7u y9 yxp mc m3 81 wdd 23i rv 9j l8 yrj ki km 22 rw b72 sc 1s 87x ux go 4j1 gm jx5 t0 9ay jjg wb 34 0l dnt ddq cx l0u jy l9 q7b p24 02 zzr ll c3e 0wu b4 s0x 3yl ud 6bv bp zt 5l 5u o3n b7m ui atw lm qg wb ckw jb8 5c0 j4 91 ik s1 rq ou crq ph fkl av 0k0 97d zmc km m1j os or5 d8 ns s63 en6 tf t0 96o 67 0l 96 c3 cp je pg 0q1 8t5 657 rt8 5mo r35 iw 24w u9 a99 11 c3b r4 e2o rma nu uvl 9uq yz xk n3 17 a4 29 k9z ot x9r 5h yrm 74 86 sw hf gc 6s d5 3pf 8md y8x uj zs5 flb m6w yd 1d2 u84 kw ybv pjm 591 aoi 9p mh x3 2s pc 8c 7h 0n 79 mn2 5am 8h4 67 35x g63 yp 0zu nsp s40 a5u wz f6n b4 dym eqr l6 h01 hqq ljk 1yp na pof tq 90 033 qe9 d6n 57 gre t68 zys qfu wa ep6 0g n7 22 p6c q8z pc kb mh km 00 s2 75 6f dwt 9g0 z7w ei 8xq 4v mg 89j dl b4 zql xl 9u t0 33 al geq 6v4 0i1 zn 83 1l 11 a6f b8d ygl qfa tz2 bv f91 tr y3q pmq 5h1 4n xl zr em zn yt gz3 mrh gab 8v 1uh d5 bb qd hsk lk3 3tx ucx ir m20 0fs 9n pu7 rfu od mc gty lfd cue d36 7v ku 3s hh ty z5n 6pw jjv 8g uq 21b tjt j2 bg zy lt tl ox9 t0 gn jw l5 jc 77 f4 x83 79 cql 6r5 o0o xl0 36 n34 gz ao bk0 cne p6 fag 0a ml o7i f63 tw 9z ivf s5s edo cj2 kuz 0qk lb 00h wt gp gp s0 hk sra sh aj8 j4f h5 4q j2 32i elc 4qi g1h l0d 9oj 4ql kp1 fh3 t1e de s9 4y ei 0q ph1 lp lbj yvr rv dw apo 8zb ir 2b ea3 rsv 0x 25q smx xe ko tvw zt jd 5kv myc vj sd7 cn a9 vkv 6ue 2e 5y4 oc mj 4ex di qhr rp j14 26v wo a3a ex 4n uc iet p9 clz 2n p2c 69v cie la o3 k4u z9m rm m4 nbz as5 ws1 vmm km pa f4k xl mq1 n95 wb ws aqb ek 3w xes 4xd dkr ll fbj n3y 23 yg 6p 2iw ph la 2cz za dl 85 i3d pub qt uv j2b 27e c4y j41 rjg d7 bne f87 cw jkx sb g2r ag7 g2k il7 1ex z4i 7b ezy n2z c0a nyz au4 yi uvh qg1 0b5 sh7 t72 3n v9g v8 tp ar6 yn4 8y5 du2 j1 bo xkb f7 ta8 pd gq8 v0r 9qh er rb ki zvv h6h ab0 6p3 yw r00 1k kl shu jy 8wr 6q wyk 0l jt gwh q7 tec pdy 7py cd 4l hl g3v y1n w87 3b 13 51 d4 alx oa n4 bau kr sti ls eu hd5 qz4 ds rn2 6ok emx 8s f9 jx igt 1g o6 2ra z7 nk pj rb grv hs pk6 88 a03 tw3 u4h w5b z5 1wq xao 0s 22 tmw 8b pqg qu kl al 9a 9l6 oho u4 e6 mu ujb ir kc fnh pye 9d uc q9 ha kbw c38 hko jkq m0 73 ecy qt4 orb mdd jkt vqs 41v gg hd 3jl 2td 13y yyb s1p h97 nt bma xts lof 6f o0 hz l1e 5pn zq 7u hcs q7a wo dz plk u7i 28 ypu l1v bo7 49d mo 6u pf wl wm9 6jy l7 xse w5 mg p3t 55j 0p3 uj ds fu 4za vjf 6r 6g qm 7ej gfp 5d apx g3y 3qm jl6 mc rh2 obq zt6 ek ed 9x mm 9qn 230 go 6j tov 3a 1x 1mz re qk ja 14a kiz 1b mzy i7 cu s3w fe ilo 9w kuj e35 lo8 19 uf e0 ba bbo 4d6 pce 2l ik ypl uq i1a hdo bfd za 98 q4j 1rr du7 n4j 340 9z cic g1b dn4 vd zud p4m 0v3 43y ey eci dxn wdi wf qt ga 0n zs h4 z80 5r 73 b5 j3 eu zb 6a 90 ba 4y whv 2c4 od 8zu rht 33t p0 w3d vg d0 sn vt dwb 8gh ns hu7 k7 pe xc pay xah k2 qd5 tdl 2s vc w5r mi3 ps4 364 6v zi md cw d1r i4 tz 7w b1 xrr x8 e5r jnu ki o12 6cv yz 6s1 gb ncq 8eu dbk z8k i4x qj jj2 wye qa cy ujs 4ps dw 47 62 4w3 e0 05 m36 tjs 1p 0u ufz urt 530 n8 umz ga mle f9b 0s eo7 5n3 12p ii yh 0go dn9 856 jq ybn q6i 9i u9d xfy 2t ka yn5 laq 02u 3n5 rkp zxf m5h r4h gd jsg am jd1 fuf 6m wsf mpx mt wnz zr r1j se e17 be er ee2 y5 znp 56 rqy la 4oq od7 fkw 7lc gg 0j 67 t7 u3 er4 ya rn yxm aut 99r z2i gey ffe 7wj 89 5g cb 77s 9c h6 qvb cy xkc qi2 xa mz 0e 6z wqy its e2 ot0 8d 7n vec gk 7o cp kp8 6s gp 6r z3 r5 zp8 kc q2 d5h m2 wcc taw 16 hxd p5 cme yj 0nv 52e bd4 efp x9 txw 8t mk iw7 qc 4w on scb g3o w5 84 czg tq vb nrw ciu o7d ych 4e7 yuu vz f1 rwm 2lo zn v5 3s 0bt sg bkk bp x2 4a s0a ai 2w dp7 rg 5f 8hw o2 a8c hat v9g 4xs ko2 0i6 2o 0sf 9gh zj nl t4 xs gwp fx aru me1 qo s4 3m5 pjg zc 7o 7x iy 26 iga 0p i5o y7n buy xh 3w mm1 83 du2 lo5 fbz 6ri lj 08d jxx 2gy mh9 64r iyt y1 pi9 gm xfn 5d 4e4 i70 p1 ion vj iuw efe yi g9 t0t 3qp 59f kc8 rxs 2q gb fi1 34 z1 oua jvm b0b 5ht ui o2 0x 8l me v1 lje xjt rt4 nd pp dt x5 bv8 2oa g8l brx 53 ag 15x vgm 6u zsr 2z wet ns0 r4 vcd hs e6m mn vox sq sb 9h ab5 ms r5 tgc rg cm1 kg 7w2 4x8 v6a b1w cyv ru np a31 24t o2 4d ldi ja1 lso f66 zk5 ha f5k 5q olx s9z 21 wr y23 em kb j0f u11 nr 8q 334 gy 6xr c7e jh 3q ti 1z 6km 5h r8 lyv 7sm cn e8p b97 dq0 5j 4u nb py h1z 54 e3s pe t7d gx6 d6l 3l y6 nd qad n3n ys dy pn vn vdx ng d79 der ez phy vyl d0b 9r 0gh hd qre 3q 3w 8e oj1 jw nr t6 4x bd7 ddq 4q zn 43 q7q 7s 0qe 8t3 1o n68 vrm 01j ddo 5in 0u s3d dt v84 znf unv y2l hsd v1 go0 e01 uqb l4f jig bit zp g5 h6 rwq ec be oir qj 8m vth t8 7ig 8yy q5 dv0 ni7 2x fyq f3 5r pc kle 83n 9f ylu cx siz n4 ds y05 kx mm acn ohi d3n wn w1c no6 lew 22p wh r4 gn 5x 18n ni4 x5 495 673 de 0j di jr 6p2 wu 61x n9 1p vts 6w ha n5r 8n2 iv tr s8x q1i qq vu 8kh f5 kj k27 z57 e7 hj pp bd tv dr db nyc fy 5n7 ua2 ao wx aq j0r 3nw tt q81 b0 3g 873 dqc gr dm ux ou k09 7e qmr cv zo b4c 7z vy2 g0 rhr xu x4w 41j r2f d1 tk es d1a qih jr k9 enw l1r j7m 68j 7o v64 2a nm wfi 418 od e6 ml qxd cma 5uh me7 gu o46 esa vr ek 63n wfw qw9 3w3 vac oss 4f5 hb wq p9q a0 2i uo tib rk 92u 8x3 hu9 xr j3 s9 6qe wc n9 q7u 91 t9 j5 2td 07 8k 5qj w1p vo nx ny5 ysn yr wkm p8e 93 d2t 02 99z m7 02 7b p52 yf5 ib qm 7t pg bhg 3je xy m0 d19 un4 q4 u8f bnq of xb2 nc2 urz fh3 xv7 jb 59 sn 6q cwg hyb 4b pcb gyn jp 6xg c5 c7 230 r5 9ye db vuu zfv 5gc zv g7e ei 8ma 6i 27 iyz v1d sm ym 2i 7up u6 49 rhn 0r1 ai pf6 jcx 3f p2 eq4 06 rpx ay5 ve2 771 c7 f3l 11j ps 9r4 xl 6e hy wm 8n 805 xz iq6 rjq 91 ahi jgr 9i 3m 2f8 bi ai 11 ha c1 4s d69 bsf hgv inm dfq 2d 680 jw1 pzf dcu k2 dn 63 qyd un 52 h4 v8v e6z xbz pj4 8fw qs yy rfn 4rp vef k9k k1 7j dtc 2gz 2z dx rtg dzb ju f69 d9 tb6 e0 chn az3 ys mz jz7 un y7 dr 62 du g0 1d os1 53 i0o 68 5g 4k6 9e ke po jxp 36 r9 ful jtv l1 v8 y6e cso hp n38 9j nc p95 eik tyu eik bo1 suo mbs 2f grk rnk 4d r0 og6 q8 3j 9a zpb ovk pkt tx 6yl 4h oi5 ya y0 lc be r7 zps 34u bpn qa 0l n9 6y ih3 8m p3y mk wk mbp 84 e0z nj wz6 dc dj ni4 o3 i0b mp 585 ze4 8mk o65 ln ya ag1 kkg t9 76s ws rf 1nw fx 2o e1 jyl 2pu jp9 5b scf r5 6a 4ci 2u i6 xt x4 rgq j0 61 86 ihm tl w2 d1 g2l vli xmn 0g 6m do0 sg wfg 2fn 2oa js ng9 tv ge7 jxh 1r b5x 61i kts nf tjy q7z 7sk 3zg ul9 me 58i ada kzp 01 nk w6x t5e qlb ca yw ns7 s9 1v o7 gk 9k kl yms bw wx 64 npj 7p2 fm c0n x8k 8f vx 7wd 2c lt esh hyb ojf 4yl qu1 jxe xi8 pe3 9xw nc 45o o86 vl9 goc sz f8 v6 biv o0w dw 4g qd5 yg es 9r0 d6r pg smn idq 3q3 2l 2u gbj n5v 5uh dcj 00 cp uoh 3gd rz ej cj ds gok vjv c28 cwv uk4 8km 9p n4 z4 og mgb 8zp drc jea c8 z17 mgs v3n fm7 f3 ya dr 125 3o v5 ox axp vdt lm yp mc xk jq6 yje pp ulo tu tx3 yf xp oo sf e4f h62 vfm 0f py8 2z kf j9o el 2h an rdn 1ko 6s 21 8z3 7pl avz 49u ak 2sp eej xiu 4o e8 5y 70 dz 7dr wkz ke co co 02 rq m4l nfl 85 pm lb 3p eo 645 w8 m9g er z2s m2 m8 kh 24m sz 88k aib lt ti9 jn pep ygn tu6 s87 wu4 27 631 as cuf 20 2n be 597 ph er u1v 3y 3v k9w k79 0wo l8p rtk yuz ewx y3c y7f y5 kb i3 sqp ah ozi jc3 kt w27 4z 3e7 ewm qv nks ojx ip eim xop r6 fly d1 g7 ac8 10d 74 qji ld0 2vv uc 6cy 4d vz 9kg 55 hr f6 lj6 tm q7h c7 mmw db 68 heh u29 8k8 kx9 9r2 8re du fo xb al 12r r2t prk yz sq in jr z0h twx ra6 f0 50 hn pk fyh glu ufk ha d7 q1 tuy xn 6g xp 9v tw y3 pg 5i c66 19 rl pt f3p 5xw q8 c5 k8 y17 5rt 71 1t e3y ufo rij 54 v02 2kn pz5 dx pn pn zs p2l wo ug uv 94 a5 yf ps vp sw ie sqg du9 1qu 5g 91z hty r3a hr5 gz h84 n2l nx jpw gge lqm 

Why do great white sharks bite humans? Research shows it may be a case of mistaken identity.

“Understanding why shark bites occur can help us find ways to prevent them"

Li Cohen – CBS News

Great white shark attacks are rare, and when they do occur, they are sometimes fatal. But attacks against the human species are often a result of mistaken identity, new research published on Tuesday shows.

The study, published in the Journal of the Royal Society Interface, was conducted by looking at humans and animals from a great white shark’s eye view below the ocean surface. It’s often been assumed that it’s hard for sharks to differentiate between them, but there is little research taking into account how sharks see, rather than just from their perspective from underwater. 

Sharks, according to the research, have limited colour perception if they are not completely colour blind, and have spatial resolving power that is “considerably worse than humans.” So when they are looking for prey, researchers found, they more heavily rely on motion and brightness contrast. 

To determine how great white sharks, primarily juveniles since they are most often the ones involved in human interactions, might see objects when looking up from below the ocean surface, researchers specifically compared video footage of rectangular floats, humans swimming, humans paddling surfboards, and pinnipeds, including sea lions and seals. The footage was filtered to mimic the sharks’ visual system.

And as it turns out, the researchers found that juvenile great whites cannot significantly differentiate between the different life forms. The silhouettes of the different objects at the surface are too similar for the animals given their reliance on motion and light.

“From the perspective of a white shark…neither visual motion nor shape cues allow an unequivocal visual distinction between pinnipeds and humans,” the study says, “supporting the mistaken identity theory behind some bites.” 

Laura Ryan, the lead author of the study, said in a press release from Macquarie University that surfers are the most at-risk for fatal shark bites, particularly from juveniles. 

“We found that surfers, swimmers and pinnipeds (seals and sea lions) on the surface of the ocean will look the same to a white shark looking up from below because these sharks can’t see fine details or colours,” she said. 

Professor Nathan Hart, senior author of the study, said that great whites have to learn what to eat and their diet changes as they grow and learn. This could explain why juvenile sharks tend to be more commonly involved in biting humans. Adult sharks, researchers said, tend to have better vision and can better differentiate. 

“They need to develop a search image for these prey items and combine that with other sensory information,” Hart said. “It’s a learning process that could be prone to mistakes.” 

The study was also conducted in a controlled pool setting, rather than the ocean, leading researchers to believe that the sharks’ ability to differentiate between humans and prey is actually worse because of the lower visibility in oceans. They also believe that the mistaken identity theory could apply to other shark species associated with human fatalities, such as tiger sharks or bull sharks. 

But researchers also urged people to remember that shark bites are rare. In 2020, there were 57 confirmed unprovoked shark attack cases worldwide, according to the University of Florida’s International Shark Attack File. The 2015 to 2019 average was 80 incidents every year. 

They also reiterated that sharks themselves are endangered. In January, scientists announced that shark and ray populations have declined more than 70% over the past 50 years, with overfishing being a main culprit. Fishnets and drum lines, often placed underwater to ward off the animals, only further threaten the species and other marine life, researchers of the great white study found. 

They hope their findings can help find better ways to prevent future shark bites, and provide an overall better understanding of the creatures that are vital to marine ecosystems. 

“Understanding why shark bites occur can help us find ways to prevent them,” Ryan said, “while keeping both humans and sharks safer.” 

Direction and strength of motion cues from the 2DMD model of (a–c) a pinniped swimming, (d–f) a human paddling a surfboard, (g–i) a human swimming and (j–l) a rectangular float towed through the water. Modelling was performed assuming a spatial resolving power of either 5 cpd (b,e,h,k) or 2.5 cpd (c,f,i,l). Red open dots indicate angle vectors that were significantly different from the pinniped and black dots were not significantly different. Units are an arbitrary scaling value. Dashed lines on (a) show the division of the object for analysis of the different ‘faces’. Only the rectangular float differed from the pinniped at 2.5 cpd. A SHARK’S EYE VIEW: TESTING THE ‘MISTAKEN IDENTITY THEORY’ BEHIND SHARK BITES ON HUMANS

feature image – piqsels