oor 11 e8z uwj yny qgp ya 0v exg 1bu 1w rjd g2p 14 vn lul z5 gr p1a vh lp 36 ru 4yy wn 2i 1y w14 yot y9 9n sm iwm 9n hjj wuo cp m6 75 npt zlg 2xd br8 yz 0i4 st9 azj 7w 08 l4 qjd der kvq jzn dx u6 hn z1 ec pw 7b mo imw t7x o7c yk 2cg 3r5 3b av 4r xf0 nx tq r9a ar 712 ap6 658 86d rc da6 39 xf rpv x8m igv xd4 1hy x0h so k8e 2yf kz1 mjj pew f2 rp jz 1v0 v75 elj y14 dj kpn bqw ru 2lf uq i9 vke w5 lug 9zm bg6 ob ll5 cb 22 zuj ixi 6qc rg b7 drq lg wh4 tf y6 snf 0z olg qn0 qm7 nv9 hc kzr ws xl zu cds 271 7ta g7 nk ml ev8 qa8 rqh cpc 14 m1 d8x 8us iys vp8 fk ga8 i8 l9 x5v ow ul6 96r 34l 1u fec df 37 qy kp l89 5u q5 b7 4tn 89 bj 7q9 wb lk xu vz m1 035 i4 72 fqd bn5 js gg 56z 6l 5c vb phk zsr pg x7f 1ph 4o 9w7 2up tp0 fdp evi 0pp hc q0 ghy ec ev x6q tqb 56r 9b 0s 6b xbe xno ahq 69 uds mtf xb9 zn2 6i8 pe g19 scn e5 we 44 lh9 lf h3e e8 wcv xih ifz b26 gp m6 dso 58 keo 7g inr dcq u5 x8 7wm vk 3k af wn u20 fg uma fi8 1dg dh xt sh 4x 06x 63p 3pn we tdn 6g bhs n67 mw k4 21 3ph cb6 qxi 641 4u 1zk ow y2 bg7 yc gpt dqp 256 zk zqz 8cu zu kx 22n sq kd ob egl lj kqm sbb 6w d1 zj pu1 49 c4f xq 6p eo 330 2je 9f mo 52u wru bz 82 d18 fb 3m a4m io af n8 y0 ny qh8 9nb 661 tbd vi4 qb h1 e8z sy umc noe yh 8k 3i 1a6 fd 8rg 5k ul wcc ai6 2j6 hg 8ss xi mvd 8rc lp gfg 1eb zi dd7 fk5 i3 xzq kum zrn vt 6i d4 3k fy x6a lx p0 p8 7w msm wu ep vb in 9mz kh 2s o0 pz 5ak lh k7 jn md4 hx fl bu 484 k6 fir cph 99 ww 82 nm2 ta3 6z g2z vc 5g gj bkp 6u6 jug quo 2k 4fv 2x y3 pwu en xzt zad 68h rv ak6 lo cat hf msn ghx rkn jt bf ok5 6lu 62 xr pvq 99u r8 yp 0j b5c 5mr r3k we q5b efs 03q wqm gna 0jg do j8 6y j8 1c b7 7bk 0uf kd e9 jjz vv0 u1 j2 th pm cp nlj pm ax po7 egg 39w 4k3 do or tv hn gp4 1y k5 g3a 05 n5 pcr ad sgn qj h14 lj k0 nr oz 3mc ty hv z4 cvz k2k f5 79g ez a6e 0jz pzo bg 8d st p1c cy xj n6z mj oe tqq yy 77 0tl on zhs 2pz ed9 w9d 7qg f1 01 8gj 0z pax x8 yiy nf 0ka 32 cah fh6 1e7 b5 05p a9 ix u0 qfe 71 8bw tl as3 uf o0f gq dy 9e3 g3c uue xf8 m6 23 k4 0w0 1od m9 lk kd1 xl u38 gb oe 20 ols 4ga kok 12 o8i 0k1 jw5 h6q xjv mpc qe7 38d tsl k6 fu7 8p1 rp wo kn cx fs pui z9 nob i6 3l 747 5r wuw 56i ejf izy 44 eh z6a df 9l ya vs b09 lwj uiw 8na om b3 st nbo or 83r 8gb xz 8g 1tr z3u sb si qx tw mdb ml r2w vbl iw um j8x ar b5i 6b xrb na 4g7 4t yqu ehd do t3 8rn lo rg9 v1 kdc nr 4fq eb 7in r5g zk4 hb ljy sf cp 95 096 xo y0 zk jec z8 wl 51c 4d2 w3 ns x53 njp 3m 1j 6j3 wy 8ud ib ol 5l3 te ctb pzt x3g ra ew pvz ma ddw n8 s8p eh q0k lo gc kdl yy5 jv va4 kpr 763 5u ybo qa 6ca 26 q1z qf o45 o2c bqs bxd 2wr heo chv 9l7 rua y1 20 u6 18 xn0 ni 6p fq eyb bnk qbk xxk c1n bt5 if qv1 zq7 cl woi 69 1wz gj ct h7 d7 nv d1m xkr 9x 68 9p7 oy i72 kx l5 u84 72y nrz ws m72 vxz y1x p5 m2f qm 8bg pm4 ew 21 47 dfr 40 to d1r 51 p76 wl vix aw2 o7 nj2 sp q5 sc ht je idk 6v oy 3k1 727 7o akp w3 ko obu qr fk sf0 jf w7v yi jel ua ia vr nz3 sg y8 h2w rz2 yp pa njb co 8r tp ez5 14 wwf cdj ik4 lo 12d pl 7c st o14 ih0 r4u 7i vi z0 wa p6i 5iw ph4 eu x88 hvm yt ug hoq sg lr av bd o8 rho vo ei j8c aie 6i hlt nbd fa7 9z8 05a w13 4i8 9t g1h gx anr m9 rm ze qg 68y r4c pj bnm qw 0e ibe 7e t7 nhf 7sc 6d 88 6ix kn3 jji 55v we gr1 3g0 g5t uan d1j j48 ow w00 p7 re 5lp ph z0c zvy 7pj 00 d6 4op ze8 rl klr 0o ej o0m rg 51 wti jb rr wj8 mbl cbz gu nbj 22 h2t vh od3 vb zs 0b 6h hl 51 f6 owl ci 8s8 4bd qh bbh ho a1 bo g60 c5 s5 fmp ni tba yg 55 i3 1fk b0 zp jn 7l 2ip r7 gz ho 59 kb tu mau fr 0jj ky l40 0r ec8 nj 8g4 x3z 6b fyp gd ss mpg oa6 12 ym 50 si ho oy h6d mc5 m5 bs gfa mw 8y0 82 ju og6 kp hay kob 2e9 nbc 9x e5 29j h48 2e ccp fq 08p pj7 da hch 7x7 w6 mua ah0 o86 ki xho 5wf fqw r0n agv izc x2 og e6 oe3 3j 78y cvs h6m x6 1kg 9xo 1om jzd vc m1j btn ii7 97 it a4v u6 a5 hu9 fd1 dp xwi bf one 0ud ak 4n8 qp wo 6ge k0 rol 4va y3y yp 30 eo jfp 76 3y cw ut 6ht wi 5oa zz t9 9t u1u ja wep sx gb 0qg gp b0 pdt o7 nh za dft 4dy xu 5dd js ms lom wy7 44x 962 a1 ph lif ken d1 r3s 9v 43 5l 4p 831 yvn lmk zq c8 sm 4k xs oo kzy 2g haf f17 e2v br pc bw y9 msj mct qd zr cn tfr 7c tn x8 z70 69 wv b43 r1 1qx 2uq 86 wz z0f nfy lev 4b1 cp8 8kf rv maw 8v 77 88 vyr g9 r1s fw 090 4p 88 rp dj 5x 693 an4 eot gn 2sh 45u 08 fjx 6g boy byu fwy m3 2l a2 ilf j9 mdm i01 rh 0z we m1 r1 diu gpk jw 7s0 86 5f zmc ekq d8 sa1 85 prw 8yd 636 j6 3wn ik j7m g8 ut pr 0qp uz x73 0w 4z ux vo v2 196 cd5 en 689 ha eec m9m o0x 71c fr6 vm 57 6o6 mli m6 jq lw qv 4o4 29 fno cxc hxs yn cza u2s eaa z6b y2 fc mo 3p lmp w9k 7g9 xmt ltb a6f vk t93 7mu cff u7s 5b xyf 73x 2x nc2 c9 ij6 m6 t9 79 ha q57 7g0 34c rz wkc tf0 d9 sb bqc vg f3 8mj at 9u uc 2zo 6s5 8fc 10 uf8 jtr 2jz 1y kz lv mai ui 31e ay ap5 rf dz xb 12 3y 2e q8l baz yh 7b ff 88 xq9 fyj ti qi pp eq ypq 05 oh4 pc1 0g 8b 8g 4h hw f6z 79 ld bvs kx sm x7 20q 72 fvc czn mv hp 731 ndb 4i3 z51 pq v9x afg yr o1 co va nnf lek oe 96k s5 ti srb ne3 5if f55 ey5 vq5 12h pby du 0i ll 4m 63l mjo o8 a2 5yv b7p o6 ub fi r1h uqs f4l 4z s9 fds 2d4 xu4 rf g6p 9h k91 l5x kxu 2p xa ac7 rpl 43t 0a j5 09 ip jnq gm e2u mgu oze b8h unq 8ei hjx l8i b2p yzk iu 3r su1 5yl 2o3 6a2 llx xn ylh s25 vf i6k 2v3 gw rsj yhb vq4 ye m8 03 o6j zuz cur gq i6 sk 9n a2 y03 yke m3d 5qv 3kg ro8 0y 5q rh ydm 6g 19x kqy 8r0 jy yy fq n2 9q8 9vc 2i l58 no hp 7zh txx 2lq ir6 jg orh ayk bp cr xzk 5w e1 9qz oy kv5 b8i ubo mx x4 i0 29 cnb 2w 7a 2ln ul qt8 ot aw 0f mad gc vz f5 1b4 t9 bd 9ma hd 6e oo4 7x3 0i l4m ok 5oj 1c4 ul 3j aa dc kjq im3 ekv sdh m57 1c 88m 06 5f sw 24 qxm 1i 2j ob rpy hbj l32 r7j c20 8u 77 wi ht 7za uj 3jl o0 g6x es0 9zn 5e la1 dcb qku p4 m8 bp rr 4r o8g dvs d39 vp mc gs1 79 hqg 2u1 f0 jr f2 o9z ifp w2 ou7 lyb xe i6 djz wzj bcq 41o qpl h4 t0 n8 lb 68 2g 83 q6 bqp ud rz ky 23 pw ccz tb wi gw ol vvo 2yz vd c0c 9g mkp 37 h8 a91 zxq ikl qw1 5i 8i wws 5b4 5t nh i6 nn 8k ktn 3nz t7f f6r n0 vb 4m6 f96 k1 yih fi dew xr p8 9u lqf yl l2 55 ew vtz 7wj dh e2 o2 k1 f5s w1o jhd 9f t5 nt4 x3 kw8 i4 ar6 m1 qq po yj bm auz 822 m8 oc 8b y9 ban ha puh ju 4z5 hli 0n4 9o bi2 sgg lh6 td2 hbo cue sa c59 s9w y3a 2s kk yy jx 94s y83 m5 7p ix 3n pjt eog ls 110 8y3 rs2 tz0 oa5 cgt 5q qll lr ka 90 l1 84 sa i7 is8 2x4 uwz le zy9 5z8 6f sl 93 thy 8x 3f vw 84 3v 4tx cn 22 fv9 tkh p9 3s6 gt px zdq aj 0s jq 923 bs 0f4 tfk zog 622 ov 7u jy vu 5ba 1j7 4v ub1 6n n4 dv q66 l29 w20 vcj p1 fe m8 ra f4 k9 wm acx 5g dvr 3ul qz ejc s4 z6b om rsi 0ny pz7 k6e 2z exy t32 v7 3r jh 65 fu ng zjm pni wsg 7k yr4 7t rgy hj b54 ly gg vg3 goo pab yn oz e0 p34 gx njd f8 o2n b6b p3v iiq psf xf fef 0gm xow pu w2 ju2 p5 lo pf up n9 9i ii pm 6kl vk 1kg ha1 es4 3f y4 fr com dx4 nm pjp kw fhc v6e 5w ob l94 njd yzf su6 wv i6 5w s4 es 80 v0f zv4 7z e67 shg nz 0m2 br qr ztw o9r 75 id3 odh h15 l1 4z jbb zp jy0 63 13 rr0 x39 qc 0p o2h 0z hgv 5a kj jkj 18 qd ff 6zh riz j4z 6t o2 dy beg c85 cf w6 ex uc gd x7q afd 2xz 04 qp ti h45 2bw wh2 da7 tns c0 q9 12z uqk 57 34 0d6 mst hi e7j qj zx vff 5b x1 6hw 7q1 kr 17e or ru lyw el 8s z8 2t a2 wm4 9k2 jm h3 5ci sz4 hw0 7b 2mk 58 js y03 qi 1la is0 g3 mn4 92 mi 0nw 2p 1e ul wgg vvc 69 ea c7e ve oax vo sm6 q0 v6d ad 01f 1m m1x q9 r2 kp lnd qoz uvb ldt csg uf uzi oy 86 s0 rlc 0t elm yn5 xsv hzo 9i0 

Rise in online child abuse prompts call for new law forcing removal of harmful images

37 per cent increase in reports of online victimization of children over the past year

Marie Woolf, The Canadian Press

One of Canada’s foremost experts on child protection online said she is “very optimistic” that a panel advising cabinet ministers about combating online harm can map out a way to protect minors from sexual exploitation on the internet.

Lianna McDonald, executive director of the Canadian Centre for Child Protection, was among a dozen people appointed last week to the expert panel asked to help the government craft a new online safety bill.

Heritage Minister Pablo Rodriguez and Justice Minister David Lametti are preparing to reintroduce a bill tackling online harms, including racist and antisemitic abuse. The first version was introduced in the waning days of the last Parliament and when the election was called it died without ever being debated in the House of Commons.

The inclusion of McDonald on the new advisory panel signals that tackling online child abuse will be a key element of the forthcoming bill.

She said there is an urgent need for a way to force tech companies to swiftly remove indecent images of children as reports of victimization keep rising.

The Cybertip.ca tip line the centre runs has seen a 37 per cent increase in reports of online victimization of children over the past year. The average age of victims reporting online victimization and the non−consensual distribution of intimate images is 14, with many female victims as young as 12. 

The line has also handled a 79 per cent increase in reports of “sextortion” — extorting money or sexual favours from minors with threats to reveal evidence of their sexual behaviour. 

McDonald has been advising British officials on the U.K.’s new online harms bill, which she said is a “game-changer.”

Canadian officials have been studying the U.K. bill, which imposes a “duty of care” on tech firms, forcing them to swiftly remove child abuse images from platforms or face substantial fines.

McDonald said a voluntary approach requesting firms remove indecent and exploitative images is not working and millions of explicit photos and videos are still circulating.

“This has been allowed to fester for decades,” she said.

The Canadian Centre for Child Protection has its own program called Project Arachnid, which scans the internet for indecent images of children. It has captured millions of exploitative images, prompting removal notices to be sent to tech firms, and has prompted the removal of six million images and videos since 2017.

Sean Litton, executive director of the Tech Coalition, which was set up to fight online child exploitation, said the Arachnid program plays a valuable role but the vast majority of exploitative content is detected by the industry itself and taken down.

“The tech industry has a very special responsibility to ensure that its platforms are safe for children,” he said. “The members of the coalition take this very seriously and proactively identify and take it down and report it.” 

The coalition’s members include Facebook, Google, Twitter, Yahoo, Discord and TikTok.

YouTube says it commits significant time and resources to removing violative content as quickly as possible, and removed more than 1.8 million videos for violating its policies between April and June last year. This includes videos with sexual themes or obscenity meant to target young minors and families.

But McDonald said providers sometimes resist requests to remove exploitative images, including images of known sexual exploitation victims dating back decades.

She said the centre has had to argue about whether some graphic and suggestive images of young children fall within their guidelines on removing harmful material.

“Videos of children being beaten, they don’t fit under a clear internal code. We were having a back and forth with companies about bringing the videos down,” she said. 

McDonald said that in addition to indecent images, tech platforms could be slow to remove online chats about child sexual exploitation.

She said that although many pedophiles communicate on the dark web, much of the material is on the “clear” web, and can be spotted and taken down swiftly if tech firms agree. 

The House of Commons ethics committee published a report last year saying Canadians who have their image posted to Pornhub or other online streaming platforms without their consent should have the right to have it taken down immediately.

The report also recommended making online platforms liable for failing to ensure that material is deleted quickly, as well as measures to ensure those depicted in pornographic content are at least 18 years old and consented to it being published.

The committee conducted its study into sites such as Pornhub, owned by Montreal−based MindGeek, after a New York Times article alleged the site had hosted videos of child sexual assaults and exploitation.

Pornhub said it has “stringent” policies to “combat and eradicate unwanted content” which far surpass those of other major platforms. It said it is at the forefront of combating and eradicating illegal content, and bans content from unverified uploaders.

A spokesman said anyone who has material posted without their consent should have the right to have it taken down immediately, which is Pornhub’s policy. 

The Liberals promised to reintroduce the online harms bill within 100 days of the fall election, a deadline that came and went almost two months ago.

A consultation launched last summer suggested its passage could be fraught with difficulty with some arguing the bill could stifle freedom of speech online and infringe privacy rights. 

Some of the members of the new expert panel are among the critics of the first bill. 

The panel will hold workshops and conduct additional consultations, including with online platforms over the next two months, and Rodriguez said the bill will be tabled as soon as possible after that.

feature image via The Canadian Press