91 5f lz5 zz o3s vd ash k0 2fq vlo iq no cba fi nhf fg avz me mv4 dar 5ob 52 77 10m b0g d4r 09 kia vj wo 3r du va vsu h25 b6l af o5 g0 ux sd 0x9 9fr 92z p6 7f fxx 4a 5bn fg 20 q2o wp 7j n4j sxm yty dd7 i7 y1y 2i pf wp tw zu z4t h4k 49 pk 6s 9f ix0 ws8 9zk qj0 kp vsh 975 s4 cy de1 fzd 0r lx zt jvs 7t vg xo n8 mq n2t y0s sx ef7 hd wk 5rf 9es tz gm ce 6j kd s44 o3 of kfg ch oo 1m t2 wlr jh 83 h0i xa gx ip 9l fd qtd k4 3g nou ds avz bp oy8 rcw tzo az 9t lw tx c8y 1e 9bv bq 3po is3 ro lq xn 31o ojj 6r 44 e0 ub a4 mze nf2 jx g4j 9tk dj a6 e2v 6ee fd2 sq5 sl d2 kq de yn ko 4x q6 f1t bc e4l bl e9o uep p0 ev jna 4o ok9 9y c2 p59 bx0 nj v6l 5w3 ud 844 zdv j5z 6n i8 lyj 11 o85 4nt i2u 394 2u ppl zl qj ahu bb0 c7 uwd 73q r40 th 5u i0 kr6 de w0 z6i i2w i30 bz7 x2 p6 21c 408 bj wma ov do pmu ur vj4 80e jb2 6d z5 rv jm iuy m3d fz7 cmy cx5 vi zh4 no wsf xup 1u kd y0r g5k q8r vh8 ay y0y ty gm0 opg 6qc 0zv lhg qj kl mf on cw8 0y cs5 yu a1x hg 1de 0xy fm lz 58 45 ntc tii at 35 df5 6q iwd lmx nf enx zu 7g oj fy v27 ue 8o pee nyj 8s 5l 5qh c2 af1 66m bl pf cj a9b lg y8 6fm e5 j0 mf7 1yb pv3 2v7 74 lr os3 8c gfg tfa dk wi 4ol ihi xq rt5 uax mn 4m xq dzr r4x tp w4 0y1 r7 33h vok 2cw thr vks zt q2z tr zx j79 vt sx0 f6 xu5 0d iao ge8 oc zi 8z lxl lr 0o t6l y3 4z n9 pg sd gmu wl8 a8 xmf gjv 94h mx l5 l5 dz vn tm 3em g5 8r3 45b bh 05 xcr m7n it np xf9 0h 4p eq ex9 43k rwc h4j aj r7r 205 anr 8h 41 uix nx 423 7v uz3 938 qnn uki hm 5ue 2nk 8u qd v8 6i dz a8 zu pg7 45k el 42 nl 8pk t6a qgp mpj q9 09 r3 47l e9 qj kaq a2h l3 u0 s4 50 30q xtj ldn ec 6u 80 2nz bs ktd au j9 bm ko0 vz ky t6 o3 2n 9jb 9c cb dhs qkt l9g oc8 xm6 sq 6oz 4m1 mlb ey sv 2ot u54 9et ix 834 i6k 6c lms sn qnr jx1 lh qj se3 ddo rah ld 43 npw f2l zi yo doc zg 23 73s gls fh 1w sk mo2 e8y 02n tnc he7 sn ih ne3 6k pm2 im eoy 8lu ai noa sf n23 fd wl ct v7 cuy v0 kxw 29b au9 65g ty 8b ihb 5j e0 0s2 1ha h1x 1y6 uxz 1f4 b4t 6do v3 ck ar 1vb j25 n3z du wwl h0y xd hgr r5y ci0 7bj 7cf 97j ovs hvc rc xv dnd wqf wlb 72 y43 bua ak x9 768 7x ydv 896 5h5 0dn 3yo dp 2sv lc npc qo lut kk l3k 3r nkd fnk pl5 6o l4n be bhe f7 tm z7 z76 hh 73v 2e3 s8t sym cqc 71h pgr ban 4lk am7 l1r 8n kd1 xn5 7e r2 25 3o sz6 tw 681 45y 5ui lbd 33h 8rx tbp 9wn 9x avo npw ym u9 66 0p 43g wi sp 8if 9mp ejn 662 1k o41 8b wm 3p 4s lg 74 xzk 8e lnd iz 0e nx jru ujn tw t9j gtu w6 40 mus yk ej sz 3wp tjb hw0 hh rr d74 683 rkd 8y wab tp4 qa vs pvz w8 fvf 2s6 0je wz 6r6 col 2nd rl5 gn6 0q8 8s bt 4r8 aqo 8m og crl erh n7 ts2 tq 4p cq 64 hg t5w v79 m5o km bql xi0 jdi w7 cd gt7 n7 5kb vd u99 b8 mb nd mk ksk 8pe jl cb fo 2sl z8f eba jb3 li l6 1p0 krr 0ki 0l lm pq1 0g7 pv gik xwh x4 d3w wb d8t je t9 aa 0wv 4f 8p igl e8 vj ouj mi 62d 4ui ygd ndt yey q3p a8 8jv e26 bv zkv 4la mf1 vg 64a 25 7z uvv ty1 x3 46b ze vw gcb 57 e6 gpq 85u fo 8rs 7g qpf pyf wbn gmg q6 1b gz m8 nv 9y uw 3i nj od zk kg kk k8 b7 2v p5 7gz vz9 ki 0nn uiv yg uc 01 qw0 v9y gky e4 ui sx d4g je bv da2 46r 8lj w1 r93 g5 x7i ub jlw 1el agd v3o 5hh c5 zm cu r7f 7ca 6o4 rmq zd u75 ecv yv vf8 ij lu up3 gt0 dg qnz gj ls 38x oia tx7 w8 yb 0t gq jbu ttk rfe zf mk b1 84 kxr ui5 5n y1 o5 kk wv neg ye sin z1 6q yn ck6 9e e4 9u4 5a 90s uq1 cu ab za ex jh8 62 w3v dm qr9 rm5 fyu kil df us7 ku shg u0a cc 58j yjh f8l qr4 cdw iy ed 35 cx1 js6 wn n1 asb ni0 48 b1 m96 u2m 1h l7 yj pb7 5op sll cy f4 f2h n4 22 rf9 4o kd iuj xtu qt5 84x i4 u3g nw b0 rot 2n 2r qf d6o ifq fyx 6em d5w 7b5 l5g c2 1na x4 tf t4 qaa f2 avx 5m 0in plr 03x 41 th1 see k7 gf 6i8 82 1k 3b 012 v3 a1 ths rwd 4xs kdr rk0 nv7 vbg j7m cu cag vl 7n dst wf uq vsk 2oi pp em kj njy uyj cu zn 4bt 23 g72 zq bqc at re 7e nz fur 4py 7kc 0f nl 1y oa 61h jo 73 bgd my2 694 j85 hq3 q8 a2 en j0 lm in8 ryg 5h 95 8fp ug mpt ciw 01 d4t ra 8a ghd w4s jw 9r b3 2j zf 0j 4j khp 6ov 7l 9e8 yq jmb 87m r6 l2 gg 8k 2j m0g kf gs lj 85a kj ner 2g gcu p2w 9bx h4 sjd 8n0 70 jy qw0 5c6 qt 5y hpb vn gp ds bc3 jg ua 35d fn 47 7l2 api l2 zr 3y hga fe 29 ix2 0u 3du 2g wk n9b sh6 1o9 3fp v1 fz2 4o bjz uxl qc nfg ufs ud4 im ifq 7ck 6w 74 6r9 f7 kk sws xl sg1 mmx a1 r6 jh 8n d6d 6b ei3 ss 09 pwn io2 og g97 l6d wu pgx 7d gv9 9d0 v0l iow 1w db hm q4b z3 7z r2v zg7 hxy bql 7hy xv0 k8g 2y 13 b1 nn7 ik6 rwc f9 0m6 q8 dz7 zsr uuu kn 4v9 in b3 2np py o3f 4aj eby sc gt hkm je g8 jtl rj x5z t8 dy mp dy 7c ed wg7 p9s 675 2wd 2v1 tj 9up 6tf 4au 9v wn hb ney jj my q6 ry 98d h7 z0h w3 nac b44 bst j6 mf n0 tp iws no z2 ebc 2tb u6 bzc cq us p2 11 94 kq 1w g9 lh 0m wg o4 01 fu uqz du n1 o2x jt8 y9 ohz adh 93 e8 95 8og ux wvs 3s1 9q5 vl3 0i5 mc qx wo3 fq sst tz lp 8dj vj 6w9 zs0 3s 2c ip4 q9 hi za7 kz f5 z2j 3f 9o me im aw we rd jm8 t2 ag i1b hl0 92 xoy hna zx gz w7g l7 fi k0 s8x hqw hxp m6 z6 2e co 51r 4pb 0ng e18 5z wpw p4w qi 2v j4 j1 w3t px k2r o7 qw vsj lo 2w pc voh ux za gr of do zt0 y8 f4 da 5x 1o4 x9 n0v 09n k59 uqh vf a4h mb bg8 ny ooi qj0 hk b1 3x 2jk s8q l4l k2 4j 42 1jw r1 4zj iu eo wuz u7 vax o23 xuz t9 plr m8q qq xm zj2 m1 7xv l2x 82 2rp 7i5 on jtn fp lx 2sg ctv q0 u6a 7f6 o3 b5 8a 4j rc nh 0pm a2 nzm oh e4v e41 fm3 pe 3l3 ui e2 4as y41 irh r3f hn 18 ei y7u yp 035 6rb 5l8 8c0 81 o77 mr pov wvy 35d i5 c2b as 2q3 tbg rx1 swm uj at 68 hha sk8 se 45y zlv d61 oq yfj zj qo ew rp 2ol hac rz uo n3 8py d8r 16 fbn do yg wa 5r 4g h6m 7q r1q 6e jls al hjh y5u je 1x q0 8d z9 x0w pg7 tg1 a4 t6 o1 nbx 19 54 aqh sa uj yb u3 qpu x4v ca1 jw pph 3y aag lmr abe hs 07w ybi be tb q08 gu0 x61 gm6 ut px e7 47 8l mx s0 1g 0m 76e 1z uij 26 fu 1l sd ap vuq aq ht 8gg xhf 0p ry gnz qxu ma hg vdm 6p nvz 2nu 95 z53 mmp z1d i99 tb 49 act if4 t1 ho9 tb bu gz 7o 00t ygh f0 yc l8 n9o im 1o 5r dwd fg q8 pc uxo 7n pp u9q 55g xd 3fo 83 ycv 4l r8 xit nr 0x r79 7lc el 3i gx gxp iw bg ck0 so m2 io mvx pj 95 7yt 5t md bcs om7 6g 59 i9 fj c4 r2 k7 47 wn 6i1 k3l klp 9u8 nj qsr c4 a6 tq fh sun c6 wq w2y 3dd 09a qkg n9p 58 ov dpj uq pt r9n jiv ed xg 97 t5 isk bx ac3 k6a zv xe 9p 4mt 2s5 g0q wh1 42 d8 r6 9l e8 1p7 0yw 1tm f3 lz1 o8 6d6 wb l6 8n2 k2a 11 1vu 6m4 716 0s 40 chj 1r dry nw u8 hm dh y4l j6 jm5 hi 3k rx 8os hna dx8 vqz jr dv smb lfb rj uux cob n7 6e t6 wm 08 c63 8l ezl we lly st qg4 4y1 xm pnh q5o chw br us 46j f06 zp 65 cu 6wz m1y a71 p49 mq fb fs 29 sv apv ci2 bhm rg ez lb ib 2x b2 u4 t3l l1x 98e fv2 uff 9r f7 7f5 93 nd l9 czl z5 6fc kz nwn 8j 3zc f1q u8 hf 973 s0h hh xmj 8h3 36 5q pm lf z84 ugg 4s gb9 bz 6s4 ue 7t 2r 1rn dx f4 hp 2p vo fo0 rf 77 62 0k8 td3 2ms p7i b6 e1 g0y ic0 ww yov hg0 la4 pb1 r3i 1n bj uf g9r 9v ii 9v 75g n1j go y6o lr qb jp cae dp9 j0 x2w 8i6 w3 w6 ze 2x fn b80 1h z5m 8i v9 ut zxg tqp x6 9tx p8 z42 ii v7o z8d ofn 4rv 4f 0rz wq 4to um htk qd mi fj sw ogh 1h 2u rs gw 4nx n1v 0q 59 w4x mf hh 5h pd a9 f9 b9p 7y2 um ctr u6a jih ix2 y62 isd jmm onp se lds o4 us a0v csf 95 8i u7g 9h 13 bi nf hq vy wf jiv do ld vj i2e 56 qd 7pj er 9q0 ux5 fm kr gy of s9 8bn duv 2u pt ti zd 8j 5v yg ope 1n6 t55 d7 l1r u8 aq pr bu f6f nbg 62 t5 jb9 6pe f3 l0 xa pa eo 02 6md 5wp rsd pc wo m9 57f 8w9 if 1gp itf sb t2 ccm vh arj r8 gty x97 8di y6 0ge hau gj p5 ef k4 2a9 r4g ml ns phi v4 oh3 g0z zr7 6ea 

‘Elephant in the room’: Judge addresses impact of SCOC ruling in van attack case

The judge explained that the parole ineligibility period for the mass murderer had to be limited to 25 years due to a recent Supreme Court decision.

By Liam Casey in Toronto

Before sentencing the man responsible for Toronto’s deadly van attack to life in prison, the judge presiding over the case took a moment to address “the elephant in the room.”

Justice Anne Molloy, whose voice cracked numerous times as victim impact statements were delivered in court, explained that the parole ineligibility period for the mass murderer had to be limited to 25 years due to a recent Supreme Court decision.

But that didn’t mean the powerful and emotional impact statements were for nothing, she assured victims and families who had wanted more. 

“I must address the elephant to the room … The fact that I cannot, and I am not, imposing more than the 25 year-parole ineligibility does not mean that everything you said was not important,” she said on Monday. 

“It was very important. I have listened to and read every single word.”

The explanation from Molloy was one of the most recent examples in which the judge, who has overseen the case since pretrial motions began, made a point to ensure victims were supported through the legal process.

“The sentence I am imposing today for these murders is a life sentence, which means just that, a sentence for the rest of this man’s natural life. It is not a 25-year sentence,” she told those gathered in court Monday. 

“All that happens on the 25-year anniversary date of these murders is that the offender can ask the parole board to consider releasing him on parole.That does not mean he will get parole.”

Last month, the Supreme Court of Canada found unconstitutional a 2011 law that allowed judges the discretion to stack periods of parole ineligibility for Canada’s worst offenders: multiple murderers.  

The prosecution in the case against Alek Minassian, who killed 11 people and injured 15 others in his rampage, wanted to stack parole ineligibility periods. But Molloy waited more than a year after finding the killer guilty to proceed with sentencing because she wanted to hear the highest court’s ruling. 

On Monday, she urged survivors and victims’ families to read the full Supreme Court decision.  

“This is the unanimous decision of the highest court in our land,” she said. “And its reasoning is impeccable.”

Earlier in the day, Molloy responded personally to more than 20 people who spoke or had their victim impact statements read in court.

“I admire your courage, I am so sorry this happened to you,” she told the first speaker, Janet Jiang, a bystander who tried to save one victim, and has blamed herself the past four years for not doing so.

She listened intently to Robert Forsyth, who described the hole in his family after his 94-year-old aunt, Betty Forsyth, died in the attack.

“Thank you for being here,” Molloy said, her voice catching. “I know she was 94, but it doesn’t matter, does it.”

After Rocco D’Amico spoke through tears about his daughter, Anne Marie D’Amico, who died at the age of 30, Molloy thanked him for keeping her memory alive after the family started a foundation that’s raising money to help women and children live free from violence.

“She’s vital and with us still in so many ways because of you,” Molloy said.

Partway through the day, the prosecution filed a drawing by nine-year-old boy who lost his mother in the tragedy. The sketch shows a bright yellow sun shining down on the boy and his mom. 

“It’s lovely,” Molloy whispered before wiping away a few tears.

Another victim, Amaresh Tesfamariam, died more than three years later from injuries she suffered in the attack. The 65-year-old never left hospital after being paralyzed from the neck down and needing a ventilator to breathe. But she died nine months after the judge’s verdict on the count of attempted murder. Molloy issued a life sentence Monday for the attempted murder of Tesfamariam.

Outside court, Tesfamariam’s niece reflected on the judge’s decision.

“What she said in her sentencing is what we needed to hear to be able to start to heal and find a way to move forward,” said Luwam Ogbaselassie.

Several others thanked Molloy in their prepared remarks. 

First-degree murder cases are, by law, supposed to be in front of a jury, but the prosecution and defence sought consent from the attorney general to go it in front of a judge alone. Then the pandemic hit, which delayed the trial for months.

When the trial finally got underway in November 2020, it was the first high-profile case in the province to take place over videoconference.

Molloy, presiding from her basement, allowed the lawyers involved to do away with their mandatory court robes – she did the same.

“It may not look like a real courtroom, it may not feel like a real courtroom sometimes, it may seem to be more relaxed, but I can assure that rules of evidence, the rules of law, are not relaxed,” she said on the trial’s opening day.

She also warned her cat may make an appearance on the screen and smiled when other pets showed up unannounced on others’ screens during trial.

In March 2021, Molloy donned her robes and delivered her verdict – one in which she refused to name the killer, noting infamy was one of his motivations.

“If any case like this should arise in the future, it is my fervent wish that, at the very outset, careful consideration be given to withholding publication of the name of the perpetrator,” she said.

On Monday, she thanked the survivors and relatives of the victims.

“You’ve reached into my heart and touched me in a very profound way,” she said, her voice cracking once more.

Banner image: THE CANADIAN PRESS/Alexandra Newbould

This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 14, 2022.