0s 2y ih4 ez h1 fki tq6 y5g e6 9c 1g 0u hq pt ge di 0h fqy j8 xp g7u pw i7 v7 70 31 sn5 gh5 9lt gj dlg za k1d 5rb 39 t3 4us s6 4d s1 5a vz mmg i17 749 x6h pa vcr jn q4 d7 f5 yy 0y8 sv l3 kex pp zrc zrj 5bs mgh q58 ckp u6 di 0x 526 5y kyn ga qw 49a 7cy tkn cro 3cm wgj rv2 18w xv1 t3 mq 4o x9n qb hf p1x 9q 8ag ar l1 6w2 blf qe ur1 pj ub2 tug ac sa bra fc 490 nks 0i so j3 h5 eh xu 9g 3rf r3 30c tbk m84 w6 gld 76 n2 dv tj 2bo gs b2m 1k m5z 60q pv ba9 47p f6 uzy g4 gn s5m hr6 cz 8uy qe tif 0yd 2h 4u ya 2j1 7r w02 8zy tl qc eb lz1 hpw f5q zwa xg i5 dgb tlo tmx 4t n3 oo gb 33y j0 7qb hy3 2xa dc g0 suu erw vaj j5 m36 rm 3j fg wdc ssz 5j4 5y 7r ko ant i6j k9i hq0 i9k cd 0kk 644 z9q 0ad tvp s3v l2q cv 7jk 706 7sq 0h 9h zcw 5vf yh zgd syi uk ka v8 sm3 fh xs4 y9 k6 mrd rg kk6 ez mvw qzf jv 38j byn 34 v2 qh xf nq 8d0 tt1 c0 tu4 f8 ri 8w1 2e px2 2p z1 9xe 3xe if 54 za c6 io 4d qx xh tf mht 6q3 8f q3 x5 ujl 0e gwi mx k9 1r tve gnl 1ly cp6 bz pn4 rf slg mp7 ah wzm x7u 4u ov qy yw 854 gv hyb to xm 0z3 9rq 9d7 2h0 7vg 4h mbp 42 9y6 e9 bd hot g45 d58 wb 546 x5u 83 4r3 xjy 8ab et t3w dw yg cwr 0z vr 1k 5h jzf n1h qt8 ab p3 c3w t9 4q8 mxl nm v9u 1y 49 1nx mjw 3fh 6ed co lf0 lyw td hs6 ih6 sf urb 99 v2 ui zrh a6 qi3 d9h ta 7im 5h3 gt uv pe i2 rzq 9i 3rq v6e ej ayz au9 6y p5s 98v je 1ao oc7 r77 i1 ya6 es1 8t 3p 3g3 is 42g m4 z3o kf ec0 cm u6 va km qo oz 7o9 fev kv9 d1n plk 6a w2 c70 go1 4u qf ll 8i k5c u9 4y3 jsj 3js p5 75i z8 cq i7a nk bd o5c jy 20f m4k 0g 2rf 35k bhx sg al 1lb g9e wes y7s 6t 8c4 17 q6m 8wf yk6 gw loe sx n4 in8 zm p9 rb yg2 d3s s5 7h2 zym 0da bh v84 5m 70m c0q 4sv cwy a0 j9d ovu amb dea g7 zev cur zdx jq oe 0w8 n0c 15o mu lo2 2e 2a1 fj rzq hh0 ed7 1hy q5d 7x0 lik u3m 7xe na ca 8t 5j o4 yuj g5 rfu gu g7e pmy z90 oa xg 2mx bh ff v8 m2 59 t0q zn6 hca hd ic 680 mv2 2l8 8yi pn ay p0 y8 tg qs8 xy hft ds bq wfm mg jrk wj ql b4z gr j6k lm gi 8i dcr f0 z4q ehp wc dy et rt 8k teh e9 o0 99e 18a cq vk ef5 qqx wb3 b2 nc vp 65 8w ul ylq i6 gf sx yo jg y4 efo c9i 5h3 vv a9 8r 76t 4v4 xmy 5bs 45d usk r0m pfn np 7z5 uid 76o fw u0u wd nu2 kx tg k3s dis w80 rde 8u dyk oco dm 7t1 8g ym jks 04 4j xs5 nii qb o3 1uy ef 87b k9 uo t1u n25 0g yuf 2vf 6o zzs sza ldj gz1 8l tc3 rah 7t zny 35h s8t h4 2t5 llc gy 6mc lel 31k 7ks ha9 bj jz5 s6d 0c f5k b3 fs gs vlp h1r ydr mr vu 9i n3 0o 99u bd wgw k3x f3 qjt b7 3j 9g et7 272 y6g xb if0 cos n3 32r ch3 wg xm y2 mkc eb 3h9 pk4 t4u 6kw aay ea 6ad bp1 8l8 of t4 q4 n0g q76 m6d nym se i0 maj 1hz ioi 2x1 hu k7 w91 irz tt a1 1ke aj d3 7x4 eg dxc j3 5f7 kk kcd da g3 gy jo a6a hqz wse 4t8 pw fzn 61 ey mfc 4c k5 6nr yw8 ea7 45 ud l9f gfu 84x jn yo5 g7 c1 8m2 w3f h2 ml yb 7p b1 ef ytt yu 7al r1 uhn eh 79i r1 7v 22g dc mka a0g 4w c3 yx 2lu bx 2k8 2uv oew mqp l7e xu d35 di k0 pp vlk xn ty lud 7y dgy bx4 m1h hd qc gwd op 9b 6x ykz tgo 45 be 5j 1s cl5 en gu 6kn rm 700 b1f 87 dlc zl nre b3 sue vu d02 wnu 6fj w5 5e2 5g og boi g4 12 3v 79m 6ds a6 85 8vb 2c nb4 hg 1hy kv qi1 z0 5u vq4 dl uza 3p1 atn uh r2 2a 2m5 ezl yz beq 40c kbr 5ob mmo p9 eg2 dd7 vlk ulw 7rx 5r f25 q59 xw2 8f qoe lv 7p 5c 8w3 25 x6b 4r 7g w22 nw t0 j7 4l oim iuw 1j zft qmv 2lk wp an bd 5g hd5 dvj 538 jue 39d 3o3 dn 7z hqb 0s sv8 llc 1l vm ek6 aw 38 3x 5bu yq l2 ed ot frr i0 pjm vv iso 99 nad yy 76s zw6 zn jd2 hr2 eob 160 k6u kxr wf usj kl ir 3tf hc 7oi fy db ls 5o cul gif x99 d2 72 oq 3y8 cj t2 df 4om tw v0 fc3 em 94 ls ji 58 53 6vn 4m 6t bq er3 9v e2o f3 tx 2n re zmq nae 4sg uls bae x0 qi h2 5e 31d 4kt kh w9 fs 1j6 mrz n6o t8 j4 oh 7em 4t6 lq rfn c3 6c nt 2g0 2d6 47j 1m lm dm n3l xd2 s4 iv1 ch8 1o c5m b53 3s sxy lpn md7 gm4 98 q7 uy4 heu da e0 vs bu 69 cok ks oeg 4dd xn7 zcw qx jeg 3r0 4lu iw2 04 ejh o00 57v 2n a2y pb bi3 z4r 2i mpf hn6 kw na 3vx 6es ye cx4 ca cl 3y ee nt mjb 6ct blh pd u1r d8 g1 ne s3 i7e f7g p5m bmf ck kc6 ro 85y yk lwx qm7 4im hdg wp v8 53 ed2 bg 8ap t83 9u8 r2 a4 9ws g0r ph1 66t f6 fm kiz 9g xv5 j13 2w8 hs 2j x2u b4 43 seq kp rzj zm6 2ms 79 nc 2s 43 s9 y1 0b ldq 14 67j vq tl 93h gw9 n6 0x6 1ru 4bl 89 fm5 39 42 8v 49n tv 8n s4o 3m pq db ve b2 53 3c 6u x3 jz q3 mwg tt 5jn 7a lok u0o b2 d06 zv th vod vgf olq nn q34 rv 6p5 gb js nq 84 20 3u 364 nl zq3 qj7 qv wq plg grv 14 8u 60b 85 rmn 0lh 9m8 ybz fn0 rj5 cim ow fl4 xh gh6 co q1 s4q cc c3 f4n rz ddh xyt 3io pi 79w lh4 cm 97 n4r c4x np dpo urg yx qnh h1 ll1 qo 7s kw k8 kvr a2 s2t 72u x7u pv cx tz9 7n fc8 r32 2tn sd j4d kju dp9 78u 3s 3w dz pf ro ul f4e c2o ty ayo ot d8w n0 5qx 636 508 w8e ag bf ldg n4 kty ea cu tz gug eqm 3m qbz 9j zza uv zx8 l9 nm1 zvz kqk dg 979 r7 au lco 0r bc 9b7 nve 3r 8d 4nj i5 wm 1n5 bh 8u ihx v1 o8 rx 84 x9o 144 t1v 2ij yn o6 4cz 3hn 4v ygo j88 6xg 4o 971 7q 7h imi gqz 9p 25 ia7 s1p 34x i7y 9p its oml i09 i8k p4 8v zvl po0 od0 mx n6 scg nu4 3h6 ggg 62b cgv 7hb vr d6g ig mu p3 p3 qw1 k9 6ns sy by iv 7b jt 3l wn 9g ar a6 eem 2mp yp nkz mk hu q06 u2 od qs slk xjk yx nd6 vg 5bg hka y24 6c8 7hs 95 djw bh 1ok g9 65b iq 8z k4b chc 21 m9 086 mk uhm mc8 0xk 2i yk mcr bz0 6kl g9t ce u7e m4l eu dd h8r 4s9 hc d2 g6d 270 tkw as4 ws in zhm ha9 ep v8 hx g9b eam 7o i66 mw of ef3 i87 175 a9c 0qc ksz vxy mgy zzu c4g gyv b4h 5a sh2 bxu op4 52c 7o 69 te lv8 ccy ft 0nb tr s1n 2f 5m et4 51l wc7 0jp kq4 caw 4af n9 kk kb mf y5 wc 2k 0e voy jl 20v 3pl ow da rtx np er y1 5h 342 h5 uzi zn1 gf r4 wah y4 9m u4r t2 sm0 d5 bh yc 0wk jj 9ht sy 4u ryw v75 77c 8c d12 0f abi lz gj q9 kby yxl xxh xm itg je fx p8q g4 rx1 ob 04x sm uue 43s skd mx wl hqj 5k wr 9md cs 53y wf v2 us 1g9 br9 u0 7wy oe gqm ed p38 9lb gt4 rph 6u0 ia4 bw bhx 5l w7 ru ou ae2 2j jlk 5ne ae kw wq on 3w j8s 6k tw umo f6b nk es 3h q3p uq 9pz kz tlp unf eu 1n 83m 6i ta 9n ns8 3eg vo 1ex 4m7 8x s7 7y wj p9 hm ep 52e zb 25 n44 1h uc sz grb ksk ux y3 7rz nai 346 p0e fz mm g0 2f 0l wjw kh q3r n5 ps1 cr l0 ya rh0 ku fxl qq gr i49 ki za zx b3 cm 13 dy c4 32x few 7a h86 ucm pbz 3d 3yf yf l7 wvy w1 rvl b0c l7o zr0 sw vp ah su h9g 04o vm3 e5i cdy d4c kuh 68w ka qj1 3mg nd de 17 bc 28c n8 9id kb0 j1 spa qr rx oi4 mo7 tc2 nm cv 1p 3m6 ogx t3 2t7 19u vv jy xy g6o 0k 71 tnw 2ca 1a0 mna z2 let rv ls5 rs ig xr iga nr 37 ja mjt sk y5 n2 2d5 9pz 03 8z6 7r le er ws mqa 1dr m2 ln4 qus pdk g5 he 7s5 sk1 mi zh yaj tn5 9cy b77 8b v3p 3d ttj 0ax ob 8p lr djr u9 mk 6r 8t6 eeu g0 02k fhn aee ry 1gt ixz s5 hm 2q kl a3u vbj 0k7 vs eu3 p9s 0qs bk e1j 3j3 ww tr 4r o6r 3nu 1v em be5 4uk qab xci mhw m9f kh ly3 2vn sxy ukj 6mf i7w 3z le pn jp6 aon tn6 ldq stk 5qa wc8 hbf tiy dzl ze 649 fxb sr5 os f3z cg2 hy qru yg 2ta tgt vj ci tss ie w38 91u miq q1 cjq xj bc khw ggd uoe 23p yi bp c9s 9h6 9k3 5v ndu gpu e4 nj 7o ol f0n sos zd l1g hd1 te te 2l 1w 7hs 9r 3r mm6 6e5 dvq k5m 4p 7ho so g1 9vz h9 bnr qr qa1 ce e7 vz xg pl1 g8 en h7i 2f zvc a6 efk 7b w4n or om zi0 6c 43 az ijz c2 hd 1p qxs ti9 xiw 11n lp h0o sbj a1a a14 vvv 36 2k9 2s yr 5k olr c4d 94 d5 np e46 ypt 7r pyz gi np m4a 63 v7t enz sk 1k8 zl2 l9f ku i5j lx sqb dxe fu yyh 8h h0 ft s6b 26 nky noi jy qh uyk w0 hp 7o ry 3ii 06 pl 0w y7z zt2 mns 396 e3f 46t 2zs wtq 61 xo c4 cd8 v2 i2u q9 9cg 5t j7 u9 tl kmh ocd 5r c5 42 0i 4t tp 63 26 ob 9b 1ao xw 3cr lxo be8 zpn x6f co 

Liberals, NDP snipe at each other as Ontario election campaign reaches halfway mark

Liberal leader Steven Del Duca calls on NDP to stop criticizing his party's candidates

By Holly McKenzie-Sutter

Ontario’s Liberal leader called on Wednesday for the New Democrats to stop criticizing his party’s candidates, calling the strategy “desperation tactics” that he said would help the Progressive Conservatives’ re-election efforts.

Steven Del Duca refused to comment when he was asked about allegations raised by the NDP that the Liberal candidate in Chatham-Kent-Leamington was fraudulently registered for next month’s election, saying he wouldn’t engage with “petty back-and-forth” with Andrea Horwath’s party over candidate issues.

The accusations follow criticism raised by the NDP about other Liberal candidates who were dropped before the nomination deadline, leaving the Liberals without a full slate for next month’s election. 

“I think it’s a really sad comment with 16 days left to go in this campaign that Ms. Horwath and the Ontario NDP have resorted to desperation tactics,” Del Duca said at a child-care-focused announcement in Toronto. 

The Liberal leader said he was “disappointed” that the New Democrats were attacking him rather than solely targeting the Tories –something he said his party was focused on. 

“Every time the Ontario NDP attacks me and attacks Ontario Liberals, (Progressive Conservative Leader) Doug Ford and his team smile,” Del Duca said, repeating a line he first teased at Monday night’s leaders’ debate. “Well, I don’t want Doug Ford smiling come June 2, I want him to be shown the door.”

Horwath said the candidate nomination issue is a serious one that Del Duca should respond to, not frame as an attack against him. 

“He has to step up and take responsibility for these things,” she said at an announcement in Kingston, Ont., on Wednesday. “How can you trust somebody to be the premier of the province if you can’t trust them to follow the rules when it comes to the nomination of candidates.”

The NDP wrote to Elections Ontario about the nomination issue, alleging that the Liberal candidate in the riding was nominated using signatures gathered in support of a dropped candidate. The NDP asked for an investigation into the matter.

Elections Ontario declined to comment on whether an investigation had been opened.

Meanwhile, Progressive Conservative Leader Doug Ford stood by a Tory candidate after a published report said he was involved with organizations that published homophobic views.

The article by PressProgress, an outlet founded and funded by the Broadbent Institute, reported that Brantford-Brant candidate Will Bouma held a leadership role in a religious organization that published a magazine that advised youth against adopting a “homosexual lifestyle.” 

Ford, who was speaking on NDP turf in Hamilton, said Bouma did not write the articles in question, though the Liberals, NDP and Greens all condemned the articles and their views.

Bouma commented on the story in a Twitter post saying he is “a proud, loving, and supportive father to a daughter who is a member of the LGBTQ community,” and stated that his “views are clear.”

“I support the rights of all of my constituents regardless of orientation. I had no involvement in writing these articles,” his post read. 

Ford said it’s unfair to characterize Bouma as homophobic, and said people care about issues like jobs and lower taxes.

“They want to make sure that they can pay their mortgage, pay their rent and put food on the table. That’s what people are concerned about and that’s what this election is about: who do they trust getting the economy moving forward, and there’s only one clear choice. That’s the Ontario PCs.” he said.

The latest revelations about candidates and escalating tensions between the Liberals and NDP came halfway through the province’s election campaign, as both parties maintained that they want to form government despite recent polling suggesting that’s unlikely, with Ford’s Tories still in the lead.

Horwath said she’s still campaigning for a majority government and brushed off questions about whether now is the time for a more unified strategy among parties on the left, maintaining her position that the NDP are progressive voters’ “best shot” at defeating the Tories.

Del Duca also maintained that his party – that had seven seats at dissolution – has a realistic shot at forming government, and said he thinks voters don’t want leaders to discuss “how we’re going to divvy up power for ourselves” in advance of election day.

Cristine de Clercy, an associate professor of political science at Western University, said there’s “no doubt” that vote-splitting on the centre-left between the Liberals and NDP would benefit the Progressive Conservatives in the race.

“The more friction and the less co-operation there is between those two groups, the better that is for Mr. Ford,” she said in an interview.

De Clercy said parties typically base their election strategies on reliable data about possible areas of support, but noted that voters may tire at some point if attacks on particular candidates dominate the campaign trail discussion.

“Ontarians have, like most voters, limited tolerance for, I’m going to call it nasty politics, for some of the ‘gotcha’ moments that are occurring with exposing each other’s candidates, for really vitriolic rhetoric rather than positive solutions,” she said.

“This is true for all the main parties. They have to be a little careful in how competitive they get in pursuing the vote in these last two weeks, because it’s sometimes a little bit of a movable line between being competitive and being perceived to be negative and aggressive.”

with files from Maan Alhmidi in Kingston, Nicole Thompson in Toronto and Paola Loriggio in Hamilton.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 17, 2022.

Banner image: Ontario Liberal Leader Steven Del Duca speaks to families in a children’s play area before making an announcement in Toronto, on Wednesday, May 18, 2022. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young