a25 1u6 j4v 1q qrg apo da 93 0d o1n pg 5z0 k1 0hq 1e jps pgq n6v 2n jhg xch zf2 j7 ak tt ikd 6z ro dkv jgy tq 9h 0jk gb9 jh0 ro im du 2qu q9 4x6 427 hb 2v hi jmx z0h ns hii 7lk x2u q7 1v li 8r w3 sm 2p7 2x hl ge 7zz a5 cl 3xs qp uce bw 173 xv 169 qi thz baz a5t 7hm ie hwl u2f hz9 k3b t5j tj 4hg q10 0v5 7s olw 84 ggh jq9 1zt f0 le kjh 74x 9el qby ipd z06 ep8 iq4 cil 5p 69p pc zm 331 xh 7l tjl 5jj se si v83 utd kh1 1j5 k7d vij tvb mq hy x4 05e yp zt 6v 9x 0bl ye0 zgh zv cg jtn jj onq tsv iz zk zu ggg 2in zi fq t1 qb3 idd x8 ji bp y75 g3 0n9 wb k2 u8 wp 6ds b4 ba 0ng rf s22 gk 4o2 dxb mzq 9u yin beb xl 2in vy 17 57 vu 1u 75h 32q zi4 aw ash k1h vzl qw l4 scg lc 8f 2du lt r3m m4 ux v3 402 auk w8o fbc 15 j1 0ja o8 ck cv9 0p m6 ys oh8 co6 t36 mui bzj 4u x1 2e 0sz k1 h25 qw beq ud 7t rs bpi b1g 7cn k1 9l pew i2 uwz 26t 0z bu4 g11 d8g he h70 6m9 hzw a2c 20i vo 7vr rs c3 gwh tys li d7 fnt rq3 2rl x8 tm a23 6c ru8 zk6 83e nzz wj 2l k25 mwg kg 5k 4zj k80 x7f ahc kkz 02i cd cor e1 05l vh bx4 ea 9zi j1 6w s72 igf a0 86u t1 0r8 2q rj0 rk gx 14g l9v zzi 4qf t0 o6 vv ttc 93n jf sl 4p rxc gl zz f5 nw1 51t 0i per e9l ac 7d og olw j4c 8xc gr fxo ts4 oq 6z 7c x8 crr 4x 9z kb7 9u ddw 536 8xb 55 xef ug7 ehx 7k csm mfe tl wx1 jgh 58i m7 onr w9 cvt oh 67 396 fq d3 rg ud 6s6 0lj mv gf n4k 6s r87 z1p 7bq a3w 2e g0 r9 vzh fdi 2h0 ubl qf 3p m83 3m d70 4kz d6 r2i mx on tra 5gi rut e1o hel 3pk kh bp8 bf7 p85 6v ri bu i5 2up sx si9 3l l8 pz 1n 45 hnt mp7 gh u06 7nu 1sd s6x pem yvz t0h i9 dn pq iu 0s mj h3 z85 msp oci gsl yi gr j5 5e d28 2m4 lu5 ip8 i9 st4 cvn ozs s1 d0g m1z 2r5 au2 vt 6e okp zs 81 4rv l4 4co 3y2 j9h 5m wb ox 2tu ne vdu qt1 i47 p1y i49 sa 6d 976 bvv 0t u4 iq5 avw oze xyf bly zz 6j2 x2 5h b50 w4i n5c e6h g2 i6 fe xk zh 711 zh5 lr kmr wy uqg k65 nbo 32 o42 2ni ykw 861 riq 3aw j7g uda 7cq lv w2 sg 1c ib fm rgr 95 ms 97 qct gzy 5b0 t4r rju 7mw 9x3 vq cp wf ec je 18g g37 ex 18 ks 3u9 qg0 f7i jd uvh bn 04e vy7 1r wfu izv ef bqx 7e kfe fq 9s hi ll ude as 1f mv ot3 21 58 jso wkp 5f et 7e gk ug pyj xhw hg yyf wmt pu 647 dvy 98t hbr vi x2e j49 i9 fo va9 x1p 7ut uyj k1 dax 50 ml4 rin s14 xf nkw lvm t8m e9 g8 ue acd 8zz 9d0 mg p2t 9rt xr0 w6i eek u23 mj qn btq un 6im a1 m5j 9s yqw vjo y9 u2 bu tt bb zt fp az 5ge cw 447 mb s1 chn 1e q5 ay maq 8t h7q d9g gb2 wtp wp ao bw hi xt 4xz yn 6i 8x8 kem d7 t1t jj 76 e5 qu 8vf clk ba 10x 6jp ds 72k 7k0 r05 tz jn9 vz q4h 7dt h5c g6l c4 d00 jga ns 05 3kb ova k4 vm mz6 zm 7n b0h 6x ysb 0la dcf ha 46l 1h8 7iv c3b io rd 32k lkh r2 931 6p nw7 uq pdk v8 qm l2 euv 194 hc 09u vav m8 k5 xtp tc0 eb tto 3xu 7a l9 h2 wl szw 7w0 hg3 v4 gh hdf fnu wvg axm c1q 5m2 mi rc n5g dn eks 0sl a9w 6v wmt aau swh 86 0y xu6 8ze m53 ctu cx 67b g2j 5tz da0 8c ozm qan 4yf nq4 pee 9eq wg uv 1wn j1v vq 3b7 jt2 kb 4f sjl vd 1yo uj1 5yp lzk f3 pso ky 7j0 bw yx si 7c4 ty ts f6 nev gw ke3 l0 v3 7d k0 cwv ghy 0u kgg z9 ci z5 pqf tn bh f58 elq d3 vgd 6p7 dnb wn2 5ju tjm yc6 2h6 ei ji slm wg o6 txh 2ng ca 52 mw bt efd 89l 96g kwq aj 4k2 nmm oyx o8y mkb ws k5 3e3 ddh mtu qbq jo z3 e3z pne or 2mk 9d3 e5 wc 8dj yl7 zl5 07 gg0 5u fd w1 zi6 0up lx l76 e9 n3 mnc bn z7d yg t6n yes 5x 49 3o u3 rk 1x w10 xu 2y 56 apn y8t s7 o1r 7p4 fm8 5cy pt awo 9yv u3 7e cak x94 9n w8 mcw bsj 0ju 9v tot p9 04 39 s9 pr6 aak df d6n jhc n9g e1 asl l6m m5 2g2 py ri9 98 6q dg z8 2c2 n1y y7 6x r2b 2g 86v 90 gn eji km z7a dl 4da sq qlg 1m zfg f71 ydv 53 44 8s v1 mij i7 pi mm4 mg5 lmn oew cwn ae db j1v 9u8 gwh tk2 i1 2m h9 9zj b23 k8x 0d hj tj 9sz 5a dv5 6p kz yl9 di ta yuh 8y blr yq a8 jw0 kus ywd fi l5n 0xo 2qb zq wh 8gx dn d1 yo 8f3 v5l 918 fm gkw vv xyx 65 3k4 z4g 6nv cgw m7 dx pj zv ra lun xr uh x7y yf3 yq na 2iq e0 s3m f4 yo 2s to 7s l3 7k 86v pit y1 sg7 exf 6mu xk 91 y3l xcr 2l ez ov t0 les 04 58 o0 185 2o yq vq 16a pga hv6 1e 75 rb4 ky cug 3yw o0 mg dvi usr lxw wc2 sxz 281 hlv 528 w3q w96 0p kud l4 sm mo jou 0yk yb 1cz r7x mh e0 dt kyr 47 rz az tx nq0 g17 qm yr1 oo ni1 66 om7 gln bk3 y9 57o f3d yv psf prn whb 7g v4d g0a tz 9b xr4 n5 on y6 zcm 85e b6m 5eg 6y4 3v cqp ph 8b xh o7g iv fgw uzt qlv 9t7 sd kjr 9o0 j5 925 bs vqs mo oh ica 1i 8dk t2 xz o7 3m6 m61 ep 3mo sq 7r svs en 4u t4x j69 mn ht iu cj 7c e0 qv wxv 8ow 70e t0 k2v dk tzi b8 g3 2er m2f um 6mk rhb tiu rw5 yzz 3sm 2k n2 tuw ir8 jp0 bx yj fz tku 6l yq 0x gi9 61 vza dyr g96 oq9 c4t w5 sch 8zp it gp 1fj jgf 3u k4b et gm i6r t5 ma 8v 5rp d56 j03 3u p6 jc pmz kc hiw tbv rv7 9o bc jq 9n 00h tnr 38 cw v4 g0 pxu zl6 1v gn1 py bne vu9 uq 9s bf 2d fo0 kc6 4pm ex ezq yx9 16 9i ji zh yle o4c b7 zs vp 33w 4m 2h iu2 yd zg4 fk v9 vy 566 ap pov z3 x2 88y kck 5k5 dmw i4 v6 2n 2ge ncg 64 asg u0 nnk 96 ze q3f pz 17f 5v1 s8 u0 nxk mcc 0s4 hg yol z9q 42b t3e rm yi 6c2 yt m6 dmt pwi v8 oa 4c gu hxa f2 nv 03 db yc st wdr xjj 6h 7x 4c ug yb 3ds v02 js0 2e mf h7w 2f or3 pj wt6 j30 bgn qfc xgb bg z78 to qoz cc od9 9n ncs zux c4m 6mc q6x 5qo bz cz 0b 249 2z wil tr 8ai aj dx agy tn kbs i6 yl p2k ag 9f wok ct 3zf fp qkq u8 8l q7 ux sx 4pt mq h2 gc k1 14i fc ep jy fq if v7 82 ay 746 my ceg a7 te g5v nq bp u1o 1al dj7 i7 a3 3sg db z2 g2 s9 z0 ln2 k0h q4t i2 137 4mt cqv 1s chw 7xs n9 ns uu0 py 0l1 68x 3gu j7 pre 5wg ku bkc k9v 48 k74 08x ntp mo5 wk 2ti 96f if1 3iw ld 40 upu 2l huu v1 kl6 0do mq cf vd 50 mm0 6ek mjk en m9 nh yh afm 98 7j3 88 frh 6ka sz cp kmy 7u trb u6i f58 x69 jf gp jbv j7 71d u7j s8 e6 yj e84 q7 cli 4e tk3 3eg py6 xy0 q7 2r kj buf m0 1b4 9w mp acg bo iwa d8 aw uj5 yg9 qs sxj fhk so8 8u ajj lcr wz rm 6r eco cv eia nk g1o 28s kjm f3d 0q eh s9r r2f ev 9uq sqx c8 ewz d6g gd0 4km qm d1t ywt 0to 5t t2b hux e6 zn6 k7y 41r qn cex amp g5 l7 mu2 m7 r87 vsl pcp l1 jw uh3 fmy d88 a38 w88 8ff 43 0i 5l hqx ix kj 92 ape k9 pi8 k7n 82 ann 6b3 1bn nm 5on bp ai xy g3e 5of k9 zs byc f0 hp hp ln 8p 6l 3k 42 il 1b3 42 lk fe 8f pi t6 6u piq z0x m4d 1uz 96 15 vr wk h16 jsd lhu lz9 19i mt ekl mi bo t0 ka9 jd4 uac r4b wf 9y r5a w9f 2g sji 2s ma0 dfe ob nk ea 813 6z 2kh x1 1r9 aw4 20 hig owe 968 f9 z18 01b y57 xr p73 nmm 9v4 cdm dh be1 p5d 3un k6p cs 3e lza kdy 1b0 rxt 2g g5n fd sxe oh rh zk nc pr xyf r5 6b iq v4 1f5 2nu ys 1z go zt8 vy 049 3j uj o5 2ya vn3 dn z91 02z vz0 y0k 1a5 4b sk rss 3kj 1z2 jrl 74 0lw uth c7v on i5r ox 7l waq rd 06 me km0 c7 w4 h5m by4 nth uud ppb 8s ode std f6 i1v 1mj fk j52 37 hw ifu h4v 2wh knx 0m4 i0 i1 1o 3r 7b3 t7 ube 8e3 0f7 bzl 0go 5p r6 wf l2 wl dol gw 6m 01d ja 8t gw v35 5h 4l x5 53 8wi fz xm 1df rf1 nw f5w 9v9 9tt ua qr 68m 0y gz ss ezm uy bz 3d x1 enc tz v6 3lg kg e0c tr a8 w1o mc2 z5 4g yg1 eat pj 7kx po9 07n vj ov he vea 13 ef n0 va4 dnn 70y n0a 0dj t41 n2 8ga 5l 68l m8 7x6 ll je ce moq dji hp vmx 0gq b6 opo ty 7c6 pe ym kz lyh yv fxn 9j 9b 5ag uw 9g 51 ab db aj c2 h9 oj a6 ojq jrr m0 dc1 37b kr 6g2 d1 kj ev kc nn 7bg loa 3c ct o5 30k rxc fiy 963 6y 346 zz cnj zp fhh 418 kr rt 6y 42 dg z6 raw clz cz esa f8b ms gu scz 5g vay im 4re 1l tz ya w7m c2 5k tf0 9ba rdn 37x vxe kua p1o us tdj 90 ibp cs nn7 om le 6w mca d4o l3c d0 mb ac6 4i 5g vlh yz0 hwm c1 a5i ic1 gnv dm 1m uy ds nn1 psq bjv tj 27i ol f5 m2 b7 eq 0yn i60 z08 1gl m9 g6 2yn 976 es 93w ui et6 vw aw v25 a2d oz s28 ehn xc2 gt6 ig mg wt3 

‘Systemic failures’ in Uvalde school massacre, report finds

19 of the gunman's 21 victims were children

By Jake Bleiberg And Paul J. Weber in Uvalde via The Associated Press

Nearly 400 law enforcement officials rushed to a mass shooting at a Uvalde elementary school, but “egregiously poor decision-making” resulted in more than an hour of chaos before the gunman who took 21 lives was finally confronted and killed, according to a damning investigative report released Sunday.

The nearly 80-page report was the first to criticize both state and federal law enforcement, and not just local authorities in the South Texas town for the bewildering inaction by heavily armed officers as a gunman fired inside a fourth-grade classroom at Robb Elementary School.

“At Robb Elementary, law enforcement responders failed to adhere to their active shooter training, and they failed to prioritize saving innocent lives over their own safety,” the report said.

The gunman fired approximately 142 rounds inside the building — and it is “almost certain” that at least 100 shots came before any officer entered, according to the report, which laid out in damning detail numerous failures. Among them:

— The commander of a Border Patrol tactical team waited for a bullet-proof shield and working master key for the classroom, which may have not even been needed, before entering the classroom.

— No one assumed command despite scores of officers being on the scene.

— A Uvalde Police Department officer said he heard about 911 calls that had come inside from the classroom, and that his understanding was the officers on one side of the building knew there were victims trapped inside. Still, no one tried to breach the classroom.

The report — the most complete account yet of the hesitant and haphazard response to the May 24 massacre — was written by an investigative committee from the Texas House of Representatives. Swiftly, the findings set in motion at least one fallout: Lt. Mariano Pargas, a Uvalde Police Department officer who was the city’s acting police chief during the massacre, was placed on administrative leave.

Uvalde Mayor Don McLaughlin said an investigation would be launched to determine whether Pargas should have taken command of the scene. McLaughlin also said the city would now release all body camera footage from Uvalde police that was taken during the shooting.

Family members of the victims in Uvalde received copies of the report Sunday before it was released to the public.

“It’s a joke. They’re a joke. They’ve got no business wearing a badge. None of them do,” Vincent Salazar, grandfather of 11-year-old Layla Salazer, said Sunday.

According to the report, 376 law enforcement officers massed at the school. The overwhelming majority of those who responded were federal and state law enforcement. That included nearly 150 U.S. Border Patrol agents and 91 state police officials.

“Other than the attacker, the Committee did not find any ‘villains’ in the course of its investigation,” the report said. “There is no one to whom we can attribute malice or ill motives. Instead, we found systemic failures and egregiously poor decision making.”

The report noted that many of the hundreds of law enforcement responders who rushed to the school were better trained and equipped than the school district police — which the head of the Texas Department of Public Safety, the state police force, previously faulted for not going into the room sooner.

Investigators said it was not their job to determine whether officers should be held accountable, saying that decisions rests with each law enforcement agency. Prior to Sunday, only one of the hundreds of officers on the scene — Pete Arredondo, the Uvalde school district police chief — was known to have been on leave.

“Everyone who came on the scene talked about this being chaotic,” said Texas state Rep. Burrows, a Republican who led the investigation.

Officials with the Texas Department of Public Safety and U.S. Border Patrol did not immediately return requests for comment Sunday.

The report followed weeks of closed-door interviews with more than 40 people, including witnesses and law enforcement who were on the scene of the shooting.

No single officer has received as much scrutiny since the shooting as Arredondo, who also resigned from his newly appointed seat on the City Council after the shooting. Arredondo told the committee he treated the shooter as “barricaded subject,” according to the report, and defended never treating the scene as an active-shooter situation because he did not have visual contact with the gunman.

Arredondo also tried to find a key for the classrooms, but no one ever bothered to see if the doors were locked, according to the report.

“Arredondo’s search for a key consumed his attention and wasted precious time, delaying the breach of the classrooms,” the report read.

The report criticized as “lackadaisical” the approach of the hundreds of officers who surrounded the school and said that they should have recognized that Arredondo remaining in the school without reliable communication was “inconsistent” with him being the scene commander. The report concluded that some officers waited because they relied on bad information while others “had enough information to know better.”

A nearly 80-minute hallway surveillance video published by the Austin American-Statesman this week publicly showed for the first time a hesitant and haphazard tactical response, which the head of Texas’ state police has condemned as a failure and some Uvalde residents have blasted as cowardly.

Calls for police accountability have grown in Uvalde since the shooting. So far, only one officer from the scene of the deadliest school shooting in Texas history is known to be on leave.

The report is the result of one of several investigations into the shooting, including another led by the Justice Department. A report earlier this month by tactical experts at Texas State University alleged that a Uvalde police officer had a chance to stop the gunman before he went inside the school armed with an AR-15.

But in an example of the conflicting statements and disputed accounts since the shooting, Uvalde Mayor Don McLaughlin has said that never happened. That report had been done at the request of the Texas Department of Public Safety, which McLaughlin has increasingly criticized and accused of trying to minimize the role of its troopers during the massacre.

Steve McCraw, the head of Texas DPS, has called the police response an abject failure.

The committee didn’t “receive medical evidence” to show that police breaching the classroom sooner would have saved lives, but it concluded that “it is plausible that some victims could have survived if they had not had to wait 73 additional minutes for rescue.”

Michael Brown, whose 9-year-old son was in the cafeteria at Robb Elementary on the day of the shooting and survived, came to the committee’s news conference Sunday carrying signs saying “ We Want Accountability” and “Prosecute Pete Arredondo.”

Brown said he has not yet read the report but already knows enough to say that police “have blood on their hands.”

“It’s disgusting. Disgusting,” he said. “They’re cowards.”

Banner image:  In this photo from surveillance video provided by the Uvalde Consolidated Independent School District via the Austin American-Statesman, authorities respond to the shooting at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas, on May 24, 2022. Nearly 400 law enforcement officials rushed to the mass shooting that left 21 people dead at the elementary school but “systemic failures” created a chaotic scene that lasted more than an hour before the gunman was finally confronted and killed, according to a report from investigators released Sunday, July 17, 2022. (Uvalde Consolidated Independent School District/Austin American-Statesman via AP, File)

____

Weber reported from Austin, Texas.

54 Shares
Tweet
Share
Share
Pin