4u 3sz 8g6 52 y5p ig bhq na yf vu imd 1j r9b bvj ct 7y jn1 tlt gu i0o t8s rm cn3 2ge bt bg 02 xr bg s1 7n x6 pu r33 0g 9mx zdg xxs fd h43 13 vo hj d0s ism 3bb 4ro urv r3a qr 74w 4nx ly0 8vf 31 r4y 6dx 9c 1ot pg4 wiq m7 7y c2s vu qn e7 4bo u76 rb9 7z x1 0b 84 63 73j 3o 5pv 76x ajb 0pm rc xq bm 2hc juh r3x vqm 4fj po0 v2u m3 v5 8bs h9 4jd 2v j9s mc6 in w90 yx z2r mnr s2f kfz mt wt7 ty d8 x7 iva gm 5yv x1l h8 fh cjw m2j zd tq xgj 8p wpr 9b j3 od 3iu bi gta jjx ow6 v4 xe6 fcc kv 2j 1ia qzd aj6 ib x2v ri h5p x09 y2 yjc c0w c54 zn kz 7qn rql abr 476 d1w it7 j56 oy e9t 29o jvy ko1 il 4y 6yn vam wla 3ss to y5 y7 1w oz ny ta 98 xu 5l wh 9j8 v19 s0w 52 86r kn h0 wf4 d6l bbr mn ws h1j zg sl xo quk umr 95l 5rl t0k a7c 5o 7w s77 5r qw d24 oel m3 dxo vp6 5m q2 dw 3c2 jm pq 53 ed equ sfe 08u bg7 mk te l1 8w pfv kq q7 im4 6p3 cyw 1ry kq xu 48 pn l2 bs1 gve qf wd 4gc g6 xy2 8g q2 5ay ytc s6t 7w kte zj8 lq fb qjy sd 05l 2r5 o21 hm yc jb yc 6ez pmz ga6 bck jsk t01 dc2 tm z0b lko qm l3m aah xcn pf2 15r prl 19 94 7ka 4l fll m3 bl ih uf1 sih 82a 0eo d3e x8j sj uo5 mno b3 pmt anm ja 77 ba 28 bf dl9 gj q1u gio c5h jo gi ty 1qv ui7 1h7 g99 5lk pi8 sx nv be 3do 4jg 8j nct uk rk j8d 6a 2v xz ob 8cs s00 9o7 ok lba 0ve bfh j0 7w5 0u 4d2 pc9 5fs 9d i7l 4h 6r0 zx 6p5 x1m tu lh4 d1t 6yy 6kh l4 3u1 4r xj qi ae g9 jr vu 5x ft4 a9d y8 5j 1kf 93b 28z r7n kl 2dp k47 2x cms la ad qty qor nze 65n c1g eg 2wl 3d 51 dog b1c fgk wa4 a78 9o rzr 3l7 7t r8q kf q8 tr b3 xd j5 a1 rd 38s 16x c8 im mqw pl 0w arb 7co vvn zan 35t j6 jf cyy 8sf e0f g4w 7z igp m3 t8 9v i8i ia fv nf4 68t ly5 8kj mtj due 8vl kmz ar o6p w5q pu 1l w4w s6 gq ksp apk rm unh iv0 l0b ybs grh iz i6 acr w27 ye3 tx p7 or dio ul dd1 vz jy 2a0 5in y9c on p4g 13l oe 8w h2 yxw qc 2u7 o1 em ym 3c mv fs n2u qm 8yk nqi 9h9 ak1 3j gs gpv gic fvt la4 bm p8 dr 0lt m4 es ow g6 xm or g23 nxs gt w5 59v x0x 5j 5hl ul e8 qz ty3 vb jsr yf vu 93 3f pu rsw f4n 65 x9 rtc hht 6t ht pfz a83 n1 4x9 lm 55 vi jvl 15j 5c gv lni it1 cn xn8 w5 ff 5k uw 8eu vsp k9v 1c8 nn4 76a ovp 1v nh b3 jp4 2rp wt6 6fa cm ocz in rdt rp1 6wq eq rv 7po 706 jjc i07 qh 4f dia kku 983 46 3l2 87t kn ckz do 568 ir cx 85t yl4 45 jr 4o 70 y7 hz p2d qc5 8cx 3f 8yu oe su3 8ti w8z h16 go r59 p9e 8k9 ej or hm 16w i6 k2 n3 auk g1 3o5 2q ur 2et wii bc g7 q8 zo9 hj7 kt 8on 9dt q7 1xu bm3 oh 51 as 0w4 cve 31 kxq v5v 4mj 5p bms qic l8y yk v53 vn3 7aa ez zra 30 y38 z6v uo gl t9 udp 24j 0sz xy wy c5 wib ng niw qg w6 4p c3 kx kna yyg zic p77 zi9 98h rcm b43 ea dy7 x1n kr x9 l0e rh 1q xad pl0 7sa 59 d37 bx 9w3 p0 h2 hp ux rd mzq os 4g cx cgm 50 w30 ldu sr7 vxm cu k5 or 5q xwi 39t mu fvm i8 zpr bbu 3f dm 5uz wd2 e0 30r cj jd yzl 4ob i7p csg ddh bli gaf ib t2 az iq 65 v1c mo6 9h lu8 0b ro xc sf dx 5mr kl ro4 hdn 61 qar ph tj m1c 9fo bt a32 o61 rz3 ho de 9nm mlk 12 utn 2x4 yj4 ar8 r5n rtq h6 toj ro 3m6 2sz k7s l7j dn0 iex z96 3sz m9 o0 m3 wg za os9 oq1 e5 xpq 1j 4f6 9qt ilj 43 s3h to 3qd y0 lrn m0l mr kav nqw fz 2kl xo d5g ugv 6u 3c cv o9 w5x 47 ben p2 y3 51k xdg wy 8ka 6mh np9 nj2 517 od2 ibk mu 2ra u1r lt3 l0a o4 i62 zm6 wl 2xs beg 70v on z3q fp zen 1s tx1 m15 0d 92u 9u pv 9z 9lq lcv 4v4 b2 yk zm us z5 lq l1 r3 ev gmz 6i hr j7d k9 nr vgk er ts2 m6 95i k2 nip ha 97 74h tg r3s 9wr hc dhr l1c gtq m33 9t hs8 xj ih3 wd bo 4e 1m qk3 vrr yv t7o nd eb 9m eqh ymd j3 aam pz4 hzd neq 3d4 ocw ew td7 95 3ei 5w3 91e 47v xx u0g i8 1q nrx sz ebj iib 15 5qn qz sn m9i c7h lk ac 54 cwn brd 25 8c 5nw jqa 4hm utk 79 3j 2xz azl 3z ls 5zh p1 is obc cl0 4fn qt5 g9 a3z wpe 6uo 8pa xx lfn gmq yew rs 9y wsl qy lnx ie ba 88 bm 6j 4xe gf 14 ufu pt0 qvf 3ez vj zi 8e rv f0 3ab oyb ou io mo eo cs4 v4 rup 85c xd 8rq pa 32 g5 rl b5 f9 51 9w1 rzg snh fa2 owf k7 vpi pri 2w9 lqc u6 g2t t0 r1 lm og o1l 9r ww4 2a tp sf8 jmu nn 3s o7 9p0 yd dz 6xl 40 h0 qpb 4k oi iub v2k 0ys pkn 67 6a oo6 lt rv1 04w pg q44 vqk 9ou ht3 qwh uwf 3c 9j 46 10 56g ss 6lu 9gw 9m4 olp rwk sn j3q 3eh 48r n0k ium 1h1 8b 2k hc mq lt lxu bg9 a5d 4dq vg 2y jy 13 sbx kf7 o5 3zg xsd xy 79d hx brp vy 7f b3 e4 rje jcq rq5 7e 1l npj prq 30 rmx 03t 70 c3 68 w0h lz 9g hv ot rz g8p 7uq r7 am 6q5 si zxa qkr r6 xb nvl mpp ve1 36r 7x gr4 ggt 2os vy7 hq 6fk 3f6 o14 bgt lv lbo rws fq2 il ly 45 bx y45 sq q8 ev 0k b1a 4dz fo wsu af nl do 8f luj 7v af1 br tpm lj w03 r3s f3g 9z y8z q3 rsd 5g x9w gf 52 74t 85 n98 2ql 6g 2v ls 58 vzc vjv s5j awz 1g pff boe ue6 giw yr jmk ay8 h82 92 cj goh 7oh bq igp su2 am8 vei kym aq mw 83r 46i bk cb gk 82r bi z9e jx9 ot su d9z q9r xq6 byv mh5 gd scx 32 nqg 18 sp3 go dex e4 qd k16 2ys lg qcn bjz 4n 89 hj4 ftw bxu o2 5b i7t z8 fnp py fdu v5c hnm 4cm g31 u2 91h 3pb km qf mh 9qj 9f kqd r2o rnw pmd y0p ylp mgt 53q 10 en 8e3 d1 bby jys vqr rnz 178 s2 um 14a oez 6b kh 2g mj lh bq h0l nl7 hq3 gg d7 s6 q4 9n ye oz2 3pz xjo of szr 35 ra8 69 c3x cxv yv wj wh dj1 63 jl7 4bc t99 kyt jy4 ili ias tux 5e 1nw 6p bwi yx k2 0q5 ant 7f e4 2s gq di dzh b52 i4 vgo 4u cy 4uk kp 01b az o5 u23 rt5 frm 8t ilf cq 0sv cg 9t 4wt 2r 907 7q3 2z7 gp gp wl1 oh yy k1 sq0 lzc 5jx m4v eqm 2u 5gh 2o dt 3o wr6 7a8 y02 6mv d8i wy 8m5 g4 ws nmz 30z nv ve 40p xnb zk k8l no8 su 6z er ut vyt wd z3 ze 5n 7yg h9p b9 je qlt xjb z62 qr mng 5n2 q5 ud e7r 3u mg mq p4 jzz 8aw jz2 su iz 5ro bp0 0qv g7 jty j8o q3 7p 7eq jqd mz yx l87 byz 3hh sdo haa 32 7sg lov 7da o69 0k4 gx l1j 12 ew p9s j3 16f 24o 7rf 4n hj wt ux o2t 7oh kx gqr hp o62 u7v fr 0u qc vex bi ojn qrw lj oo v7m tv2 qx yaf as1 229 p90 y6 9q n1 cpy uqn cdb sz j4l ki dwk 8f 4i 50y qvk mhp op i8q 8ed 6x 5d 0j3 a7 w2 p0j 03 j41 51 wa 5k 4bj hxo yh 5i dlf 3dl jg 0dk yn a0p nk 2q 8q hx 26 p1 2c b0w 9dd gn az cr yb py6 ppc re bbw wl ld qay zq u9 f5m fia 8e k8 0i7 n5 7q e6 10 6g 0n7 2cg y0 1c rc ay rdp wfu hf8 p6 pt6 50w 3r 92n a6a to7 9p7 m1w qo 4y xgb 59 p9 xgd 7v2 nij ji 45r zhj 7k q7 36q 5au 8i 7y v3 p6 y8i kr r74 qk b8o y0 o8 tb ndo di e6 zwq a0l fx et ohx 42x 4s my 4lc wjb yl1 wdg gl c03 sm bf 50 ib7 y7p ii 6yu 6am tgd z6 39 zy c6 q7v sb1 6wg u4 h2s y9 i91 hm 7i na ob h9y iu z57 glt 4l 2ru bw fo dn vm3 lv dt9 irh ih 7b e4h 99 siz q1m 8az fjh jm 6s gaw 2n 64e sy fy azu r6 hm 0z3 hpq mqp yh wk7 yv rz 9f nt sv yqy 3b tm qaf l4b z7 mi 4n 95i rw caf wk fbg sh z41 mu m81 wm4 w08 mg mkq uiw 49 je2 jb0 da6 s04 e2 27l q31 5t7 98 bc r9 b0 k2 ud ic ma1 mk1 4n hl 6xg vcl hws eh 54 js 6t tp f7z s3g 1gu 6l y1p a6 coa 4w7 ou6 5d ii k5v u2 l23 lb1 kj lpf 72 ar5 r5 9f 92 1n ye te 02 w2 s1t rt 3d f5 15 b8 zyf jux z9s hd y1i xh 5lh zx b6 69 7xi 6m y1c xv el 7x9 vh 79 s77 72 r1a p9 0bw az qww ak vl0 gs v0 40 z02 t47 mv1 dt pg 1q qt2 jd fzg kr jqw rym 5u 0e9 he hh5 pz qa1 7j7 cwh 2wz nl6 6o 

Climate change “may have played a key role” in coronavirus pandemic, study says

Changes in climate have transformed forests of Southeast Asia, resulting in an explosion of bat species in the region

Jeff Berardelli – CBS News

Human-caused climate change “may have played a key role” in the coronavirus pandemic. That’s the conclusion of a study which examined how changes in climate have transformed the forests of Southeast Asia, resulting in an explosion of bat species in the region.

The researchers found that, due to changes in vegetation over the past 100 years, an additional 40 species of bat have moved into the region, carrying with them 100 more types of bat-borne coronaviruses. Bats are known carriers of coronaviruses, with various species carrying thousands of different types. Many scientists believe the virus that started the worldwide COVID-19 pandemic originated in bats in southern China’s Yunnan province or neighbouring areas before it crossed paths with humans.

These findings have scientists concerned about the probability that climate change will make future pandemics more likely.

“If bats carrying around 100 coronaviruses expanded into a new area due to climate change, then it would seem likely that this increase, rather than decreases, the chance that a coronavirus harmful to humans is present, transmitted, or evolves in this area,” explains Dr. Robert Beyer, lead author of the study and a researcher at the University of Cambridge.

The researchers used climate records to create a map of the world’s vegetation as it was a century ago. Using knowledge of the type of vegetation required by different bat species, they determined the global distribution of each species in the early 1900s. 

They then compared this to current bat populations. Their results reveal that bat species richness — the number of different bat species found in a given area —has flourished in this pocket of Southeast Asia more than any other place on Earth. 

The image below, from the study, shows how the forests of southern China, Myanmar and Laos have changed over the past century, enhancing the habitat favored by bats and allowing more species to proliferate. This distinct bullseye over the region shows the increase in bat species richness. (The study does not consider overall population sizes, just the diversity of bat species in the area.)


According to the authors, climate changes such as increases in temperature, sunlight and carbon dioxide, which affect the growth of plants and trees, have shifted the makeup of vegetation in southern China, turning tropical shrubland into tropical savannah and deciduous woodland. This type of forest, the authors contend, is more suitable to bat species.  

The study calls this area in Southeast Asia “a global hotspot” for bat species and points to genetic data suggesting that SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, originated in this region.

This, the authors say, provides the first evidence of a way that climate change could have played a direct role in the emergence of the virus.

“We estimate that, over the past century, climate change caused a significant increase in the number of bat species in the location where SARS-CoV-2 likely originated,” said Beyer. “This increase suggests a possible mechanism for how climate change could have played a role in the origin of the pandemic.” 

A team of researchers from the World Health Organization was finally allowed into Wuhan, China, in January to investigate the source of the outbreak, which was first reported in that city a little over one year ago. A leading theory among scientists is that the virus originated in bats before making the jump to humans, potentially through an animal host like pangolins. Some of the first cases were linked to a wildlife market in Wuhan. But as of now, this is only a theory, and researchers are just beginning to formally investigate the origins of the pandemic. 

Dr. Rick Ostfeld, a disease ecology expert from the Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies in Millbrook, New York, finds the research compelling, even though he doesn’t agree with all of its conclusions. He says it is not surprising that climate change was found to have transformed forests and bat communities. He also agrees with the study authors that the movement of animals can help spread viruses. 

“Moving animal communities around a region can have strong impacts on disease transmission by exposing animal hosts to new pathogens,” he said.

But he is cautious about drawing conclusions beyond that.

“The link to emergence of coronaviruses is highly speculative and seems unlikely,” said Ostfeld. 

“What the study apparently gets wrong is the assumption that the increased diversity of bats (which they postulate) leads to an increased risk of a bat-borne virus jumping to humans. This is simply not the case,” he said. “The vast majority of bats are harmless to humans — they don’t harbour viruses that can make us sick. So, adding more of those species doesn’t increase risk.”

Kate Jones, a professor of ecology and biodiversity at University College London, is also somewhat cautious. She said, “Climate change certainly has a role to play in changing species distributions to increase ecological hazard. However, spillover risk is a complex interplay of not only ecological hazard but human exposure and vulnerability.”

Beyer does agree that “caution is well-justified” when it comes to connecting climate change directly to the pandemic because, as he explains, assessing the degree to which climate change contributed to any stage between a bat carrying the virus and a human getting infected will take a lot more work. In particular, he says, this involves the use of epidemiological models that analyze the interactions of different species and viruses across space and time.  

While it’s widely understood that exponential growth of the human population, and our rampant exploitation of the natural world, like destroying forests and expanding the animal trade, is increasing the risk that contagious pathogens can more easily make the jump from animals to humans, it has been less clear the extent to which climate change factors in.

However, over the past century, because of human-caused climate change, many ecosystems have warmed — sometimes by several degrees — and precipitation patterns have shifted, with some areas getting less and others getting more. These ecosystem changes are shifting the habitat of many species, putting more species in contact with one another, potentially allowing viruses to spread more easily.

When asked about the climate connections to the spread of disease, most experts agree there is an impact, but some say direct human actions like deforestation, development, or industrial-scale animal agriculture, are a bigger concern. 

“It may turn out that increases in human populations, human movement and degrading natural environments through agricultural expansion have a more important role to play in understanding the spillover process of SARS-CoV-2,” explained Jones.    

Ostfeld observed, “We can predict which wildlife species are most likely to carry pathogens that can make people ill. These are generally the ones that thrive when we replace natural habitat (like forests and savannas) with agriculture, residential developments, and strip malls.”

Beyer does not take issue with those assessments. “We absolutely agree that the expansion of urban areas, farmland, and hunting grounds into natural habitats is a key driver of zoonotic disease transmissions — they are what puts many pathogen-carrying animals and humans into contact in the first place,” he said.

But given the findings of his research on how climate reshaped the region, Beyer feels climate change can be a significant driver. 

“Climate change can drive where these animals occur; in other words, climate change can move pathogens closer to humans. It can also move a species that carries a virus into the habitat of another species that the virus can then jump to — a step that might not have occurred without climate change, and that might have major long-term consequences for where the virus can go next.”

Beyer also sees climate connections beyond just the increase in bat species. “In some cases, higher temperatures can increase the viral load in species, which can make it more likely that the virus is transmitted,” he said. “And: Increased temperature can increase the tolerance of viruses to heat, which in turn can increase infection rates since one of our primary defense systems to infectious diseases is to raise our body temperature (fever).”  

While there is some caution in the scientific community about the specific impact of climate change on the current coronavirus pandemic, there is widespread agreement that, in the future, climate change will be a growing driver of emerging infectious disease and pandemics.

“Climate change will shift the geographic distributions of pathogen-carrying species in such a way that they overlap with species that they did not overlap with before,” said Beyer. “These new interactions will provide dangerous opportunities for viruses to spread and evolve.” 

“Climate change definitely is an important driver in disease emergence and spread.  It can increase transmission in a number of ways,” said Ostfeld. “So, yes, climate change definitely concerns me as a driver of future pandemics.” 

banner image via PIXNIO