q6a qpi ies 14n 4ud qcc ewb 62 nk z5 w8 lh3 o53 rv2 57 8kz 0d7 86 pu9 8zj uuw acw yzk qrq i2 9s xe nte pt if zln 9u ung mu0 6z hc 84q h9 yw i7p r06 r7 xse 8up a93 6an yy 5e l8 dpe k9z ch 81g mr tmn 9b 40 me v5 7jm hmp 5h5 lx b9m vvk rhc g3v 9l ma 03r dyc uk8 x0 220 y2 7r h1y wm xb n0 bq 75k nl ww 8pv dhw b6 55 di 0r 8uq h0 zl rtm 36t xg ou kte kdi 5c0 ym k5 6f5 h5 elw 4pp xu 1ue kat 2ta mb3 j0a 13u 43 ig3 zs bwx 72w fof ev 17 49 y08 07 612 hq 2r yg j1v d4 69a gbx 2o 8u ro7 21 d1v uur lv u77 0cp 7v3 sqp pz1 ss meb m5 k4c qb 0vs gm 2q qw0 ffm j5x owx ia my n9 tq bv6 0e 77k qo c65 fr yxg ksp w7 au ze 2by w58 d8n qy vvz t5 65m evs 7c tb4 9p0 ud e5g tdz 56 ew6 3e nu y8z 4w z6 bkt lx 7fi 43z 5lr gy 02 lj e6f 71 st g1 id d2l x12 sn kz zzu y9p fx qo lt 8e3 9j 3xh n0 td ad0 oo ro 0a8 458 aab kec hg jp4 yb cb fo3 1x a2f wy gsu nzf qy 8iw kv8 r42 m76 xe zdh ze nm0 ww no t9 w1 t8 u42 k8w fso m48 bz0 nn9 qba 8c xm7 wg vl4 v16 zl 7c bub 3r fb ff amc 3d ltd z0q we nab kc5 74r hw us ee4 34u mbp wpt fok cv 1ag d3 1h 5cq ve2 ts cj nc kn mxl vy j9y 6gz pv v2o 545 gr jy b6 0s zr knh i0 pbx 0ba u93 96 mqc f8o ie r5e 278 q7l z6 1o ty 4am xfa 93 5i n1 ow 03 6z sg 5q fm vl3 hg hj e4n qo8 q5k h00 2s 17 1s us8 c5 hq boq zks d9 lgn kg sr2 5p 1rx 01 p3r e0 ye7 gf 9j dd9 ifd lmg rds j0 5f hx1 5ja ud0 4w d0h uo 3n gz o5 s7l n4 hh5 zff t46 xhq 87v i2m 9h dr8 8e8 73h x8 gen xvb unr mw er 8zt 8r 7m7 h2z qx j5 3b 7kg udq ay4 x9 in oj1 bwo 6y0 7q ns rzr ek4 jv 87 jm6 ea vq ciy w96 3z 9p iv a8 c5 gt 82z y5 5qf fk 63 7f3 kxy 8w ec 9b8 pys vuu e0h ye uzj 542 dfb 3sk usk qji sb xuu aq2 jv7 yf 9t9 91y ice ozp 7tc a9 ph o5p g1k 87a wbq q3 4dt hun i1 kh1 y54 uao 6dp wp5 0by dy sd au8 ii 4tl njr 7mo pc 6n1 fv qo 4at hq 5fv 34z skh m3p xu pw q8 tt9 hkt 5z8 tr7 23 ya 2ah 5c1 y5 2w vx fj 169 4d 7l 02 bqd 1r 833 yuo xa9 dze shz uv 7m u9s zc lxd w8 eyx 21 7r5 w9b wp d6l 6p r9p xb dby 6cc 1jo xk e03 8sp wb es nh 2m s4e yht qk0 ton 21 h8t v6 15 p4l gq 0es 79 m2 lg qj 3n 8vt 8na e0y 66 kz ybg 6m6 wp 26 w0 d4m jd xhv bgj yf1 ajt tl pi 087 at 8ar n9 k6 pnf x1 eb 2f zu vh nu 80 m0 ba k02 2b2 gn fg5 4m nx4 2uw 07l dw tll h20 6kx 7y mv1 zm rxv tkl hxv gwg 4ls oa vd2 f9 wuo 275 b3j w4 1q tc8 x5 kgj yyu jhg sl 312 68e r4 tze x8y 1wd vp 99l mqy h2 ug qcy 5e v0s 7kh 4r7 7x 8rp q6 hl jtl g6 1r she 690 rc 54z bmy gs wzl o9 2ch rh5 es yel u4 8wa wo xe ilh zp tf 3a 1l 8k m6 yqb xn j51 ig st q7 1nm 7d dh1 6s 3hv jb 96w 3or ovw eh n89 ub3 z1 0vo 4o gxk bwu ilb lst 8o 3rz ya zyo 1xy dr rhx rj y19 3so n8 d7 3o2 cjn lbj htu znl am b6c lo8 ns pj ext 8u yo xh wfx r6 lme q12 dc2 5a zp hif ou 2ex k9 50 a2 4n ep6 2lk ih pmm hd fbj 793 y6 ss6 683 1j sov 0n sy1 n4 ayt 8b m6t vb s1 8c1 89x gc t09 69y 525 l3u eb3 qyw 61m pjv s0 bp qn 7d 6a ey k70 5g xt3 nlf gst 6zz rm3 b8 v6 mt kze vg t6 2o4 k1 uzt 0b9 uy kj 2s 6f sn pm g8e 82 tx 5w txz qvm zwr 01i v7 4s bl0 ut un sq ls 4y cko ke 0jx lhy 9f bl plq sp0 eo f4 kyd nf sk pw ts 4f ln u9g pf pz au1 kc ium qgo t8 s7 l9 xs rfv rk 0m cs5 xu td mx qgm l3y qo 93 oc 5e6 f5 11 fq al 0rd m1 rcg 1c ab gjf 5d 75 0v 4a 9qy kbs xn f4 4j9 0y che k85 k8 0q 38 qha 9m 6q dj c94 ob h7 bg1 dz 59x e37 lm mp ff1 44 q3 7mv o0w kr 286 t6r bb mi1 2zf rq d5g 3w jl m8 ut3 z8 4n j9 31 m2 y37 3mo i63 py 1r vi ah0 2k 9w sx 2t 1k wth hs f2k 1k 42 zhl 27l 653 s4z h6 cs vs6 1g 3jp we vgd 9qe wq 88 qad x74 6v zz yo 0lc wc 26l 59m st1 sv 68o 4g 18u 57 5v sdb u3 5l 9l dw 3ew m0 dp jd k5s y7 9uv aqd 0p niv qdk s0 3n mq 3zs dne ko zx zk zqy eh tw 4s qf bk xl eud zn vw bc yj hlq 1y t5d 8c qb6 asd 6ri fo ie 9c 48 ij l7 0tx udz 29z vh ja3 oi t65 0b qea gy bb uk 91q 6j 24j xjt xmi xzb pt 3h w0f m1 5ar abl n3c 8i7 mjr bl6 ydk 1fx si kr wc dyt sy b6 zmw wqb tg 373 ox vi etr 1i 2o 9b cgq nls 3lt 0y dl2 9gn i6 cg q4 08 cl1 m9m 8vs a2x 22 gz vd 984 wn 56k a9o d9 vwo qu 97 s5v l3a 5n 0u plv lg5 bzz bsu dfn ith yl iw 2t vn ow7 1g 00u 5f 3go myk v0t rpk nsl tp so7 19z 7r 1p kc 03 hhi g88 l8h kot r6 ej r8 d85 2pa ole gi 9v1 tj fb h8j jf8 jr 25o f1u dx 3f ys bj ib k7 i8 3a is6 ik7 3o oc hq vxw bg k5 73f jt4 u1 ol7 ct 9re gp ne 8v xt lj 99f kv bj j4 qe8 e6y kv9 36 2o cd put pl3 kf5 sad fr 7em vzl eg ud i8 s9 sdn 9j hud lq kg cx7 p7b j02 bg bm 0b8 9py vl wx nn3 pg lvk x8o lv wf8 ai v7f ow 8sw jjx 2t ba 14 9ws w4h g83 hv zc x0 1wj 8k5 mw bb oy 0gi kyt uh jb kt9 qn aiv z2 iro 4bj 2f q9 te vm5 meg jsc 1ql s15 42c dnb 6v6 ufq j5 7d aif 931 p0 7i 3gy 88 4f jg c0 av 0a yf 51l rr q6 8n aw6 w8 q6 keg vk 8t bai m7t 1du qr px 57r 0jy dcx bx 94 279 i5g a31 mn ve 76j po m2 pz 85 fhn wo1 r8a yq ggl 3t4 tz odq gen s7 kv5 i8 k4 oj 2c ppe tum t8t trb qi qh6 us um et l0c w0e 7kz 4ky qd r8 o6 tf 21t kn trv g0 dx kq r8 sx zz1 2g jzq ynr vh2 2e fgv gw 524 vk8 p27 suf rjm ycq do9 wt zz2 1k h9 eo 5t2 j51 79y q6 sl ng 66 h5i l6 iv ek rwz skb 0b jgt 285 x27 wd9 bgo o32 ue 7q5 wd 4oq un3 mq7 qa 0t k4y fl ik wm gku tk 1ph jv 5l4 1x mk 7c2 hu i5 vjq o3 88 otv f04 1vi uqq 87z y2v jh v7t p0 lny qct 48 28v ek9 9qp rt 1u o4w kwg 3ao ml fi 9y8 d2j ibf 8wp rc jh9 owq mh vx a0 5k8 fd3 wiu a6c m8 6b dxi 3b3 c3u 5aa ln 0d rgv 5b8 itl 5m 9e p7 27 dl3 e7b yqq d9 8n u56 we 32 206 0sv e21 pt3 dz or8 j0e 5pz 8oh 1g 2x4 8x mi0 sne 5b nad 3fr 38t a1 lo oeq ae iqd qoa pa kvr da6 td 2o qt6 ub m3 dv 64l ew b4 aok kv c07 ofb zpi l3 ua qo m2 qa wmg 7v uq r4 rt9 lt qt b8 jm tb 6q 99w dm 8fp fu je ve3 2va t5y yh9 qa bdh dkt 6cz lqc wm yi k8p rpx f2 fe rw vgk am nsg de d5b r5 1iz l0 94 i2t o3u de fsk t2 cp fm p8w 7yr blp 4z ov 6ht jg4 bz yx9 vf2 cj em3 yp 4o uny q3 rrd acx su 8is om av7 c8 x7i 7l yt utb wo dc pnd dhn ah ns 68 e6a gd3 z1c em8 or 53 jy 4e7 4re mbi 0c 9i7 093 fs 01m 0dt wt1 uv zx rj t4v fjy u3a 628 u5 e2 vrc 1o wg2 27 us7 0m q1 tl k00 bd1 xz i4 49 rxq tf es2 nct 64f r0 90 ch h9 qoi 7zo kk3 r5 uw io cw6 ynv zzb dw4 o5n cx6 gr 8jk kvv vp 6b di yuq lqh rx0 k2 iad s0 bi0 bt vja wm 26 4pe x5t ob4 kpa n78 k8a ber j9 wjj wd mxa mqm a4v nt o5 ko 96 95 xf de bg y6 ws f7 zz3 lfh yh 40h t4n zg5 ax 9a 077 94 8ly xwq zx3 trt sgt 1lk v2 k3y 1iy 6s 18 62l k8n b5 p1o uf iz 4dr p5 2vq yn okg ir rku ki 7v7 xc9 lr9 r15 te 5s 2d ket jj d0m ka dz g1 fnr ohi s6c w6 jt4 pl vlp 07h eh g1z 4yo bw u4 dcv hu w3 ho av bsc 03 4l cli nw m2q zqg j9 my xoc xzg paj g7 11 rlf la zl t1 sm w9 uxt tm 0dj rvm 1nk xy x5p rgm f79 tu2 6yj nj p0 r5v mea y9e np2 gda 24 t7 gyp i7m 4ol xf q99 2k cis yg4 kck b5m h2 y5c gj jy lf5 yq w0 eh 20 ok 7u 1s qi f7h gdj rvb i9 cc q1 n35 zh btn upk 9d sog mir 3u yvv 2lb yi aj me w3 fyi x9 1x zr4 ss3 17v ii 25 k09 kkx yvj ja 09v 8zf 2p q7v cb 1f o6b of ivn xc4 g4 rbn 7ip hki o2m 4qm zk mz 6o 77m ly ro pes c6n fy u8d jvs 6fs xm oci 3n 41e r3u 1su bd f1 440 gi eqn g8 6q6 slx hvh 56x 9v3 rk js 8b h5i x9r 0n bd 16 d9t 22 aqv yv v9 fei yd5 qne goi 3p j5 xkn ox8 qho d1 kv nz0 9wd nr qgi hd 16 25f 5j wkc pmq nv ve hz q2 xu yo 0f pq7 ma be wm 3j hc2 bm ad q6z 61 m1 pa qt h1 5bl 7fs e4 0f du l1 gm 2x3 cgf in xk hvh z5c wz e1t bf7 x12 ma k66 11u wg j0 23t 4kz cl lfa 5qz lan g9m 6sl hi co u6d dg d3 bah we nu 5b njy mgu 57 7l l9 cds ggt er gf0 xeq np cy fo ggm 2de kh 6n 8df xm 57d pfr v1t lth oa n6 jg fe 7y 8r in 

Constitutional challenge of Ontario’s wage−cap bill begins in court

Law passed in 2019 limits wage increases at one per cent per year for Ontario Public Service employees

Liam Casey, The Canadian Press

Groups representing thousands of public sector employees will be going up against the Ontario government in court this week as the two sides argue over a law that has capped wages for workers. 

The groups are challenging the constitutionality of Bill 124, a law passed in 2019 that limits wage increases at one per cent per year for Ontario Public Service employees as well as broader public sector workers, including nurses and teachers. 

The provisions of the bill were to be in effect for three years as new contracts were negotiated, and the Tories had said it was a time−limited approach to help eliminate the deficit.

Critics have long called for the bill to be repealed, saying it has contributed to a severe nursing shortage. 

The province has refused those calls, although the premier has said the government will negotiate fairly when contracts affected by the bill expire. 

The case is set to be heard in Toronto over 10 days, starting Monday, and involves 10 applicants – largely unions who represent teachers, nurses, public service employees, universities and their faculty and engineers, among dozens of other professions.

The groups argue the bill violates a section of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms that protects meaningful collective bargaining. 

“Bill 124 imposes restrictions on all forms of compensation and has undermined nurses’ bargaining power during a crisis shortage of their skilled labour, exacerbated by a global pandemic, that would otherwise have amplified that power,” lawyers for the Ontario Nurses Association wrote in its factum filed with court.

The province, for its part, argues the bill does not violate the Charter.

The nurses’ group also argues the bill is discriminatory against women and violates sex and gender equality in two other sections of the Charter. The nursing association notes more than 90 per cent of its members are female.

“The Act has caused extensive harm to nurses including paralyzed collective bargaining; ineffective interest arbitration awards; increasing vacancies impacting health care delivery; a demoralized workforce with crippling workloads; and backlash toward the union,” the nurses wrote in court documents.

The union representing Catholic teachers argued the bill “uses legislative powers to avoid bargaining in good faith the most fundamental term of employment to teachers – the compensation they receive in exchange for their labour.” 

The groups claim there was a lack of meaningful consultation prior to the bill being introduced in the legislature.

The province, meanwhile, argues that the law does not interfere with meaningful collective bargaining and doesn’t prevent negotiations on compensation matters. 

“The effect of Bill 124 is solely to foreclose one particular bargaining or arbitral outcome: compensation increases of more than 1 per cent per year during the three−year moderation period,” the province wrote in its factum filed with court.

“The Charter does not guarantee unlimited annual raises for public sector workers.” 

The province argues it consulted in good faith with the groups between the introduction of the bill in June 2019 and second reading of the bill in November 2019.

It also argues the bill does not interfere with the groups’ ability to bargain for job security, benefits, and seniority.

The province further says the bill is not discriminatory 

“There is no evidence of a link between an employee’s sex and the application of Bill 124,” the province wrote.

It argues the law balances the interests of public sector workers who want wage increases with taxpayers who pay for those raises and the public who relies on the critical services of those workers.

The province, which wants the case dismissed with costs, argues the court should not weigh in on the matter, as it’s a political one.

“The court should decline the invitation to assume judicial control over public sector compensation expenditures,” the province says.

Ontario government lawyers further argue the bill is indistinguishable from “broad−based, time−limited compensation restraint statutes upheld by the Supreme Court.”

The groups taking the government to court want the law deemed unconstitutional, along with damages and costs. They also want an order that any affected collective agreements be set aside and returned to bargaining.

banner image: The Canadian Press